***SPOILERS*** Panic Room's ending wasn't rewarding for me ***SPOILERS***

Spoiler

Forrest Whitaker character (Burnham) being caught by the police at the end just wasn't satisfying for me.

They spent a lot time a lot of time establishing him as very competent, inventive, level-headed and compassionate.

When they found there were people in the house, he wanted to leave. When he was talked into/forced to stay, he calmly took action to secure the house and insure that Jodie Foster and Kristen Stewart would be safe and controlled.

He was strongly contrasted with Jared Leto (Greedy, lying scumbag relative) and Dwight Yokam (violent sociopath who didn't care who he hurt or killed.)

He's the guy who saved Kristen Steward with the Glucose shot.

Leto also suggested that he needed the money, having something to do with his children. So he's not motivated to steal by selfish motives.

And Jodie Foster's family had no claim to the stolen bearer bonds. The "victim" of the crime was dead.

Ultimately, he had left the house and would have gotten away, but he compassionately returned to save the entire family from Yokam the socio-path.

There is simply no reason for the audience to wish that he get caught at the end. We get a cinematic shot of Forrest surrendering and the Bearer Bonds flying away in the wind. But I can't get over that he got caught. For me he is basically the protagonist of the film.

​

https://i.redd.it/yjmwmrwu0bf31.png

Posted Aug 8, 2019, 11:47 PM UTC

010
scaredofcheese•

The bit that doesn’t work for me about that ending is Burnham taking the bonds out of his overall, just to let go of them. It’s only there so Fincher can end with the money blowing away. It’s fat handed for Fincher. He’s usually much cleverer than that.

9
Antman269•

You’re probably right. The movie was ok but the ending sucked they should have given his character a better ending like the family letting him get away.

8
DevonMG•

I also found the film to be a lesser experience than I initially expected. I saw it once and moved on. Perhaps Fincher was trying for something more subtle.

5
TeamStark31•

You misread it...for some reason. Clearly he’s not the protagonist, but he’s not ax-crazy like Dwight Yokam either.

Maybe a villany free villain type character. He doesn’t wish anyone harm and didn’t think they’d be there, but that doesn’t absolve you of breaking the law.

Edit: TV Tropes says he’s an anti-villain, but same reasoning. They’re the opposite of anti-heroes, who do good but have bad traits. They do bad, but have good traits.

4
riegspsych325•

exactly, at the end of the day, he still involved himself with shady people to commit a crime

8
TeamStark31•

Correct. Hence why he’s arrested at the end. He choose to break into the house and still thought he could get the money, even after finding out they were there.

2
PhiladelphiaFatAss•

I felt the same. The film went out of its way to show that he was essentially decent, only to sacrifice him in the end.

I bet Forrest wasn't pleased with it either.

3
podwink•

It probably had more to do with Fincher’s directing style and all the production delays but at the time I remember hearing that him and Whitaker didn’t get along at all.

3
Jerrymoviefan3•

As a diabetic I only remember it as a really stupid movie that got the disease totally wrong.

3
riegspsych325•

He may have been wanting to get the money for good reasons (family) but he associated himself with greedy people who had no qualms resorting to dangerous methods to get their hands on the goods. Burnham was also the one who started to flood the room with gas, an idea that did escalate violently, leaving Leto all burned up on his arm and face. He also had no problem with Raul severely beating the ex-husband that showed up to help Foster and Stewart.

Burnham is not a protagonist by any means, and him giving Stewart the shot and his last second saving of the family from Dwight Yokam's would-be murdering still doesn't redeem him. He is meant to be shown as a tragic character who has brought all of his misfortune upon himself, even if he didn't mean for things to horribly escalate the way they did. He was still just as responsible as Leto/Yokam for what had happened.

Loved the movie though. It was my first introduction to both Fincher and Whittaker

EDIT: grammar and wording

1
hsox05•

I think the POINT is that you end up feeling tragedy for a character that was introduced as a villain. Not all stories end with reward

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0