Several AFK Bot Accounts win Savo Island Premium ship contest while ruining hundreds of games for us real players.

Discussion

I just clicked the news blurb and had to do a double-take when I recognized several of the names listed as Top Scorers (not all of them, several of the winners are real players and several other of the winners are not humans)

They're AFK bot accounts that do not play the game at all, they go 10,000-20,000 games where they do 0 damage per match and they just queue 24 hours per day 7 days per week, so they won many of the premium ships from the contest without even shooting an enemy once

It's not that wargaming hasn't been told about these people, I personally sent wargaming support tickets with half a dozen replays for the AFK botter accounts where they join games 24 hours a day, shoot at the open water, drive in a circle, crash into an island, never once reacting like a human in any way, they only make random movements purely to defeat wargaming's useless AFK-detector (that only penalizes the people who don't move at all, not the fake players who just go in a circle the whole game AFK)

Example you can publically read from the stat cards of one of the winners

830 Fuso co-op games 2993 average damage 93 XP, only killed 3 ships with the guns, got 42 kills with the secondaries by sitting AFK at the corner while the bot drives into him.

Wargaming corporate is so pro-botter-accounts that the official Wargaming Support website removed the category for bots/cheater/fake-accounts entirely and they ignore reports even if you send them replays of 10 games in a row where the cheater has driven at random into a mountain and never shot at a single ship the entire match. They tell you the auto-detection will just do their job for them, but the auto-detection (like so many wargaming programming) is entirely broken and cannot detect bots.

One of the two bot accounts managed to set his stats to private after 10,000+ afk matches and paid to rename his account (maybe after the account was purchased on ebay or g2a), but wargaming has the report tickets and the replay files and wargaming can see his actual stats, they simply don't choose to help their paying customers from these AFK botters.

It'd be pointless for us to spend money on wargaming items if they're allowing people who aren't even playing the game at all to get the same items for free just by having a cheat program drive in a circle.

I have a folder full of replays of these bots doing their afk-farming game after game after game without wargaming bothering to ban them if anyone is unconvinced of the very definite reality. Message here or in PM if you'd like proof. The player's stat-page is already proof enough but combined with the replays it's impossible to deny that wargaming is failing to ban the fake accounts.

Posted Aug 15, 2019, 6:44 PM UTC

37177
SynpaxEnterprise•

Yes, agreed.

Bots are also exploiting the refer-for-cash scheme.

Is this an appropriate time to ping u/sub_octavian?

115
VanzigOP•

He doesn't care. I've told sub_octavian and mrConway and @WorldofWarships on twitch and their support department and some other employees, wargaming simply doesn't have any interest in these bots ruining thousands of games (which is why Wargaming Support removed the Botter category from reports and why they copy-paste a BS response to just rely on auto-detection even though botters have done 20,000+ matches while auto-detect never bans them)

Unless wargaming starts paying support employees to do their job and ban cheaters, none of their employees will solve this problem. I got one 20,000 game cheater banned last year after talking to a half-dozen employees, but in the effort it took to get them to do their jobs a single time, the cheaters just make 500 new accounts that don't get banned.

84
Carrier_Hoshotwitch.tv/carrier_hosho•

I never understood why they removed the bot report function. Its an effective system, if a person is getting multiple bot reports per game, they are probably most likely a bot. Its essentially a turing test.

49
eggfacts•

bUt AbUsE

19
Rudy_13Wheraboo Slayer•

Having played WoT for a few years, I can tell you this system wouldn't work with that community unless you implemented some sort of punishment for over reporting.

11
VanzigOP•

It's quite easy to do a combination system, using player reports for short-listing for consideration the players who statistically get reported way abnormally and then having employees manually check to guarantee the end result before taking any serious action.

With very basic statistics, it's easy to find if someone is a fake-report-spammer if they're always reporting people that nobody else reports and who isn't the account that does thousands of 0 damage games. Anomaly-reporters can be automatically hidden, so the employees are manually checking the credible reports with no time spent on that one guy upset about getting sunk by somebody.

