I'm not confrontational. Help me with my MIL

Advice Wanted

My MIL is a lovely woman. Generally a JustYes.

But she has this habit where she'll call my son "my little boy" and so on. And sometimes when she's holding him and he's looking over at me and reaches for me she'll talk through him and say "Go away, mummy!" which breaks my heart.

I know she misses having a baby boy. Her two sons are grown now and she wishes she had more. But this is my first and only baby and it hurts my feelings when she says he's hers and tells me to go away through him.

I don't want to upset her because she isn't a mean person and I'm not good at conflict. Can anyone give advice on how to gently tell her it hurts?

Posted Aug 9, 2019, 6:17 PM UTC

4619
Abused_not_AmusedEven Satan Hides When She's Pissed!•

Have DH talk to her. He needs to let her know she’s being hurtful to his wife and alienating his son from his mother every time she says “Go away, mummy.”

As an aside, saying what she says IS mean, not very nice at all. The next time she says that, you need to remove your child from her grasp, and simply state “That is NOT a very kind thing to say. Why would you tell a child to say such a thing to his mother?” Put the question to her so she can think about what is coming out of her mouth. You might even ask her how she would feel if someone said that in her presence to her.

41
SomeSeeAWish•

This is perfect because it's true. She isn't being nice. I started all my old posts with "my ILs are really nice..." Because I felt like I was the problem, but I wasnt, and neither are you. I suggest you do just what pp suggested. I hate confrontation too, but sometimes we really have to be tough. Turning the question on her is good because YOU aren't doing anything and maybe she needs to realize how inappropriate she's being. And DH really needs to shut her down, this is parental alienation, even if unintended (which I doubt it's unintentional, because really who here can say theyd EVER behave like that with someone else's kid. She knows she can say it and get away with it).

15
blueberryyogurtcup•

Just in case she really is a Just No and has only been hiding it well, I might go at this from a slightly different angle, and not tell her that this hurts you. Just Nos do not care if they are hurting you, they only care about what they want. So if you point out to them that their behavior hurts you, they might pretend to care, but in the long run, it won't change anything, and they will have ammunition they know hurts you, for later use.

Instead, maybe try to point out that her saying things like this is "inappropriate behaivor" for a gramma, that you are SURE she doesn't mean to sound like she is trying to alienate you, his mother, but other people might think so. I certainly think so. I would never say something like that to the mother of my grands.

Or to go more gentle: "MIL, I know you want to hold him, but he is going to learn to trust you better if he knows that when he wants me, you let him come to me. That's how babies learn trust."

14
boscobaby•

I dont think she is nice, I think she sucks. Being jealous of a child's love for its MOTHER is spectacularly shitty.

8
BabserellaWT•

Your SO needs to reign her in, not you.

7
_Green_Kyanite_•

It sucks, but you're going to upset her regardless of how nice you are. People don't like being corrected. Even nice people don't like it.

Instead of focusing on avoiding hurt feelings, I'd suggest asking yourself this-

Which is nicer? Letting someone (hopefully) accidentally upset you over and over again, while you stew in those feelings and let that anger and resentment build up?

Or quickly addressing the problem (camly, but quickly) before it builds into something relationship damaging?

Being polite, but upfront, is usually the nicest way to address problems with other people. So yeah, it sucks, but it is ultimately the kinder way to go.

It's also kinder to refuse to allow her to brush the comments off because that doesn't resolve anything and will just breed resentment.

7
NYCTwinMum•

There’s not gentle with this kind of abuse. Have you DH tell her: “Please stop that. That’s MY child not yours. It’s hurtful and if it continues there will be longer periods between visits”

6
ILoatheCailou•

I think you can be very honest with her and tell her “please don’t say things like that. It hurts my feelings.” It’s honest, polite and if she has a problem with it that’s on her.

5
BeckyDaTechie•

It’s honest, polite and if she has a problem with it that’s on her.

And it's revealing OP's weak points if this is yet another "The incubator functioned correctly, now I need my Sonsband to divorce it so I can be The Once, Future, and Forever Mother again!" MIL.

With personality disordered and otherwise difficult people, it's often wise to play your points of pain close to the vest.

1
robinscats•

Keep repeating to yourself that standing up for yourself is NOT being confrontational. She's displaying behaviors that you don't like and it's okay to say that you would prefer she not do it. She may get her nose out of joint, but that's on her and not you.

You are NOT being confrontational. Say that in the mirror to yourself over and over until you really feel it and believe it.

4
MeteorMeatier•

"silly mil! Baby boy would never say that!" then take him from her for a cuddle. Don't give him back.

Or if you wanted to be more direct "what?! That's crazy mil, why would you say that??" take him from her and walk away

4
Igetnosatisfaction•

When MIL says, "my little boy," correct her and say, "Yes, he is your little grandson."

When she talks through your son, "Go away, Mummy." "MIL, hand me my sweet boy." Literally take him out of her arms. Or, if you are feeling bitchy, "Mummy, get me away from this crazy old bat."

3
BeckyDaTechie•

"Mummy, why does Grammy think I'm a puppet for her to be rude to you with? That's weird."

2
LetsTacoBoutShit•

If she is reasonable just telling her your feelings should fix the issue. Your husband could talk to her too. Or you could just ignore her completely when she says stuff like that and take your son out of her arms without asking or hesitating at all. She might stop if she sees it doesn't work. I hope you get things sorted out!!

2
botinlawMOD•

Quick Rule Reminders:

OP's needs come first, avoid dramamongering, respect the flair, and don't be an asshole. If your only advice is to jump straight to NC or divorce, your comment may be subject to removal at moderator discretion.

^(Full Rules) ^(|) ^(Acronym Index) ^(|) ^(Flair Guide)^(|) ^(Report PM Trolls)

Resources: ^(In Crisis?) ^(|) ^(Tips for Protecting Yourself) ^(|) ^(Our Book List) ^(|) ^(Our Wiki)

Other posts from u/MakingBadDecisions:


^(To be notified as soon as MakingBadDecisions posts an update) [^click ^here.](http://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=botinlaw&subject=Subscribe&message=Subscribe MakingBadDecisions JUSTNOMIL) ^(|) ^(For help managing your subscriptions,) ^(click here.)


^(I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please) ^(contact the moderators of this subreddit) ^(if you have any questions or concerns.)

1
Zanryu1993•

“I know you’re just playing, and I tell myself that every time, but in the back of my mind it hurts to hear you say that.”

Honestly the most polite, least accusatory way I could think of handling it. I get what you mean, my SO always jokes around with our daughter trying to get her to say she loves mommy, but not daddy - sometimes it’s a game, sometimes it hurts.

1
ohrettano•

She WANTS to hurt OP

-1
Zanryu1993•

See, judging by what OP has said about her, I doubt that very much.

3
BeckyDaTechie•

"It's not like you to be that rude, MIL. Did I do something wrong for you to feel it's alright to say things like that to me? I'm his mother."

1