I'm a new commish - league doesn't like one rule

[removed]

Posted Aug 19, 2019, 2:18 AM UTC · locked

19
walterdog12•

The problem here is that it's a money league.

In a normal league, that rule would be more than welcome and honestly I wish it'd be the norm just cause it's no fun to be in a league where half the teams are dead by week 5 or 6.

But in a money league... You making those moves for inactive teams will just result in controversy and outrage, because why should a guy lose when money is involved even though the other team hasn't been actively monitoring their team? Or what happens if the winner of the league ends up having say 2 weeks where he would have lost instead of won if you hadn't made a roster change for him?

3
Todd999430•

Slippery slope. First you put in a player. Why player A over player B? What if that’s the difference in the outcome? What if someone is starting a suspended our IR player? Fixing those too? What if ten minutes before lineups set, you learn that Mahomes won’t play... do you bench him too?

I applaud what you’re trying to do but my best advice is to not touch it.

Instead, give a substantial fine to anyone with a blank roster spot and/or injured/out player in their lineup. Put it into a kitty and that’s how you help pay for next year’s draft location/food.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
RedditGuy5454•

I’d say do it for bye weeks but if someone is a late scratch and they don’t catch it I can understand other players not wanting you to help them. It’s pretty obvious when someone gives up and won’t even trade out bye weeks.

1

It's a fair rule in principle imo. I think people have a hard time with giving up that kind of control though, or admit they might need that kind of help to begin with.

1
c-regs1•

No you are right in setting the line ups. It ruins the fairness of the game if some people get free wins and this is an acceptable way to deal with it. Playoffs are a different story though. Just tell them If they are so “seasoned” why are they worrying about losing to a team that has given up?

1
N1NJAREB0RN•

I don’t like it because sometimes towards the end of a season it is ideal to throw a game if it puts your projected playoff matchup more in your favor.

1
JackSucks•

I totally get why you’d want to. Missing the playoffs because a team with a similar record chance’d into facing an owner who forgot to set a lineup sucks.

Why not call the owners with lineups not set though? Or ask them if they’d want you to at least put a starter in for them?

1
jonasdashMODAC Week 11 Top 10•

There is a Daily Thread for League Issues, please use it.

1
holcamania•

Create fines for people who play injured or empty slots.

0