Systems like this, where the playerbase generate reliable cheater-detection in aggregate (like a Recaptcha, one person will give a fake answer, but use the test on a thousand people and the Law of Large Numbers results in getting the right answer reliably) and then a human employee gives final oversight, are popular in many multiplayer video games around the world. Stuff like League of Legends, Starcraft II, FPS games.

It's not at all unusual to have players bringing things to attention and then employees taking action, the unusual part is wargaming doing the opposite of all the good gaming companies and trying to discourage and ignore customers efforts to get proven cheaters off the system. WG is the first major publisher I've seen actively remove bot-reporting options to actually try to make life easier for those malicious actors. Not only does wargaming support not do their job by punishing the 10,000+ AFKer, but they tell people "in the future you shouldn't bother telling us about that person" It's pure insanity.

22
MrErickzon•

It was probably used more often to report non-bot players than to report actual bots would be my guess.

1
Purity_the_KittyEven I Say Remove CVs•

I've been working with them on fighting bots and the hacks that have been more available since 2017, and nothing, nothing, nothing.

For the first time in my history of Clan Battles, an opposing team actually had a couple hackers. Not naming anyone yet, replay's in WG's hands, we'll see what they do. Might post it to youtube with an exploit breakdown if I feel like making the time.

1
hypsss•

i'll bet he wont react or at best with some generic wg bs

21
flimbo59•

Correct. If he does respond, it will be to double down and go on the defensive, while maintaining the facade of a measured, reasonable response - just like he did with his "100% optional guide to communication".

21
StevieSlacks•

BuT hE's mAh fAvOrItE dEv EvaH. So InVolVEd!

7
flimbo59•

What do you imagine Sub_Octavian would do?

3
SynpaxEnterprise•

I don't have an imagination.

10
BonzoTheBossRoyal Navy•

Something more than nothing, which so they've done so far.

1
VesseryWG•

Thank you for raising this issue.

We conducted an investigation and the results show that several accounts, including some winners, are considered bots. They will suffer the standard penalties for botting and will be removed from the winner's list. As a result, winners will be changed, and those who got lower places, will get rewards for the place they already got, and the place they will get after adjustment of the list.

We are very sorry for the situation and will plan our further events in a way that won't encourage botting and will adjust bot checks accordingly.

Thanks again, and please, send me your in-game nickname and your most-desired tier VIII premium ship (which available now in shop) – we believe initiative such as this should be celebrated. Also, please, could you send me your CS ID tickets, we will check them additionally.

30
OnlinePresence897•

Color me impressed!

6
VanzigOP•

I sent the requested info, with 3-4 tickets on at least one winner which has gone back over 3 months without any followup. I'm glad at least in this case a few of the most egregious violators won't get free prizes for the vast amount of games they messed up for real players.

We're not trying to create a lot of extra work for wargaming, just to communicate there has to be a more streamlined way to help us help you because the current auto-detect simply does not work. If it did work the guy would not get away undetected for 3-12 months straight and 5,000-10,000 incidents without getting punished.

I play many other online games and they seem to be doing fine with a support option to report flagrant cheaters and their support doesn't respond that I should not bother letting them know or sending in evidence. Removing all support options and responding only with that copy-paste dismissal no matter what someone shows (I told them auto-detect is broken for months in a ticket with 6 replays showing it was true) cannot be fine if the auto-detect cannot accurately spot super obvious, totally blatant ones.

If this is the time that changes actually get made, it will make me and a lot of frustrated people quite pleased. We want this to be a game that we play, so we're hoping the best outcome for both wargaming and real players both. It's the 10k game cheaters who should be suffering, not real players and devs.

5
WhyLarrySoContrary•

I can only commend this, as these guys were so obviously botting/afking it was painful to see them win anything but a kick in the ass.

