Several AFK Bot Accounts win Savo Island Premium ship contest while ruining hundreds of games for us real players.
I just clicked the news blurb and had to do a double-take when I recognized several of the names listed as Top Scorers (not all of them, several of the winners are real players and several other of the winners are not humans)
They're AFK bot accounts that do not play the game at all, they go 10,000-20,000 games where they do 0 damage per match and they just queue 24 hours per day 7 days per week, so they won many of the premium ships from the contest without even shooting an enemy once
It's not that wargaming hasn't been told about these people, I personally sent wargaming support tickets with half a dozen replays for the AFK botter accounts where they join games 24 hours a day, shoot at the open water, drive in a circle, crash into an island, never once reacting like a human in any way, they only make random movements purely to defeat wargaming's useless AFK-detector (that only penalizes the people who don't move at all, not the fake players who just go in a circle the whole game AFK)
Example you can publically read from the stat cards of one of the winners
830 Fuso co-op games 2993 average damage 93 XP, only killed 3 ships with the guns, got 42 kills with the secondaries by sitting AFK at the corner while the bot drives into him.
Wargaming corporate is so pro-botter-accounts that the official Wargaming Support website removed the category for bots/cheater/fake-accounts entirely and they ignore reports even if you send them replays of 10 games in a row where the cheater has driven at random into a mountain and never shot at a single ship the entire match. They tell you the auto-detection will just do their job for them, but the auto-detection (like so many wargaming programming) is entirely broken and cannot detect bots.
One of the two bot accounts managed to set his stats to private after 10,000+ afk matches and paid to rename his account (maybe after the account was purchased on ebay or g2a), but wargaming has the report tickets and the replay files and wargaming can see his actual stats, they simply don't choose to help their paying customers from these AFK botters.
It'd be pointless for us to spend money on wargaming items if they're allowing people who aren't even playing the game at all to get the same items for free just by having a cheat program drive in a circle.
I have a folder full of replays of these bots doing their afk-farming game after game after game without wargaming bothering to ban them if anyone is unconvinced of the very definite reality. Message here or in PM if you'd like proof. The player's stat-page is already proof enough but combined with the replays it's impossible to deny that wargaming is failing to ban the fake accounts.
Posted Aug 15, 2019, 6:44 PM UTC
Yes, agreed.
Bots are also exploiting the refer-for-cash scheme.
Is this an appropriate time to ping u/sub_octavian?
He doesn't care. I've told sub_octavian and mrConway and @WorldofWarships on twitch and their support department and some other employees, wargaming simply doesn't have any interest in these bots ruining thousands of games (which is why Wargaming Support removed the Botter category from reports and why they copy-paste a BS response to just rely on auto-detection even though botters have done 20,000+ matches while auto-detect never bans them)
Unless wargaming starts paying support employees to do their job and ban cheaters, none of their employees will solve this problem. I got one 20,000 game cheater banned last year after talking to a half-dozen employees, but in the effort it took to get them to do their jobs a single time, the cheaters just make 500 new accounts that don't get banned.
I never understood why they removed the bot report function. Its an effective system, if a person is getting multiple bot reports per game, they are probably most likely a bot. Its essentially a turing test.
bUt AbUsE
Having played WoT for a few years, I can tell you this system wouldn't work with that community unless you implemented some sort of punishment for over reporting.
It's quite easy to do a combination system, using player reports for short-listing for consideration the players who statistically get reported way abnormally and then having employees manually check to guarantee the end result before taking any serious action.
With very basic statistics, it's easy to find if someone is a fake-report-spammer if they're always reporting people that nobody else reports and who isn't the account that does thousands of 0 damage games. Anomaly-reporters can be automatically hidden, so the employees are manually checking the credible reports with no time spent on that one guy upset about getting sunk by somebody.
Systems like this, where the playerbase generate reliable cheater-detection in aggregate (like a Recaptcha, one person will give a fake answer, but use the test on a thousand people and the Law of Large Numbers results in getting the right answer reliably) and then a human employee gives final oversight, are popular in many multiplayer video games around the world. Stuff like League of Legends, Starcraft II, FPS games.
It's not at all unusual to have players bringing things to attention and then employees taking action, the unusual part is wargaming doing the opposite of all the good gaming companies and trying to discourage and ignore customers efforts to get proven cheaters off the system. WG is the first major publisher I've seen actively remove bot-reporting options to actually try to make life easier for those malicious actors. Not only does wargaming support not do their job by punishing the 10,000+ AFKer, but they tell people "in the future you shouldn't bother telling us about that person" It's pure insanity.
It was probably used more often to report non-bot players than to report actual bots would be my guess.
I've been working with them on fighting bots and the hacks that have been more available since 2017, and nothing, nothing, nothing.
For the first time in my history of Clan Battles, an opposing team actually had a couple hackers. Not naming anyone yet, replay's in WG's hands, we'll see what they do. Might post it to youtube with an exploit breakdown if I feel like making the time.
i'll bet he wont react or at best with some generic wg bs
Correct. If he does respond, it will be to double down and go on the defensive, while maintaining the facade of a measured, reasonable response - just like he did with his "100% optional guide to communication".
BuT hE's mAh fAvOrItE dEv EvaH. So InVolVEd!
What do you imagine Sub_Octavian would do?
I don't have an imagination.
Something more than nothing, which so they've done so far.