Villification of Soy

Rant

Have a distant cousin (nonveg) telling me 'I don't eat soy'-I am trying to explain that while eating nothing but soy is a bad idea (as it would be with any food), soy is not in and of itself evil. That there are countries where soy is a big part of their traditional diet, and they don't seem to have erupted into widespread infertility and gynecomastia, etc. Got nowhere with this.

Trying to explain the pesticide food chain here, the idiocy of mad cow (all it would take to prevent bovine spongioform encephalopathy, would be to stop feeding cow to cow and yet somehow they won't even do that damnit!), and still getting nowhere.

Ugh!!!

Not going to bother sending her links about the association between the livestock industry and global warming.

I didn't even try for vegan! I was just trying to say that soy is healthier than red meat! Is this such an off the wall notion?!! Are people really that unaware of this?

Posted Aug 12, 2019, 3:00 AM UTC

1512
solomonroots•

This is a good article on examine.com which is sort of a skeptic's guide to supplements and foods. Link

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1

Yeah it sucks I’ve had my mom repeatedly tell me eating too much soy will give me breast cancer, and then I show her some research against it and it gets completely ignored

5
SeekingApathyOP•

hmm...is she consistently getting mammograms per doctor's recommendations? And doing self exams? You could turn this into something beneficial/ make the breast cancer fear halt...

3
hamster_avenger•

Yeah some people are super ignorant and there is a lot of bad information out there... You rock for trying to educate.

2

After I went vegan and people would tell me how bad soy is I started noticing that it’s in most processed foods. So these people who “don’t eat soy” are usually eating soy as they’re telling me not to eat soy. It’s... interesting.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
hereitcomesagin•

Some of us are genuinely sensitive to soy and need to avoid it. If you are not one of us, knock yourself out!

So here's my request to vegan food developers: a fake burger that has no grains other than rice, no soy or corn products. You could get lots of umami from braised mushrooms, garlic and onions. Bind it with rice flour? TIA. Also a sausage crumble with same limits.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
hereitcomesagin•

I feel for her. Soy is in almost everything processed, in one form or another.

1

Does she eat cows....if so, she eats soy....that cow has eaten way more soy than she would ever eat herself. If she wants to avoid soy she needs to stop eating cows.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1