Isometric fans: what do you dislike about isometrics rpgs?

I love isometric-style rpgs. Played and loved the classics (Baldur's Gate/PST), and I liked most of the new generation (which came with lots of quality-of-life improvements, but a reduction in actual gameplay and storytelling, I think).

Here is my list of things I would like to see done differently:

- Generic fantasy setting. It was already pretty tired when they did it in Baldur's Gate, the fact that we're still getting so much wizard/dragon/dungeon content is a little tiresome. I'd love more off-the-wall fantasy like PST, and scifi. Modern, Victorian, steampunk, Dark City weirdness - there are just so many other kinds of settings we could have and we see so little variety.

- Related to the above: over-reliance on DnD as a template. You don't have to have fighters, wizards-as-glass-cannons, clerics-as-healers, etc. This has wormed its way into rpg mindsets so much that most people don't even question it, it's just taken as a given that that is how things have to work.

- The need to go barging into people's houses and asking them if they have any quests for me. I never liked this tradition of needing to poke your nose into every peasant's kitchen just in case there is an awesome side-plot hiding behind their missing cat side-quest.

- Inventory clutter. I have enough trouble keeping my real-world possessions organised. I'd really appreciate games cutting down on piles of ingredients and consumables (that I will never use).

What conventions do you think could and should be different in the genre?

EDIT: I should acknowledge that there is more variety than I am suggesting. For me, at least, that isn't much good, because I don't find post-apocalypic settings very interesting and turn-based combat is a big downside for me (it's not a deal breaker, I loved DOS2, but I much prefer RTWP), so that all reduces the options a lot.

Posted Aug 15, 2019, 11:12 AM UTC · edited

5796
Loading comments…