2
VesseryWG•

Thanks to Vanzig we found the issue and solved it!

1
demosthenesss•

You need WG tags here!

1
VesseryWG•

But I have it! You can find my tags on Old Reddit. I'm not sure that it visible on new Reddit :)

1
DunK1nG•

He doesn't care. I've told sub_octavian and mrConway and @WorldofWarships on twitch and their support department and some other employees, wargaming simply doesn't have any interest in these bots ruining thousands of games (which is why Wargaming Support removed the Botter category from reports and why they copy-paste a BS response to just rely on auto-detection even though botters have done 20,000+ matches while auto-detect never bans them)

Unless wargaming starts paying support employees to do their job and ban cheaters, none of their employees will solve this problem. I got one 20,000 game cheater banned last year after talking to a half-dozen employees, but in the effort it took to get them to do their jobs a single time, the cheaters just make 500 new accounts that don't get banned.

Either OP is lying or you are only reacting because this thread got a lot of attention. Either way, poor behavior that you guys let such a thing even happen in the first place, color me disappointed.

will plan our further events in a way that won't encourage botting

WOW, why can't you make it so that botting IS NOT encouraged in the first place? JUST FUCKING SAD.

-3
VesseryWG•

I can't be responsible for every contact what's happening with WG or Lesta employee, but I can suggest that question on stream was lost in the big chat activity. What's happen with Customer Support tickets - I don't know and it's the reason why I requested tickets ID. Will investigate it.

We reacted when we found this post on Reddit this morning. I'm sorry that's happened so late but better late than never. Will take into account situation like this and try to avoid this in the future.

Botting is not encouraged, and we very carefully monitoring and prohibited any bot-programs for a long time. There was a little problem with this event due to some internal problems. Now this problem will be solved, we will take into account new experience and improve our processes.

9
Admiral_Thunder•

We reacted when we found this post on Reddit this morning. I'm sorry that's happened so late but better late than never. Will take into account situation like this and try to avoid this in the future.

You might want to talk with the mod's on the NA forums and your NA customer support then. I reported that at least one known botter won at 8:30AM eastern time on the NA website forums. The post was soon moved to feedback and bugs and a Mod gave a standard blow me off response. So you were notified more than just here on Reddit.

My post... https://forum.worldofwarships.com/topic/198226-wg-you-need-to-take-another-look-at-your-botting-protocols/

Also, FWIW, there was a huge thread about the botter I refer to on those same NA forums a few months back where the player admitted to what he did. Mod's intervened in the thread to tell everyone to be civil yet no action was taken (his clan kicked him out but nothing from WG) against a self comfessed botter/rule breaker even with his confession right there. I have sent a ton of tickets in with replays, as have at least 10 others I know, showing this one player's actions, and all we ever get is a canned response and nothing is done.

So I am glad to see you at least are stepping up and making this right for the people who should have won and didn't. It will also help the rest of us in normal play who get saddled with these people. I am so tired of playing over and over with one of them.

Thank you again.

6
VesseryWG•

Thank you for your post! I will talk with the guys and investigate what happened. But I can't promise a lot.

1
DunK1nG•

I didn't mean you as person but you as in company. If botting is not encouraged why do we have bots running around in this game for years? I don't even mean bad players, there are as many really bad players as Super Unicum players, I can buy that, but I can't buy the botting is not encouraged, as per replies from other users, it's not even the first time this happened.

1
Uberghost1Gunslinger DD :dd:•

Good on you. WG needed to respond to this and you have. Thank you Vessery.

1
VesseryWG•

Thank you so much for your kind words.

1
milet72HMS Ulysses•

WG has access to all stats. It should be relatively easy to make statistical analysis of all accounts, using either heuristics (average damage < 100 XP in > 100 game, fired main guns X times in Y games), or big data analysis or even AI techniques.

After statistical run bot accounts would be flagged and hand-checked by staff.

