I finally got my book and there's a problem

I got my book in the mail last week and my wife, who plays in my campaign, opened it up to take a look. First page she opens it up to is Bonebreaker Dorokor... who I 'borrowed' and introduced to my campaign last week. My references are no longer obscure. Now I have to check if the other things I took from running the game series are in the books, or just hide it from her.

The book is awesome of course, I couldn't be happier.

Posted Aug 19, 2019, 5:54 PM UTC

17022
JanitorOPplznerf•

That's the risk she takes by looking behind the curtain.

​

I wouldn't be ashamed that you steal things, we all do. Especially if we're grown with bills, few people have the time and skill to write fantasy epics, that's why we pay people with the Middle initials of R.R. to do it for us.

But maybe you can re-name or re-skin some of the ideas so that it isn't quite so obvious.

108
oneeyedwarf•

Darn straight. DMing is a bit like a magic act. A good DM take us away from the act and into the illusion via verisimilitude.

Experienced players and other DMs know the act is not real but will play along.

22
Fuzzatron•

DM here, my current campaign is league of extrodinary gentlemen plus full metal alchemist, with a dash of power rangers. All my interesting characters taken right out of my favorite books, especially Sir Terry Pratchett.

6
Thebluespirit20•

That’s what I do a lot for my NPC’s

I made a Elf Rogue who looks just like Black Cat and is named Yennefer Snow after Yennifer from the Witcher and my favorite house in GoT

A Drow Blood Hunter named Geralt of Rivia who is basically a mixture of Geralt and Drizzt Do'urden

And a Dwarf Barbarian named Leroy Jenkins who is essentially Gimli from LOTR but I made him a drunk

Even a BBEG That is a Dragon Born Blood Hunter based off Darth Maul is one of my favorites

If it’s cool just copy it and find a way to add it into your game , that’s what I learned from Matt Colville ; just change it a bit or add some personal flair to it so your PC’s don’t call you out etc

5
JanitorOPplznerf•

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm pretty sure Snow is a name given to bastards in the North to ensure that they don't inherit their father's lands. Meaning there is no 'House Snow' the same way there is a House Stark or Lannister.

So John Snow & Ramsay Snow have the same last name, but they are not related.

2
takenbysubway•

You at least changed the name right?

2
JanitorOPplznerf•

I think you meant to reply to the OP

2
fang_xianfu•

Why would he need to?

1

Well, part of the problem is that it's not a DM's Only! book, it has plenty of stuff of interest to the players as well. And the adventure is right in the middle of the book.

2
JanitorOPplznerf•

Again "That's the risk you take by looking behind the curtain". I'm not saying "Don't read supplemental materials" as a player. I'm only saying that the deeper you dive into the source materials, the more it will be spoiled for you.

2
Capisbob•

Lol. Nice. Let her think she's on to you, and use that to pull the rug out from under her.

25
bardbarianboi•

This man, has the right idea

9
oneeyedwarf•

I’m liking the idea of Bonebreaker Dorkor is a title. There is always a Bonebreaker Orc. But the last Bonebreaker was so memorable they kept both names as a tribute.

4
Epsilon55•

That's why I'm using Doorbreaker Bonokor.

Renaming, reskinning, and mixing and matching NPCs and monsters is my jam. Gets you something seemingly original while not requiring an excess of creativity.

18
AssmeatOP•

That is amazing.

4
Seige83DM•

That’s when the goblins get a sponsor and are suddenly equipped with chain mail and long swords

9
Snakepipe_Hollow•

Kalarel the Vile was renamed Ral'Thul even though there was zero chance of anyone in the group knowing the Black Company or "Keep on the Shadowfell" and none had discovered Mr Colville's channel at that point.
Even if the players know I'm running "The Hidden Shrine of Tamoachan" or "The Village of Hommlet", names are usually changed. Not just to protect the innocent and the villainous, but because I may not like a particular name. Replacing an NPC is almost a certainty, too.
Swordbreaker Korodkha may make a cameo in a "Ghosts of Saltmarsh" campaign.

8
s_M_e•

”Stewart, what does momma say about little girls who eavesdrop?”

”Momma says, that little girls who eavesdrop, deserve... to learn the truth”

”and what does momma say about the truth?”

”Momma says, that the truth can often be devastating “

7
feyrath•

I dropped the shield of Andrim into my game and discovered who watches Matt’s videos. And Pinna is the hedge wizard in town. Well maybe more of a shrubbery mage.

5
DuckSaxaphone•

I stole Pinna for an unrelated quest line and then she turned up again as a town's hedge wizard as intended in the book. The party love her now and keep trying to push an important wizard they know into taking her on as a pupil.

5
Geodude671DM•

Just don’t tell the Knights of Ni.

2
spock1959•

I always rename characters so that this can't happen. They might realize they share similarities but they won't know if all I've changed is the name.

4