What feature would you bring to classic with you?

Discussion

Just a bit of fun here, but if you could bring one feature from Live to Classic, what would it be?

And if you could bring one thing from classic to live, what would that be?

For me I'd take the transmog system back to classic. As an RPer I'm dreading having to go back to filling my bags/banks with gear just for style haha!

As for from Classic to Live, it would be the lack of flying. I hate flying mounts.

Can't wait to hear your ideas!

Posted Aug 18, 2019, 8:07 AM UTC

054
Gosu_Horaz:horde::mage:•

The only thing I could think of is the dual specs from bc.

6
BenedickCabbagepatch:alliance::paladin:•

Nah, I like the creativity it forces you to take in trying to make adaptable talent sets. For example, my Pala's going to be a Prot/Holy mix when he initially hits lvl 60 so I can both tank and heal dungeons if I've the appropriate gear.

Then I'll be switching to a Holy Shock build (Holy/Ret) so I can both heal but also PvP.

It might not be minmaxing, but it's fun to try cover multiple bases with one spec.

3
Listeria08•

HotW and Moonglow... It's so hard to decide:)

2
BenedickCabbagepatch:alliance::paladin:•

For me it's Holy Shield or that sweet crit chance on Holy spells/Holy Shock.

2
Gosu_Horaz:horde::mage:•

Yeah, I like that too. But some classes just have to pay 100g a week and there's no way around it.

2
BenedickCabbagepatch:alliance::paladin:•

That's a fair point. Perhaps instead of having us switch on the fly we could specify talent builds that automatically apply in dungeons/Bags/Raids/The Open World?

Or maybe the retail-esque switching is just the most elegant solution, fuck, I dunno!

1
Gosu_Horaz:horde::mage:•

The most elegant solution in my opinion would be to let 'lock in' two specs at the trainer and let us switch between them (at the trainer) for a discount, like 5 or 10g a switch. Would stay kind of true to the spirit bit take some pressure off of some classes, especially priests and warriors.

2
kuppokuppo•

THIS!!! As a warrior tank, I hate paying so much gold to switch specs to pvp.

1
Raknel•

Dual talents are wotlk

1
Gosu_Horaz:horde::mage:•

Are you sure? Memory is a bit fuzzy, but I kinda remember having them in BC.

1
Raknel•

Yeah for sure

3
ZoboCamel:alliance::priest:•

Yeah, that was going to be my top choice too (in conjunction with making more specs viable, if you could call that a feature). I've always liked to swap between roles and characters to have more variety in my playstyles, fill roles flexibly etc... but that's less appealing when respecs are expensive and you've often only got one viable spec for PvE anyway.

1
Raydough•

*wotlk

1
MogthrollOP•

I couldn't agree more! That's why I'm going DPS and no tanking or healing. Save a fortune on changes.

0
Sguru1•

I haven’t really played live since cata but did a little panda. But I do read. The one thing I think would be sort of cool is if they could make pseudo timewalking work for classic in a sense. Like we can challenge ourself with a 40 man raid version of future encounters. The loot could be side grades to AQ/Naxx level stuff and be of Similiar item level; and some loot tables for the meme specs.

Also the cata iteration of archaeology added to classic would be cool too.

If I could ask for one serious change from the classic client though: in vanilla alliance had a grind that gave them a winterspring frostsaber. In wotlk (maybe?) they added a horde equivalent to ungoro crater that gave horde a devilsaur mount. I’d like that quest/grind added to classic for horde.

5
MogthrollOP•

It was indeed wrath, and I do like the idea of time walking into the future?

1
AlexCForPres•

32 slot bags

5
MogthrollOP•

Oh man... I'm even further dreading inventory management... Thanks for the reminder haha

1
Totaemoeggerli•

guild bank please

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
MogthrollOP•

I totally agree about the arena thing! And I hope to god they don't add in anything from here (I mean we know they won't) it's just a bit of fn!

1
noxhearted•

Could you please tell me your reasoning about how arena had such a negative effect on the game

1
Achibot•

I can't speak for STE06 but it marking the beginning of the Devs' obsession with "balancing the classes" is the most common reason. Presumably because they've admitted themselves that this was a trap they fell into and found hard to escape from. I suspect most would say they never did.

1
Steeff0•

The other classes

2
lpagtr:horde::mage:•

L->C: probably a convenience thing.. is aoe loot a thing in classic?
C->L: i would de-streamline questing to the point where knowing where to go and what to do was like classic (aka reading comprehension), and then those that don't want that can just download the addon

2
BenedickCabbagepatch:alliance::paladin:•

Transmogs as something you can opt into through the interface menu.

E.g. By standard you see everyone in the normal gear, but toggling transmogs on allows you to see mogged sets/mog your own stuff.

2
Riverr2303•

Classic to Live: no LFG system, no cross realm comms, in depth talent trees, spell ranks, attunement grinds, no map quests and no flying mounts

Live to Classic: Mount inventory system, Guild Bank, passenger mounts and dual spec.

1
MogthrollOP•

More than one, but I appreciate the enthusiasm haha! It would be nice to see the community feel back in live!

1
Riverr2303•

Sorry I couldn't just pick one, I tried! 😁

3
h0lymaccar0ni•

There was no guild bank in classic? This is gonna be a shock when I’ll first time play classic I guess lol. I also never thought about dungeons being something else than 5 man and learned that a few days ago.

