Just another "Tell me what you think"
A while back there was a bunch of posts about keeping a blog just to keep writing, practice, or get started writing, I really liked the idea, and just brought everything together (art, concept etc) anyways I was hoping you could let me know what you think of my first real post, thanks.
Posted Jul 27, 2010, 3:06 AM UTC
42
If this is supposed to be a stand-alone piece, I think you need to work on the flow quite a bit. It plunges in without any context or stated purpose and then becomes a list of short summaries followed by conclusions that aren't tied back to earlier information or adequately explained. I read it a few times and didn't get it. It kind of reads like a school essay where the writer is trying to meet a word count and expects the reader to already be familiar with the text.
Rewrite this from the top down, take your time, set up your purpose, and make an effort to explain and support your conclusions in the "wheat from the chaff" section. There are some grammatical issues as well but I'd ignore those for now. One approach that might work (it does for me) is to completely rewrite your conclusions without using any of the same language. It will make you think more carefully about what you're trying to get across. Then use what you learn in that exercise to rewrite the rest.
Hope this is helpful.
Thank you very much! I didn't quite feel like the first one was right, I'm not used to this type of writing and I guess I needed a push in the right direction. Sorry it took me so long to get back to you, but I wanted something to show for it. If it's not too much trouble I'd love to hear your thoughts / critiques on the updated version.