Diamond player with ~70% wr on current Panth. Here are my thoughts...
Ok so I've been playing Panth on my plat smurfs and for sure he feels weak, we can all agree on that. I've put in about 20 games of him so far and so I think I have a good idea of how he works (I have about 200 games of old panth from this and last season). Here's the list of what feels good and bad about him currently in the top lane.
Pros:
-
Q along with tiamat feels amazing for waveclear, really good powerspike since it helps you roam. It also doesn't force you to e the wave (like old panth) and make your vulnerable to all-ins
-
Early game is ok. When you're running ignite, he definitely feels fine early game as you can poke down the enemy with tap Q and not aggro minions.
-
Hail of blades is currently the best rune (not by much). It allows you to have a really strong early game with empowered W > auto auto quick > then empowered Q. With titanic hydra, you proc the item passive 6 times quickly and if you run botrk (this is fringe, still teasting), it's also very strong. This also allows you to proc black cleaver very easily.
-
Can block some key abilities like Darius ult, Camille Q2, Irelia ult, Morde Q (then you all in), Tryn R for his all ins, Aatrox Q3, Sion Q/R, Illaoi R (this one is big), Jayce Q+E, Ornn r / empowered R, Riven combo + R, Wukong R, Kennen R, GP E.
Cons:
-
Really poor scaling. You lost all of your E burst (100/150/200/250/300 (+300% bonus ad scaling)) so you still need to poke targets before your all ins.
-
Really poor poke. So if you manage to hit an empowered Q without it hitting minions, it might do somewhere around 4-8% of the enemy top laners health. Maybe it's about 10-15% against squishies but that's pretty terrible for a fairly skinny and short range ability. When it's not empowered, it's not even worth throwing unless the enemy has banshees or something. In my last game, I threw my Q through some minions and hit an enemy urgot who had no armor items in the mid game; it did 56 damage. Like, it's pretty pathetic.
-
Thrown Q does as much damage as Olaf Q but it has a 10-8s cd while Olaf has 2-0 if he picks it up AND Olaf Q still deals damage when it goes through minions. During this 10-8 second window of dealing no damage, the enemy champion can do whatever they want because you have no way to retaliate.
-
E cool down is way too long. Now this IS going to make some other mains butthurt, but the cool down should probably be about 18-10 second CD, maybe even 16-8. I would argue that Pantheon's old passive gave saved him more health than the current one because of how often it was up. Yes we're trading an offense tool for stronger defense but they took way too much offense and offered too little defense. You're almost never using your E twice in a fight but when you do, the defensive part probably didn't matter.
-
With 150 bonus ad at level 13, current pantheon is dealing 100 + 480 damage = 580, with 20% cdr, over 30 seconds which is how long an extended teamfight lasts, he's using it twice and is dealing 1160 damage.
-
With 150 bonus ad at level 13, old pantheon is dealing 750 damage, with 20% cdr over 30 seconds, he uses it 6 times and is dealing 4500 damage.
-
The difference is about 400% damage loss with the new kit, just so that he can protect himself twice against champion abilities. When I went over my match history vs an irelia, I noticed that she mitigated more damage than since her W is almost as strong as Panth E however, it's on a much much shorter cool down (and she can jump behind panth and auto when his E is up, negating the effectiveness of his E).
-
You don't have an ult indicator for your teammates. A ping isn't good enough because your team has to be confident where your ult is landing (also if you even are ulting, instead of just pinging on my way) so that they can corral the enemy champion(s) into your flank/landing zone.
-
W rank goes up by 20 every rank. It's actually laughable about how bad his kit scales. I'm not expecting him to get 100 damage or anything, but at least have the empowered W autos scale from 50%-100% in strength.
This is all I can think about at the moment, I want to know your guys' opinions and see where we agree, disagree or if I missed anything. Thanks for reading!
TL;DR: If you don't want to read, just move on please. I want to raise awareness of how this champion feels currently.
Posted Aug 17, 2019, 4:40 PM UTC
Disappointing and Condensing TL;DR - guess I'm not reading it
Considering the fact that he's listed almost 3 times the cons than pros I'll go on a limb and say that he's shit
I also see more numbers in the 2nd part so I guess he doesn't like the dmg numbers
Yeah 3 of those bullet points is just one point talking about his E numbers. Essentially he deals 400% less damage than before for the sake of having a 3s total of protection (which isn't as good as it seems)
Because its a defensive ability that replicates his old passiv you idiot