r/starcraft: Ways to Improve the Archon

Given that Blizzard has released a mini-update describing how underused the Archons are, and after watching the recent King of the Beta games, I think a small buff would go a far way to making them more viable as part of the toss unit composition. It seems that Archons are strong against zerg but not so much against Terran where they get eaten up rather quickly against MMM, Tanks or EMPs.

So here's my simple solution to help make the Archon more viable. Give the Archon the property of being immune to concussive shells, but not massive status or any of the other perks. Therefore concussive shells won't slow him down. I think this buff would help and its a simple solution that doesn't upset any other mechanics. What do you think?

TLDR: Subtle Buff - Make Archon immune to Concussive Shells.

Edit: Added TL;DR.

Edit 2: Thank you k0rr, RedAlert2 for pointing out that concussive shells do not cause a "stun" effect and that stun status is reserved for the Thor's 250mm canons. I was under the wrong impression that the slowing down effect of a Marauder's concussive shell was named "stun".

Posted Jul 20, 2010, 2:56 PM UTC · edited

740
thinkbohemian•

I often forget that I can warp my DT's to archons, so once i've been detected, and i'm getting shot at by banshees/mutas, a simple tip "don't forget you can morph to archons" would be a game changer.

You could even make the default sound when you're trying to storm with no energy to be something like "My energy is depleted, free me to archon form" or something equally awkward.

Not all buffs have to come from numbers, sometimes a little social priming is all you need. Less wasted templars on the battlefield = more archons

Not to mention newbs don't know how to use them (i.e. they don't understand that they're meant as a backup for when the original unit becomes less useful.)

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Syphon8Random•

Have their shields regenerate faster than other units, and give them the ability of the shield battery (Except it drains from theirs, not energy).

It'd fit with lore (Archons psychically project their shields, where it's technological on other units), and I think it'd help balance, especially against EMP spam.

6
[deleted]•

I think archons are fine and buffing them risks making templar tech too strong and you will never see collusus play anymore. I think overall Protoss is a fairly balanced race. Terran is a bit too strong right now and Zerg is a bit too weak. I would rather Blizzard focus on balancing the other races then buffing/nerfing toss.

4
drizzleliciousProtoss•

I think the ratio of Protoss users going colossus to HT is something like 3:1. I don't really think we're in danger of losing colossus play any time soon

7
marcuspowersOP•

I agree with you. Colossus is a very powerful unit and I don't see people forgoing them for Archons anytime soon. Also the subtle buff I mentioned is not game changing and I think it would make them slightly more usable against terrans.

That being said, I've read several posts by higher level players who say that Protoss is the most well balanced race so far and that the other races should be balanced against toss. However Blizz's data shows low usage of Archons. Therefore when I thought of this small buff I had that in mind.

3
spoonraker•

I also don't think a small buff to Archons would lead to less Collosus usage.

Collosus and HTs effectively do the same thing and are used similarly, they have area effect damage and work well against packed up enemies, but HTs are more micro intensive. It's easy to retreat out of a storm, but once a Collosus laser hits you the damage is done. This is why I think Collosus is more common, because it's just a bit easier. I think HTs are more effective per mineral cost if you get the most out of them though.

2
[deleted]•

This is exactly what I was thinking. Colossi are a fire and forget type of unit and Templar require more micro. However, Templar are far more effective per mineral cost.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
TheAceOfHeartsTeam Grubby•

I like the idea. If they're immune to stun they can close in to enemies, it makes them SO much more useful.

4
Ipp•

Terran units are slower than zerg and don't have natural hp regeneration making storms much more powerful, not to mention feedback can be crucial on thors as they don't use their cannons often. The Archon isn't suppose to be a main combat or support unit. It is something you do after feedback,storms, etc and need a little extra something.

I think the problem is the warp prism is more flimsy than the shuttle; making drops much harder to do. However that is made up for by its ability to warp in units; I believe this is an highly underutilized unit in dealing with an immobile army.

3
[deleted]•

I think both protoss and zerg players are under utilizing drops/warpin and nydus to exploit immobility. I am surprised I don't see it more often.

3
LittleRaptor•

At 300/300 for Zerg (100/100 for speed, 200/200 for drop) and the long research time makes drops a mid to late game tactic. That out of the way, I think we don't see it much because it requires a lot of actions to successfully drop troops.

So, to over simplify it TvZ the Terran (mech) player is

  1. Macroing

  2. Positioning his/her ground army

  3. Scouting

The Zerg player, in order to beat him/her, is

  1. Macroing

  2. Positioning his/her ground army

  3. Scouting

  4. Loading units into overlords/moving them/dropping the units and controlling them/picking them back up again

Not to say it can't be done, it is just if you have ~60 APM, a higher percentage as the zerg player has to be taken away from 1-3 to do it.

[edit: formatting]

1
[deleted]•

I love the WP. It is so useful if the enemy doesn't have vision of their entire base. I will normally push an attack at their front door and warp in a round of chargelots on their high ground to take care of the mineral line.

1
RedAlert2Terran•

So here's my simple solution to help make the Archon more viable. Give the Archon the same buff as the Ultralisk, specifically the immune to stunning. Therefore concussion shells won't slow him down. I think this buff would help and its a simple solution that doesn't upset any other mechanics. What do you think?

