r/Ska•
Brek_Shea

What is the easiest ska horn section instrument to learn?

I absolutely adore ska, especially ska punk. I also play guitar, bass, ukulele, banjo, and mandolin. I really want to learn to play ska so I can join a horn section one day.

What would be the easiest instrument to learn and play.

Bonus question: what is the most sought after position by ska bands?

Posted Aug 19, 2019, 3:56 PM UTC

3435
DuncanShifter•

Sax.

Bonus answer: sax.

Source: I'm a trombone player in a ska/reggae band.

34
evanparker•

i'm a bass player/guitar/horn in a few bands, I concur.

During initial learning, the very begining learning curve with the sax is a little bit hard getting the embouchure right, i think. The fingerings are a tiny bit less intuitive than like the half steps on a trumpet or a trombone slide, but one you know your scales and those fingerings cold, the sky is the limit.

Once you've done these very base basics, you go from zero to hero really fast. You you usually play as fast as you fingers can clack the buttons, which absolutely isn't the case with the trumpet/trombone.

The 'buzz' breathing is much more strenuous and requires a lot of practice to be able to do for a practice, or even a show.

There are also lots of interesting key saxes floating around, much more so than with the trumpet and trombone. It's easy to play the other types and fill in your skills to be more useful.

as for your bonus question. the most sough after position is always a drummer. There are often lots of drummers, but the few best ones always get to pick and choose quite easily what they end up doing.

4
DuncanShifter•

I guess I was coming at it from a horn'd perspective. I see it as horns are way more scarce than any other section. It's pretty much a given a ska-ish band needs horns or it's at least implied horns are optional and/or present. A sax can be a whole horn section. And Like you said, there's always drummers just most of them don't favor Ska or Reggae.

However, I can see your point in that finding a drummer that can do it and do it well is a tough proposition. And, no drummer - no band. Period. Whereas (contradicting myself a little bit from above), a band doesn't need to have horns in order to be a band or to play Ska.

3
Brek_SheaOP•

Thank you!! Can you link your band btw? I‘m always into discovering new music :) you can PM if you want

1
DuncanShifter•

The Fuss (live recording) - current band

Here's a Fuss studio track I'm fairly happy with

The Shifters - previous band

I've done other stuff but that's probably what I'm most known for (?) - if I'm known at all.

2
Brek_SheaOP•

Nice, I dig it!! DC too ... If y‘all are playing when I come in November I might check a show out :)

2
hawkearStupid Flanders•

Easiest: Sax

Most sought after: Trombone. Good trombonists are hard to find. Find one and treat them really well, even though they're odd.

10
squrr1•

Professional trombonists are all sluts:

They blow the bone for money.

6
dirt-merchant•

Amateurs blow the bone for free.

4
verranzo•

I have never met a Trombone player that wasn't a bit off... Source: Trombone player

1
sgt_squeaks•

Saxophone is easier than trumpet and trombone for beginners although you might end up spending more money over time on reeds.

If you have the natural ability to buzz your lips to make a sound on a brass instrument I would go with trombone. It’s an extremely versatile instrument and the buzzing is easier than trumpet. The positions aren’t that hard to learn if you already play instruments. I would recommend taking a few lessons to get going with it properly though.

9
ouishi•

I took a few trombone lessons and thought it was pretty easy, for what it's worth. I play a few other instruments though, so that could be why.

1
Brek_SheaOP•

I agree. If it were a string instrument I probably wouldn‘t because I‘m very accustomed to this musical family by now. But this is totally different... I‘ll take lessons :)

1
skatunenetwork•

Sax is the easiest instrument to make a sound on, however sax is the most likely for you to struggle based on the quality of the instrument. a shitty sax can make the instrument unplayable and theres a million different factors on why you aren't getting a sound.

brass is very touchy. People often form bad habits very quickly without proper guidance. I would say seek out lessons on how to develop a sound even if its a few lessons, or even one. it'll make a huge difference

4
dirt-merchant•

This guy should now. I heard he even plays the Hurdy Gurdy.

2
biscuitsboi•

i played/marched trombone throughout jr. high and high school, chosen in 7th grade, solely to be able to play in a ska band. then no one would start a ska band so i ended up playing guitar for years in different punk and hardcore groups.... anyways, i really loved playing trombone and think it's the most enjoyable instrument when done well, especially in ska.

...and you can easily transition to playing baritone/euphonium. i suppose i am just particular to low brass in general.

3
Brek_SheaOP•

Haha I‘m sorry!! :(

Thanks for the reply though. In my opinion trombone looks the coolest too.

3
Skibz777•

Weird, swap out "7th grade" for "10th grade" and your experience and opinions are literally the same as mine.

My condolences. -_-

2
Ramzavail05•

Trumpet is not easy.

3
stevenworks•

the giant sax the guy from fishbone plays

2
biscuitsboi•

i believe it's either a bass or bari sax

1
Matrillik•

Did an image search, looks like he mostly uses a bass sax. It’s a little bit bigger and a half-octave lower in pitch than a Bari sax.

3
paco_is_paco•

I could never get a sound to come out of a saxophone. I was a trumpet player in middle school band and highschool I marched F Horn which essentially a bigger trumpet.

Go to music store that gives lessons and they might let you try stuff out.

1
AnarchistForPrez•

Yup. I've only played trumpet of the listed instruments, but it is different for everyone and difficult to say for a certainty what would work best for you. Try them out, if you can. Take a lesson on each, if you are able and choose what you like best.

1
Chibi347•

Definitely sax. Tenor is usually an easier embouchure for beginners also

1
philanchez•

If you're the real Brek Shea you'd learn to play the Nah, nah, nah's like Toh Kay. The ska-est of horns.

1
Brek_SheaOP•

Just planning my career post-soccer!

No. I‘m just a fan :(

1
philanchez•

I'm gonna hold onto the image of Brek Shea, full dreadlocks, killing it on sax in a two-tone band.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
HalfRatTerrier•

Isn't there some story about King Django learning trombone positions while he was waiting around to audition with it?

1
antiquehats•

Im a multi-instrumentalist. This is not my main instrument, but Sax.

When i was in high school i got myself a used clarinet and a $3 lesson book, i was easily able to transition to sax when i learned the basics... which was like a couple weeks or so.

1
Brek_SheaOP•

Nice. How much did the sax cost?

1
antiquehats•

I didn't buy one, i borrowed my friend's tenor and later another friend's alto. Each were expensive, I'm not a serious reed instrument player, only wanted to learn it just to learn it... kept the clarinet for song writing and reference

1
keasbey•

It depends on your background. As a former flautist turned guitarist, sax. In general, our bass player picked up trombone more quickly than trumpet, didn't try sax.

1
Karlskiii•

My biggest struggle with trumpet was hitting the very high notes. The way you have to blow your lips like a raspberry takes its toll after a while.

I remember my trumpet teacher had a mouth like a cats butt hole from years of playing.

1