Band of Brothers style military system?

Game Suggestion

Basically title. Been goin back to a setting I’d stopped working on and wanted to know if anybody’s ran this sorta thing before. A nice balance between grit and gamey-ness would be welcome. Ruling out Only War because I’d prefer something generic and it’s a bit too cannon foddery for the game concept.

Things I’d like to have: (apologies if this formatting is hideous I’m on mobile.)

  • Relatively simple combat rules. Nothing too complex but nothing too barebones either. Light crunch is acceptable.
  • Narrative focus would be awesome but not a requirement, I can compromise.
  • A focus on early to mid 20th Century combat would be cool.
  • Substantial equipment variation, even if I have to make it myself.

Thanks for looking.

Posted Aug 21, 2019, 7:42 PM UTC

513
JaskoGomad•

I think Band of Blades hits a lot of your points except mid-century setting. It's not generic though.

carry. a game about war or Patrol might be what you're after?

14
AnotherNameForSnowOPVeloCITY advocate supreme•

I’m givin Band of Blades a look as it’s been recommended twice now, lol. Might be able to scavenge some mechanics from the rest.

4
Sphere6•

Also came here to say Band of Blades, but not only is it tied very specifically to a setting, and fantasy theme, even with those removed it's still specifically about the tactical retreat after a devastating loss against an implacable enemy. It's gonna be hard to remove all those things and still have much game left.

8
arannutasar•

Yeah, changing the setting shouldn't require too much hacking, but changing the campaign structure from a fighting retreat to something else is going to require a major overhaul of the non-mission systems, which is solidly half of the rules.

1
SchillMcGuffin•

I'll get in the obligatory suggestion of GURPS here. It's not necessarily complex for players -- certainly scalable to "light crunch", but the GM might have to do a fair amount of work in character creation and prep. The major plus is a wealth of WWII sourcebooks for 3e (there are a few key mechanical differences between that and the current 4e -- which is actually streamlined relative to 3e -- but the sourcebooks translate over pretty easily).

Going really old-school, FASA produced a WWII role-playing game called Behind Enemy Lines back in the '80s. If you can find an affordable copy, it'd probably a good system fit. It's simpler than GURPS by virtue of being setting-specific, rather than "Universal", and pretty well meets your bullet points. Since it never really found an audience, it didn't build up much of a source library -- its setting and equipment are Western Front 1944-45 focused, though they did also publish a "British Commandos" supplement and a "Guns of Navarone" module.

12
AnotherNameForSnowOPVeloCITY advocate supreme•

Yeah I’m thinking GURPS will be the winner here, and if I can find Behind Enemy Lines I’ll give it a look! Thanks yo.

3
Corvus_Lupus•

Savage World's: Weird War II. Just take out the "weird".

4
imneuromancer•

Have not seen it yet or read it, but from what I have heard Band of Blades would do the trick.

It is a fantasy version of band of brothers, kinda, so either using that world ornadapting its moves to wwii era combat could work.

3
Rauwetter•

For a narrative focus there is also Ross Rifles—that is based on PbtA.

There are some other sources next to the GURPS Sourcebooks fur stats, like 3G from BTRC, Phoenix Command Small Arms Combat System, Twilight 2013, Millenniums End Tactics and Investigations Handbook, Millenniums End Ultra Modern Firearms—but the systems are all crunchy like hell.

For GURPS there are WWII (3e) and Dogfaces (3e) (among others). Perhaps GURPSlight is an option, e.g. the Hellboy RPG is using them.

And for CoC there is of course No Man's Land and Achtung Cthulhu!

2
Rauwetter•

There are some other sources next to the GURPS Sourcebooks fur stats, like 3G from BTRC, Phoenix Command Small Arms Combat System, Twilight 2013, Millenniums End Tactics and Investigations Handbook, Millenniums End Ultra Modern Firearms–but the systems are all crunchy like hell.

For GURPS there are WWII (3e) and Dogfaces (3e) (among others). Perhaps GURPSlight is an option, e.g. the Hellboy RPG is using them.

And there is also Ross Rifles—that is based on PbtA.

1
ShuffKorbik•

Palladium's Recon might work. It's set during the Vietnam conflict, but that should be easy to change. It offers a decent range of tactics and the rules are still quick and easy. It doesn't use the usual Palldium system, but instead bases most things off of d100 rolls.

1
mrh216•

Ghost Ops. You can get it with its own rules system or adapted to Savage Worlds. It's a bit more modern but you could definitely stat WWII weapons and vehicles (if somebody hasn't already).

1
aston_za•

Worth mentioning Operation: White Box, which is an OD&D clone modified to work for WWII. At least thematically it is aiming for the stuff that you want, although I doubt that it has everything. Still, I believe that it is free, so worth looking at, at least.

1