But: I think aside from this whole layering thing that goes wrong so much cross realm was a good invention for small servers. I’ve played on a small rp pvp that hardly had enough players being in one region to defeat elite quest mobs.. so it was a good thing they at least pooled some servers and gave people the opportunity to group with players from other servers if they needed help.

1
Riverr2303•

Yup no guild banks. Generally the GM or an officer would have an bank alt and would keep items for the guild for distribution. My guild used to use the guild site to request something or over ventrilo (lol I miss this)

I guess I was lucky to have been on a ok population server to not experience lack of players that were around and willing to help. I don't like cross realm because it doesn't allow for player reputation on the server. I loved that I knew the good players from the bad, that I made friends from random encounters in killing elite mobs and generally felt like it was our community.

2
h0lymaccar0ni•

Wow okay that sounds so unreal to someone who has never experienced that. I wonder if this works out today still with all the deceiving and betrayal people seem to find normal today. I remember once during late wotlk someone created a saphiron 25 3D run (?) where the black and twilight drake mounts drop and snatched them both as loot master and everyone was just stunned at how rude this guy was. Fast forward to nowadays I think people would get over it in a minute or two.

Yeah on my server this was a real pain in the butt. If you were doing lower level stuff and had nobody available to help it was impossible to complete some quests.. but I get that community feeling, I heard many people miss this a lot.

1
[deleted]•

Guild bank is probably my big one...always surprised it wasn't a thing from the get go,as a perk to joining one in the first place.

1
marclonia:horde::hunter:•

My werebear form.

1
Raknel•

LFR just to watch the meltdown

1
K1pling•

Achievements but with an option to turn them off... I enjoy them, others don’t...

1
Celtain1337:alliance::warrior:•

It worries me deeply that so many people want to change classic... Really hope there's some sort of system in place to prevent new players from having a say in changes to classic.. If you don't play on an account that was registered in Vanilla, you shouldn't be allowed an opinion.

0
MogthrollOP•

I've been playing since Taurean didn't have mounts, so that would warrant me to have a say, but I'm on the same boat as you, I wouldn't change a thing. As mentioned in the post, and a previous comment, it's purely for fun and I'd be at the front of the rage train if they changed anything at all. I don't want change, nor would I agree with anyone wanting change, it's just a bit of hypothetical fun.

2
tontonjp•

They should make a 3rd version for "Classic w/ changes", if it becomes a thing. The real classic should be left alone.

That being said, they might/could release TBC and WotLK versions as well. That would further fracture the player base, but it might still be worth it to maintain overall subscription levels. I don't think the retail/live version has much more life in it, it's too messy, and the whole franchise is kinda due for a reboot of some kind.

1
Dirtsamwich:horde::warlock:•

That's a really bad mindset to have.

1
Celtain1337:alliance::warrior:•

No it isn't. I just started playing Warframe a few weeks ago. I wouldn't dream of voting for changes that I didnt understand. Most new comers will play classic for a few weeks and then leave. Why should they have a say in the future of the game?

1
Dirtsamwich:horde::warlock:•

I was more meaning the vanilla registered account thing. Within a matter of months if people want to know about the game they'll know more than you, they'll know more than me. You are not better because you played in vanilla. Give it six months and you'll have 19 year olds shitting on you in wsg. You. Are. Not. Better.

1
Celtain1337:alliance::warrior:•

I never said I was better. But a lot of us are playing classic to relive the experience. It wouldn't be fair to allow new players to ruin that experience for the rest of us. What the fuck are you even talking about BGs for? It's completely irrelevant. There are already a ton of younger people that are way better than me at the game. This isn't about skill or knowledge. Sorry but I'm not going to continue this conversation. You're an idiot.

0
moxthunder•

The dungeon finder and lfg system. It's the most significant quality of life change the game ever got in my opinion.

-2
Sguru1•

Hard disagree

8
MrHackberry:horde::hunter:•

Same here, but I won't downvote him for stating his opinion.

2
Sguru1•

Absolutely agree neither will I

1
KashXz:alliance::warlock:•

Along with the downfall of wow lol

5
moxthunder•

I stopped playing during cataclysm, returning for a few weeks here and there. But I remember having to organise a group, and then wait an hour for everyone to also walk to the dungeon.

There was something special about having you warlocks summon another person to the raid so that you could use the summoning stone.. but Jesus as a warlock player, I was sick of always being the one to have to stop questing so I could travel to the damn summoning stone.

2
Ossuum•

Half the reason the dungeons got so incredibly dull, though, alongside with them being hit hard by power creep. Turned something that felt like an undertaking into "press button, run from point A to point B while mashing your keyboard randomly, press button again, congratz, you've completed a dungeon". As for interaction between people gathered by lfg system, it was so negligible that making it a single player with bots wouldn't have been much of a difference, if any.

3
MogthrollOP•

While I agree it made life easier, because by the light it does, I sure hope classic brings back the sense of community. It was great seeing those "realm celebrities" in chat. Something you don't get anymore.

It's there anything from vanilla you'd like to see in live?

2
LastofTimelords•

Never needet such a thing! Play good, be nice and you‘ll get asked to join groups all the time!

2
Dessolos•

i respect your opinion but no group finder is honestly the main appeal of classic wow for me otherwise I wouldn't be wanting to come back to game.

2