Heuristic is really easy, just run some queries over database.

16
Admiral_Thunder•

I know of countless replays sent by a multitude of players showing the botting by one of them that have been sent in to customer support (many sent by me). The player himself has even publicly admitted on the WOWS NA forum he does this as well. The sheer number of games played over given time periods is physically impossible for a human to do as well. Yet WG does NOTHING and now the cheater has won a premium ship. Way to go WG.

I feel bad for the player he beat out for the ship he got and the subsequent player beneath the one below him who got nothing. He cheated 2 players out of prizes.

7
Boatsntanks•

But they are lazy and don't care.

6
StevieSlacks•

You didn't find a way to monetize the solution with loot boxes. You've been added to SubOs ignore list due to yoour racism!

5
DunK1nG•

I mean if you look at videos how they read spreadsheets, you'll notice they will never get this easy job done.

2
shepahotep•

Do you recognize any botters in the Hall of Fame pages? Since the French event captain will require Hall of Fame participation to acquire, I wonder how many could end up going to bots instead of real players.

12
_Didds_•

comment

if you look at the hall of fame in the current event you can see that a lot of those players have thousands of games played in just a couple of days, to a point that its basically impossible to even do it if you were a real person, and there isn't even a grand reward for this hall of fame ... so responding to your question to another user, you will get at sizable portion of the half fame filled with bots

12
Silverhammerz•

I didn’t interpret the announcement to mean only the top X% of players in the hall o fame would get the new capitain. I interpreted that players needed to finish all directives and enter the hall of fame. Is this not what others are thinking?

3
lthv•

Based on past experience, my interpretation was that higher placement in the hall of fame means more currency.

8
Admiral_Thunder•

Yes, you can't earn enough tokens outright in the directives. You also need some combo of HOF earned tokens and/or Mogador and Le Terrible Missions. Here is how it works...

  • Max you can earn by doing all directives in the 4 parts = 1610
  • Mogador & Le Terrible Missions award 200 tokens each = 400 tokens
  • HOF awards 300 tokens for each stage you meet and surpass = 1200 max possible (300 for 50%/300 for 25%/300 for 10%/300 for 5%)
  • The Capt needs 2100 tokens

So you need some combo of doing all the directives, having those 2 DD's, and HOF placement of 50% or higher to get the Capt for free.

Premium crates will have 120 tokens p/ crate for those who prefer that route.

5
Konato_KPlay Button•

Having 1 DD is enough, 1610+200+300 is 2110, but yes, it's awful.

2
Admiral_Thunder•

I said some combo of the following. I know it says 2 DD's but I assumed people would see where I said the missions were 200 each. I should have been more clear I guess. Sorry.

1
Purity_the_KittyEven I Say Remove CVs•

I'll be grinding my ass off for Mogador anyway, hopefully I get the Vaquelin mission to speed it up, I don't wanna start from Guepard. At least Guepard is really good.

1
shepahotep•

FRENCH TOKENS

You can earn French Tokens for:

Completing all Directive missions of the “French Destroyers: Part 2” event—up to 1,610 Tokens.

Ranking in the Hall of Fame—up to 1,200 Tokens.

Completing combat missions with IX Mogador and VIII Le Terrible—200 Tokens for each mission.

"up to" definitely sounds variable.

2
GentianaceaeSunk in Port•

As I learn more about Wargaming, I feel increasingly uneasy about spending money. I fear this whale needs to beach itself.

12
U-B-WareUBWare (NA)•

haven't spent a dime on the game in 2 years. I plan on keeping it that way for the forseable future unless there are some BIG changes to the way business is done and I don't mean new content.

But I'm not holding my breath.

4
DunK1nG•

You really should stop spending money until they fix their shit for real.

4
WhyLarrySoContrary•

Yup. Wichita winner is regular coop bot guy in his Georgia.

Saw him non-stop leveling my Benham capt. Never a word, or you know, any effort.

