RedditFitness: If you saw someone using bad form in the gym, would you try to help them?

Today I was at the gym and I saw someone doing far too much weight with bad form on their squats, and it made my legs hurt just watching it. However, I wasn't sure if I should say anything... would you?

Posted Jul 18, 2010, 9:07 PM UTC

217
valadil•

Every time I've seen someone using what I thought was bad form, I later learned that I was thinking of the wrong exercise. They were using perfectly good form, but for exercises I didn't know existed. Having had this happen more times than I care to count, the only way I'd tell someone they're doing it wrong is if their form was so strange they might hurt someone else with it.

3
Paul-ish•

I have had that happen to me too. I usually keep my mouth shut. The only time I can remember correcting someone was when I saw a guy in the elliptical with his lifting belt on. I just reminded him that he had a belt on (maybe he forgot), and he just said "I know".

1
Atheizt•

Sadly some people wear lifting belts and gloves purely for image. I personally use a lifting belt because... well... I lift heavy and need one but I take it off as soon as I set the bar down and I refuse to wear gloves.

To each their own.

1
goodbyeworldOP•

Sticking to my hypothetical, what if they looked like they had no idea what they were doing? (I am talking ab knees way over the toes or something, using back on squat, etc...)

1
[deleted]•

Here's the problem with giving advice.

EVERYBODY at the gym thinks they know what they're doing, and EVERYBODY thinks they know better than everybody else, and NOBODY wants to take advice from strangers, especially if they're fellow patrons who've just happened to become internet experts by reading a different set of articles.

Unless somebody is doing something that is an IMMEDIATE danger to themselves or others (say doing twisting torso rotations while squatting heavy), just use them as an example of what not to do, and move on with your workout.

This goes double if they're women. Leave the chicks alone unless they ask for help. DON'T BE THAT GUY.

If you want to give advice to the ENDLESS number of people with terrible form, get certified as a personal trainer and get a job at the gym. Then you can give all the advice you want and get $ for it.

7
OrangeJuliusPage•

Upvoted if only for the "Leave the chicks alone line." There's been a handful of times that I've given a girl advice. Like, literally 4 times in 10 years. Once it was one of my best friends, so she was receptive. Twice, they seemed skeptical of my advice since they thought I was hitting on them, which while they were attractive, is seriously poor form at the gym. The fourth time was a girl the other day who asked me to spot her on incline bench, and even she seemed kind of sketched out that I didn't have an ulterior motive when I told her to be careful how she lines up her hands on the bar...which is a much greater euphemism than I originally thought, upon further reflection.

1
valadil•

At my level of knowledge, I can't be sure those are bad things. Someone would have to be performing cartoonishly badly for me to know for sure that they were doing something wrong.

1
[deleted]•

Never. The only time, in my experience, to offer help is when someone is asking for help. I don't correct bad form, don't tell fat people to lose weight, don't ask smokers if they know they're killing themselves, etc. It's a good rule if you want to avoid being detested and/or punched in the face :)

EDIT: Actually, afer reading other comments, I've realised there's an exception: if they look like they're going to hurt someone else, I'll say something. I've had to say something to a guy wheo was kind of ducking and weaving through people doing barbell lifts to get to the water fountain once - he forced a guy who was about to dump an overhead press to hold it an extra two-count while he walked under the fucking bar.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
lynxification•

Only if its a danger to others around them.

Also I hate bad gym etiquette, such as the guy who thinks he's a badass with his 100lb dumbbells and then throws them at the end of his set with a loud bang potentially breaking the ankles of anyone who might be in front.

2
Osirius44•

I may give them a look of disapproval, but I havn't ever gone up to them. I have had a few ask me for help with a spot, which turned into me correcting their form.

The one time I went out of my way to fix someone's form was a friend I knew decently well in high school. I saw him doing deadlifts completely wrong ( butt was too high, relied on his lower back instead of his legs to lift the weight etc) and rushed over and demonstrated proper form for him. I've injured my back before, I didn't want to see someone else go through that.

2
rangerthefuckup•

Personally, if you walked up and knew what you were talking about it I would be greatly appreciative. Then there are some who wouldn't be so enthused, its up to you. Gotta be ready to bite the bullet if they get pissed.

2
HerrFaucherCoaching•

As a trainer I see people using shitty form day in and day out. Typically I will watch them for a little to see if its form degrading late set or if they just flat out dont know whats up. Keep in mind many people have ego issues at the gym and dont want to be told they are wrong, however there are also many people who would love pointers from those more knowledgeable themselves. If you do in fact know what you are talking about go up to them and let them know that you do said exercise "like this" dont tell them their form is shit.

In short, the worst that can happen is someone tells you to fuck off, in which case they can hurt themselves all they want. Be friendly and offer constructive criticism, not negative.

1
adagar121987•

I was corrected on my form doing cleans, which I was just starting. It helped a ton!

1
blackblackbird•

ive been corrected on my form a couple times. It was done very politley. I was grateful for it, I mean otherwise, I would have been wasting my time. But you never know how someone is going to take the criticism. If the guy already looks like Lou Ferrigno, Leave the man alone.

1
[deleted]•

I would only say something if their form is so bad I think they're going to hurt me. Otherwise, I keep my mouth shut because I know I don't know as much as I think I know... what?

1
krakow057•

only if it is a girl, and only if she is fucking hot.

nothing gayer than coming to a man and saying "hey, I was just watching you exercise from there"

1
smileyllama•

I have only ever been in a position to offer advice to people I already know. I am a decent weightlifter, but would not consider myself knowledgeable enough to give advice to anyone above a complete novice. Thus, I would not want to advise anyone unless it looked dangerous. If I were more of an expert, I might feel more comfortable interjecting (even if I would still feel a bit awkward).

If I were doing something genuinely dangerous, I would want someone to say something. Granted, I don't have the ego issues that a lot of gym-goers do, but I would rather wonder if some stranger were hitting on me (attractive female) than potentially injure myself.

1