Network Design Review

New Hardware

Hi All,

Thanks to a particularly disastrous lightning strike I get to rebuild my entire network. Since I'm starting from scratch I'm looking to build a complete Ubiquiti system over my whole property. Unfortunately, I'm just a guy with minimal Google skills and no IT/Network Admin experience so I'm hoping to get some feedback from the community here about my planned setup.

I'm looking to cover 2 homes (1 (mine)=~2,500sf, 2 (my parents)=~4,000 sf or more?) and a detached garage (~3,500 sf). The homes are already wired together with Cat6 cable I installed a couple years ago in order to share my internet connection with my parents since they're too far off the main road to get their own connection from the cable company. The garage is not physically connected and I'm really not looking to trench a cable over there unless there's absolutely no other choice. I do have good line of sight from my back room where all the network gear will be located to the side wall of the garage though.

Once it's all set up I'd like to have several wireless networks available for use. One for my home automation, which will need internet access since I have Nest cameras. One for the houses. One for the garage. And one for my kids so I can limit their access.

I drew a map of the property with the equipment I'm looking at using here.

I also drew a map of my planned network here.

On to the questions:

  1. Do I actually need the Cloud Key? I'm not opposed to buying it if I'll see a real benefit, I just don't want to have it for no reason.

  2. Is that enough access points? My current (now dead) network incarnation has a single router in my house (House 1) and 2 old routers running as APs in House 2 which provides pretty decent coverage throughout. I know I can add more later but I'll happily add them now if they're going to be needed.

  3. For the line of sight connection on the NanoBeams does it matter if there's an elevation difference between them? I'm planning to wall mount them so will I need to shim one to angle it upward toward the other?

  4. Did I pick all of the necessary equipment to make this work?

I'd love to hear any feedback you all have. Suggestions, questions, comments, anything you've got.

Thanks in advance for the help!

Posted Aug 15, 2019, 4:40 PM UTC

315
julietscause•

Do I actually need the Cloud Key?

You dont need the cloud key, if you want the controller features you can just download it and install it on a computer.

Are you planning on using VLANs/Guest SSIDs? If so then you will need a controller up and running.

If you dont plan on deploying that, you might be able to get away with just using the mobile app for configuration

https://help.ubnt.com/hc/en-us/articles/115012360487-UniFi-Getting-Started-with-the-UniFi-Mobile-App

Is that enough access points? My current (now dead) network incarnation has a single router in my house (House 1) and 2 old routers running as APs in House 2 which provides pretty decent coverage throughout. I know I can add more later but I'll happily add them now if they're going to be needed.

Honestly no one is gonna be able to answer that, too many variable when it comes to your place/wireless in general. Start with it and then you can add more later if you need coverage

For the line of sight connection on the NanoBeams does it matter if there's an elevation difference between them? I'm planning to wall mount them so will I need to shim one to angle it upward toward the other?

For your environment it should be fine

4
DivisionMatrixOP•

I'm still reading about VLANs (I just started trying to learn about all this a couple days ago when my frankensteined network got fried) but I think that's the way I want to go to separate the different networks. If I need the controller running 24/7 to do that then I'll stick with the cloud key. Thanks for your help!

1
julietscause•

If I need the controller running 24/7 to do that then I'll stick with the cloud key. Thanks for y

You dont need a controller running 24/7 for VLANS, you just need the controller to make the advance configuration (you can make the changes and then leave the controller off after that).

Guest network function requires a controller to be up 24/7/365

1
redbluetwo•

Captive portal needs the controller otherwise just having basic guest isolation should be fine. ex: isolated guest network that still uses standard wpa2 password setup. Controller is nice to collect logs and monitor stuff too. Unless I missed something recent.

2
itstaylorham•

Seeing as how you were a victim of lightning once already, CAT6 surge protectors for any outdoor AP's or devices, and surge protectors for everything inside to plug into. A whole-house panel surge protector is also not a bad idea to knock down incoming surge before it hits your surge strips/UPS's.

2
DivisionMatrixOP•

I have 6 of them in my cart already! I had surge protection previously but I think this was just a direct hit that no amount of protection was going to stop, I wasn't home but my mother later told me that it sounded like a giant slapped every window in the house at once.

1
Drives_A_Buick•

Depending on exactly which VLANs you want to be available where (in particular, at your parents' house), you may need to upgrade the Netgear to a managed switch. For example, if you wanted their wired network to be on its own VLAN -- while making all SSIDs available on the two APs in their house -- then the Netgear wouldn't accomplish that.