Edit(Not Alaska) Thx Thunder

9
Admiral_Thunder•

Wrong guy. The Alaska winner isn't the one you are thinking of. Look again. I won't name and shame but the Alaska winner is not the one - he only has 12 Co-op battles and is a pretty good PVP player.

It is one of the other 2 you mean and yes lately he ahs done it with Georgia. Missouri was his favorite before and under his old username. Believe I have seen him in Jean Bart as well.

5
WhyLarrySoContrary•

Ah Yes, You are correct sir. It was the Wichita winner. Name and shame isn't the same when your talking about automated abuse.

6
Uberghost1Gunslinger DD :dd:•

Can confirm on the Missou bot. I saw him...or it...nonstop botting on a previous campaign. It’s pretty blatant at this point and allowing this character to win anything is a serious black eye on WG’s behalf.

This is a really bad thing for the game.

3
RogueIslesRefugeeImperial Japanese Navy•

I recognize one of the Wichita guys, and I think it's the one you're referring to (see this guy in a Georgia often enough), but while he may be botting, he also actually plays from time to time. That, or the bot setup he's using is better than most, since I've seen him seemingly actively playing more than once, even making the top 2-3 on the scoreboard at the end of matches on rare occasion. He's also in a clan as of yesterday or day before.

1
VanzigOP•

It's not allowed in the ToS to play 1 real game then AFK-bot for 49 more games.

He's got a co-op page of so many thousands of matches AFK that his average in ships is like 1000 damage (less than the secondaries setting one single fire per match while he sits at an island)

Him occasionally taking advantage of all his stolen items that he didn't pay or play for isn't redeeming himself in the slightest.

4
RogueIslesRefugeeImperial Japanese Navy•

I haven't looked at his stats, since I'm in co-op for things like snowflakes and such, so just want to get in and get out. And I don't mean to suggest that what he does is okay, just that I had seen him actually play, so he's not botting 100% of the time (or so it appears). I wonder if the clan he's in knows he bots though, or if they even care. Assuming of course that it's not his own clan.

2
Admiral_Thunder•

His previous clan kicked him out for what he is doing. His current clan is new. Not sure if he started it for himself or if some unknowing clan let him in?

The guy bots big time. I have sent multiple replays in to WG showing it. Even if he plays once in a while it doesn't excuse the hundreds, and thousands, of times he doesn't. And he admittd to doing this on the NA forums as well just FYI. WG had/has a confession to the things he does on their own forum and they still won't act.

It infuriates me to no end that a cheater is allowed to continue to cheat, win prizes, and always put his team down 1. PVP or Co-op it shouldn't matetr or be allowed.

4
Uberghost1Gunslinger DD :dd:•

And this is the crux of the issue. I suspect that one human played game out of a 100 (or more) somehow nullifies WG's questionable attempt to determine if it is a bot. But, shouldn't winning a contest somehow garner some deeper inspection?

The key to successful botting is to not stand out. This guy just became the nail that is begging for a hammer.

More importantly, folks know he botted. The word will spread. If it goes unchecked, then you're giving carte blanche to any potential botter winning contests, clearing campaigns, and worse.

The bottom line here though is clear: If you have seen this character play, then you know something isn't right. You know that whatever he is doing does not comport with the spirit of fair play and sportsmanship. He doesn't pass the smell test. And, his numbers are absolutely indicative of a botter.

Sure, it could be some seriously handicapped fellow with tons of free time and a serious addiction to the game. There are exceptions to rules and possibilities of innocence to anyone accused of something improper. Yet, in this specific circumstance, knowing that WG did check into it and gave it an "all clear" would go a long ways to defending the honor of the game.

Whether you believe it was a good faith inspection is up to each person. Yet, something must be done.

It couldn't be more clear.

2
Admiral_Thunder•

It couldn't be more clear bcause he admitted it on the WOWS NA forums!