Concussive shells =/= stunning. Immunity to stunning is immunity to the stunning aspect of the thor's 250mm cannons, not to concussive shells. All massive units are immune to concussive shells.

2
marcuspowersOP•

Thank you for pointing that out.

1
marcuspowersOP•

Oh and I know Zerg players get a bad rap for whining about their race being underpowered, imbalanced, etc. but this time I'm whining for the other guy.

1
sotonohitoProtoss•

Its "bad rap", actually.

1
rhiesa•

Unless you throw some chopped salmon, a bit of lemonade and some old vegetables. Bam, you've got a wrap.

2
dr_draik•

That sounds like a bad wrap...

1
marcuspowersOP•

Thanks. Pre-morning coffee attempt.

1
AzuremenProtoss•

If the immune to stun was applied to the Archon, I think it would be balanced still. Lore wise it makes no sense at all for a ball of energy to be stunned by a grenade, and gameplay wise it is quite frustrating to watch Archons get kited by a few Marauders...

1
[deleted]•

Ultralisks are immune to concussive shells because they are Massive, not because they're stun-immune. The stun-immune applies to abilities like the Thor's 250mm cannons.

3
AzuremenProtoss•

Doh on my end, I should know better. Perhaps grant the Archon massive status, though they aren't that large lore wise.

I just feel ignoring Marauder Concussive shells would make them far more viable in PvT.

2
RogueVert•

iirc one of the later patches made them immune to stun now

1
chekulk•

What if Archons came with one shield upgrade standard? You rarely see it get researched anyway.

1
Blythe703•

Or to make them a bit like Ultras, they have a special upgrade that only worked on them but buffed shields like crazy?

1
DanielDoh•

The archon doesn't need to be viable, it's an emergency and/or mid-battle unit to make.

Besides, I disagree that it isn't useful. They don't get eaten up against tanks, they have 350 (or 300?) shields, which is a lot of damage an archon can tank. EMP only takes off 100 shields, and yes, it's hard to get them close to marauders, so... don't attack marauders with them -- don't make them if the enemy has a lot of marauders.

1
RedAlert2Terran•

What I find funny is that you want to give archons buffs vs terran (and only terran). I am guessing because you think it is weaker than it's broodwar counterpart? In this game, archons are actually useful against terran. In broodwar, EMP would take way all of the archon's shields, instead of just 100 of them. In broodwar, every unit did full damage to them (because of shields), so they would get owned even by vultures. Archons are so much better vs terran in this game than they were in BW. I don't know why you think they need to be better.

1
Syphon8Random•

Ultralisks were already immune to Concussive Shells because they're massive.

Making Archons massive would be pretty good, because it'd also give toss a fast unit to pop FFs.

1
achronism•

Archons are fine, excellent against Zerg, weak against Terran. Exactly as they are in StarCraft 1. Every unit doesn't have to be an all-purpose unit... it would be like asking for Banelings to be more effective vs Protoss. I'm quite happy to have more diversity among the units.

Fixing the Mothership should be a priority. I want my fast, mobile, useful Arbitors back. The whole taking '10 minutes' to warp in, weak attack, 1 per player and slow movement speed makes for a complete mess of a unit. They're just as much of a joke as Scouts are in Starcraft 1.

1
kman420Protoss•

Making archons a massive unit would also cause it to take much more damage from certain attacks. Currently it's a psyonic unit and takes minimum damage from every attack. I don't see them changing it to a massive unit. You can't really make archons viable against terran unless you completely remove the EMP ability.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
SeedersZerg•

What about a self destruct ability? Not automatic like the baneling, not as large of an AoE as storm, but just like an instant 15-20 damage to all units within a certain radius of the archon when the ability is used.

Just an idea, I kinda think archons are fine as they are.

0
DevinTheGrandZerg•

Well if it's only 15-20 damage then no one would ever use it because they have splash and do way more than that by just attacking.

1
SeedersZerg•

Well fuckin more damage then, I dont fucking know.. That wasn't the point of the post.

1
EarthBounder•

Better micro of HTs is a huge buff to Archons. Too many players using a+move with HTs, storming, and then losing them all. Good players are using archons more and more since the increase in their splash radius and decrease in merge time.

See HuK v TLO Day9 KotBH g2 or White-Ra v Masq.

0
ONPRaGuProtoss•

I was thinking about this the other day, what about if they allowed archons to move up and down the cliffs in the same way the reapers do? They are pretty slow to try to harass with and would still be extremely offensive but they could be useful in tanking some damage and getting sight on higher ground.

Edit: They seem to float anyway!

-1
Sunergy•

Well, given the fact that high templars (and thus archons) are the alternative to going colossus, which already have the trait to go up hills, I think it would be better to keep the builds as different feeling as possible.

2
moogleiii•

Link or info about the mini-update?

-1
marcuspowersOP•

It really is a mini-update, a very small blurb: The StarCraft II team is addressing internal testing which shows that archons and lurkers have so far been underutilized by players. Apparently this update was back in Feb (I thought it was more recent) and since then Blizz has applied some buffs such as faster build time for the Archon once templars are merged, but I still see posts about underutilization of Archons on TL.

-2
Taedirk•

Lurkers

Back the fuck up.

2