The US-8-60W would serve this purpose -- and also clean up two PoE injectors -- while "only" costing USD $50 more.

2
Drives_A_Buick•

P.S. You don't need the Switch8-150W. (Unless there are other PoE devices intended to be deployed in your house ["House 1 / 2500sf"]-- that is not in your diagrams):

  • UAP-AC-LR consumes ~7W max;
  • NanoBeam 5AC Gen2 consumes ~9W max;
  • CloudKey consumes 5W -- although I have read in some forums people suggest that you should power CloudKey via USB, and not PoE, for reasons that I forget... [I don't use CloudKey]

so you are nowhere close to 150W... the 60W version is plenty. That'll save you USD ~$80 or $90, which can pay to upgrade the Netgear to a managed 60W.

2
DivisionMatrixOP•

Will the 60W switch power all of those? I thought I read that either the APs or the NanoBeam needed the 24V poe, not just the 802.3 (or whatever the standard is)? Or am I misunderstanding how all of that works? If so I'll happily get 2 of the 60W switches and replace the Netgear one too.

1
derfmcdoogal•
  1. I would. They are cheap enough and nice enough to have on hand. I've read way too many tales of people that set it up with their computer and then... Formatted their computer, or lost their drive, or whatever without a backup.
  2. Really depends on the house, structure, etc. "Probably" is my guess based on my own house.
  3. As long as there is line of sight, you'll be fine. I have an elevation difference between my house and detached garage. it works fine. Can push 480mb across it.
  4. I believe so. The US-8-150 will power both the UAP and the Nanobeam. If you aren't putting a POE switch at the parent's house, you'll have to use the power injectors. You may want to consider another US-8-150 for the garage to power both the Nanobeam and UAP that is in there. But I know those switches are stupid expensive for what they are...

Not sure what you are getting at with your Wireless Network assignments. I don't know why you would want to advertise a separate network specifically for your garage. Doing this your devices may wander between the garage and house. What I would do (just my opinion)

My SSID

Parents SSID

IOT SSID

Kids SSID

Separate VLans. But you'll need smarter switches to handle VLan traffic at the parent's house and the garage.

I believe 4 is the maximum you can broadcast (not sure, don't bite my head off if I'm wrong.)

2
DivisionMatrixOP•

Thanks for the input! I was wanting a separate SSID for the garage since my dad and a few of his friends work on their cars back there and I was going to give them their own network. Since I'm going to get the Cloud Key I may change up those assignments and just have a guest network too so I don't have to keep giving out the password to my main network.

I'm thinking I may just buy 2 more of the switches and give each location a managed switch. They're not that expensive when compared to the total price of all this anyway, especially if I can get away with the 60W ones instead of the 150W.

Also, I think you're right about the 4 SSIDs per AP. And I'm certainly not biting anyone's head off! I've spent every second of free time for the last 2 days learning everything I can about networking but that just means I've gone from completely clueless to mostly lost.

1
derfmcdoogal•

The US-8-60 will only power AF access points. The NanoBeam bridge runs off 24v Passive POE. So, remember that... The US-8-150 is the only smaller switch that will do BOTH 24v Passive and AF.

I believe you can manually select which networks are broadcast by each AP. So you could tell the garage AP to broadcast a "Guest" network instead of your Parent's network. Or maybe you don't have IOT things out there and could drop off that network.

2
DivisionMatrixOP•

The US-8-60 will only power AF access points. The NanoBeam bridge runs off 24v Passive POE. So, remember that... The US-8-150 is the only smaller switch that will do BOTH 24v Passive and AF.

Ok, so I did read that right. I picked the 150W since I saw that the APs and Nano both said 24V. I may get the US-8 since it's cheaper and just use the injectors for my parents house then. Would I even need a switch in the garage? All that's going out there is an AP and I was planning on using the included poe power supply and connecting the APs poe injector to the LAN port.

Great point about the SSIDs per each AP! I didn't even think about the fact that I can have different ones for each one. The IOT network is only at my house, not my parents or the garage.

1
derfmcdoogal•

I've never tried going nanobeam directly to a UAP.

Also note, the newer UAP_LR units you are talking about use AF POE not 24v passive. Though BOTH are out in the wild so to speak.

2
curving_edge•

I think the max is 8 SSID if you turn off wireless link monitor. If you wire all APs you don’t need it on. Also if you are using a USG you can setup a radius server and create client logon that places them on the correct vlan and run one SSID for everyone, an IOT and I run a SSID that is Mac filtered for devices that aren’t 802.1x. Also a guest captive portal.

1