r/LegionFX•
David-89

Why Switch...

Spoiler

Why Switch thanked Syd for helping her when she was human? Yeah, because...she didn't. Seriously, she didn't. I didn't understand that part...

Posted Aug 21, 2019, 2:45 PM UTC

543
kingkoopazzzz•

I think she’s thanking all of them in general. If she hadn’t gotten involved with David, which she got involved because she witnessed Syd kill David, she would have never evolved into the 4th dimensional being that she became.

15
HereForTheDough•

If she hadn’t gotten involved with David, which she got involved because she witnessed Syd kill David, she would have never evolved into the 4th dimensional being that she became.

What? She evolved by dying. She wouldn't have died without all that nonsense? Her father states that she is essentially a member of a race of 4th dimensional beings. There was nothing implying that David torturing her to death because of his selfish desires remotely changed the fundamental nature of her species.

-1†

Was it just a matter of dying, or using her abilities to the point that she lost all her "baby teeth"? She never would have pushed herself as hard as David did. He was awful to her if course, but it was apparently necessary for her evolution.

17
HereForTheDough•

Was it just a matter of dying, or using her abilities to the point that she lost all her "baby teeth"?

She literally looked back at her corpse and her father told her she didn't need a body any longer.

She never would have pushed herself as hard as David did. He was awful to her if course, but it was apparently necessary for her evolution.

There is nothing suggesting it was necessary for anything. It was a crappy magical ending out of nowhere with nothing in the plot connected to it in any meaningful way except for the hackneyed 'daddy loves me, angel saves everything, bad guy turns good' ending.

-8

Ok cool. Sounds like you made up your mind already. Have fun hating!

12
kingkoopazzzz•

You didn’t understand it at all. I understand you have your opinion of the ending and that’s fine, but you missed so much obviously. She had to Lose all her baby teeth in order to pass on to the next level or “die and look back at her corpse” as you put it. How was it she was losing those teeth? By David pushing her to travel further and try harder. That’s the whole point of why she thanked them for helping her reach her destiny. I know your gonna think we’re all wrong, but it went over your head.

9

Was it just a matter of dying, or using her abilities to the point that she lost all her "baby teeth"? She never would have pushed herself as hard as David did. He was awful to her if course, but it was apparently necessary for her evolution.

5
pyriclastic_flow•

she evolved by using her powers to the point of her dying. she wouldn’t have done that unless all the shit that goes down in the show happened, hence why she is thanking syd and also (probably) thanked everyone else.

1
HereForTheDough•

So....the show said that...where?

She didn't 'evolve' from using her 'powers'. She was ALWAYS not human and a 4th dimension being. She was wearing a third dimensional sleeve of some kind, which is why she had the windup key in her neck. Her father never said "oh good, you evolved from using your powers". He said "we are 4th dimension beings and there's an entire society of us, and also a single timeline doesn't even matter" (paraphrased).

Switch was never a mutant with powers. She was a completely different species that exists in a different reality. The show never said anything about her not 'growing up' (essentially) without using her powers. In fact, after the series finale, there isn't even any evidence in the show that David putting strain on her was what made her lose her teeth. It could have easily been her reaching 4D being puberty that just coincided with the time travel.

0
pyriclastic_flow•

you need to get your eyes checked. literally every time she used her powers her teeth fell out. 5 seconds after she spit 20 teeth out because david kept her in the past so long her dad shows up saying that she “finally has her adult teeth”, signifying she “grew” up. the show literally said that her use of her powers caused her to finally “grow up”. (she obviously didn’t literally grow, but it was more of a metaphorical growth)

6
[deleted]•

No idea. Cary took Switch out to Division 3 and said she would be safer with them and they...put her into a tank seemingly against her will and let her stew in her own nightmares? Syd had zero problems about it.

6
Peter_G•

The whole story would have fallen apart if Syd hadn't have saved baby David from the blue meanies.

5
[deleted]•

Yes, she helped baby David. She didn't help Switch when she was human..

3
kel0700•

Syd and div 3 helped switched by hiding her from David. At the time switch didn't realise David was the bad guy but at the end when switch ascended she realised what David was doing and how syd and the gang had tried to help her.

0
[deleted]•

Syd and div 3 helped switched by hiding her from David. At the time switch didn't realise David was the bad guy but at the end when switch ascended she realised what David was doing and how syd and the gang had tried to help her.

Yeah, no.

4
kel0700•

Why no?

1
Tiny_Space_Ship•

Well, I think to answer this question we need to ask what did Switch receive help with?

As far as I can tell she received help reaching the full potential of her powers, and "ascending". That's her entire story line. So, by murdering Legion and creating his need for Switch, Syd helped Switch find the path toward her "ascension".

It's a pragmatic "help", not a moral "help".

5
rotarydialtone•

I think she means when Syd helped David by telling him where Switch was when she was inside the capsule in the Airship.

3
qaganoficeandfire•

Syd changed her goal from killing David (when Switch first was introduced) to protecting baby David and not interfering with Switch & David Prime restarting their collective timelines. That was Switch’s goal, and Syd and the gang were no longer adversaries; they were doing their own work toward that same endgame.

2
Slobotic•

Well, when D3 captured Switch they didn't kill her. Killing her would have prevented David from following through with any of his time travel plans. The conversation about what to do with Switch isn't something we ever see, so I couldn't say if Syd weighed in on that.

That's all I can think of, and it's a stretch. Good question.

1

Either she was referencing a deleted scene or it's just bad writing to make Syd seem like the hero she was never portrayed as.

1
TrueFaceMask•

Were all the "mutants" (not prof.X and shadow king) on the show LEGION. If not then i do not understand anything.

0
TraptNSuit•

Hawley was worried people would remember his interview saying Syd was the hero when she was really just The Terminator in this season with a tiny bit of Terminator 2 at the end.

-3†