2
Uberghost1Gunslinger DD :dd:•

Could you link it? It might save some time for a particular person...

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AcidNewports•

Wont matter Submarines will give them a boost of cash. After the sub's I dont know what their money maker will be, Modern Ship's?

6
EIGordo•

Premium Tier X Battleship USS New Jersey with nuclear tipped W23 shells instead of high explosive shells.

You'll be able to exchange her in the armory against 200 plutonium tokens. To obtain those you'll have to fulfil 200 out of 180 daily tasks each awarding a single plutonium token. But don't worry, if you can't play every day or aren't a time lord they'll sell token boxes with the first ten only being 1€ and every following batch being exponentially more expensive. But the daily tasks too aren't just available like that, each one has to be individually unlocked through lootboxes of which there is a standard version at 150 doubloons and a premium one for 750 doubloons with a higher drop rate for daily tasks.

Fair wind and following sea, captain!

30
[deleted]•

[removed]

5
cain071546•

But you can't gift ships and stuff so that doesn't work

1
IanH755Over 3.5 years of WoWS and WG are still doing dumb shit!!!•

3 of the 6 EU Ship winners have their account marked Private - thats 50%, not suspicious at all there WG!!!

5
kweniston•

WG is a shit elite company that keeps up its appearances, and that we are condemned with for the best online naval game (and most profitable ever) around.

4
Cit_the_bedTruce. Clockwise. Why you shooting! Stop! Truc...•

The bots are probably WG bots to reduce how much stuff they actually pay out.

4
IanH755Over 3.5 years of WoWS and WG are still doing dumb shit!!!•

You know what, by this point I'm so fed-up of WG and their shit I could actually believe they do that!

3
usedgun•

You're telling me....that all of those 300 PR or less CVs and other wonderful individuals with 10k average damage in T9s and 10s are bots? This sounds like heresy to me.

3
Merakas•

Spam this in the forum to see if they dare to even reply the same bs

2
Admiral_Thunder•

I already have and they responded with the usul BS.

2
Mysterious_Tea•

...and not a single fuck was given from WeeGee.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
BirthHole•

The bot guys are enjoying the fuck out of this thread.

1†
Uberghost1Gunslinger DD :dd:•

I’ll be watching this thread today for a WG response. This is the medium where thoughts and perceptions are shared freely among players from all servers. And, if there is the potential for a “poison apple spoils the tree” scenario to play out, then this is it.

The fairness of all future contests is at stake. The fairness of any achievement or award that rewards botting behavior is at stake.

I cannot emphasize enough how important the notion of equity and fair play is to the physiology of a successful game.

This is not going to go away. It’s going to become a huge headache for WG if they don’t address this head on.

It’s a tricky scenario for WG because of their own name/shame policies. The contest winner has named himself, and the means by which they won is the shame. According to the TOS, anyone who acknowledges the winner is potentially a rules violator. There’s a reason why my country has developed some very effective and complex slander/libel rules and exceptions. We have a direct cultural conflict with the boilerplate language of the TOS.

I do not envy any WG employee who takes this on.

It’s also a difficult problem to solve since botting has evolved into a far more complex behavior.

Finding a workable solution is akin to painstakingly clearing a minefield while under direct fire...from both sides.

Yet, here we are. By winning the contest, the chickens have come home to roost.

WG may not be responding because they simply don’t know how to respond yet. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.

0
Boxhundo•

If the numbers say they won, then they won, Comrade

-14
WhyLarrySoContrary•

Get a bot, be a winner too? Understood comrade.

Just as long as we're clear on the standard that there is no standard. What you really need is him on your ranked or random team cause the people who matter refuse to act. It would matter then.

11
Boxhundo•

Holy crap look at all these downvotes! I think the bots are horrible! I was just making a far reaching joke about WG not doing anything about it lol

2
WhyLarrySoContrary•

Morning hugz man. I took my downvote back GG

2
Konato_KPlay Button•

Found the botter

1