It's that time again

Im sure everyone is already tired of seeing these, but I’m doing it anyway. I was really hoping to see a bit more last night to make a few of these calls, but it is what it is. The game still provided some clarity at a few positions. All the players I list are ones that I think are making it, with what I think are obvious locks named as well. Unfortunately a few of these spots will be decided by injury news, that I have not yet seen.The 24D/26O split reflects the available talent. I would prefer to go 26D/24O for more ST players, but I think we’ll just have to make do. Cutting players like Tonyan or Davis, or going with 8 OL are just not palatable to me.

I went ahead and listed the prediction and made a separate comment for a more detailed breakdown of each side of the ball.

24 Defense

6 CB - Jaire, King,Jackson, Brown, Tramon, Hollman (Locked)

4 S - Amos, Savage, Greene (Locked)

Cambell add Jamerson if ESB on IR

2 NT - Clark, Lancaster (Locked)

4 DE -Lowry, Adams, Keke (Locked)

Looney

3 ILB - Martinez(Locked)

the 2 healthy of Burks, Bolton, Summers

5 EDGE -ZD, Preston, Gary, Fackrell (Locked)

Gilbert

26 Offense

5 OG - Turner, Elgton (Locked)

Taylor, Madison, McCray

3 OT - Bahk, Bulaga (Locked)

Light

1 C - Linsley (Locked)

2 QB - Rodgers (Locked)

Boyle

4 RB - Jones, J. Williams, Vitale (Locked)

D. Williams

4 TE - Graham, Lewis, Sternberger (Locked)

Tonyan

6-7 WR - Adams, GMo, MVS, Kumerow (Locked)

ESB, Davis, Shepard

1 K - Crosby

1 LS, 1 P

Practice Squad - Ento, Jamerson, Sagapolu, Crawford, Sheldon, Keith Ford, Moore, Redding, Lazard, Fadol Brown

Posted Aug 23, 2019, 6:11 PM UTC · edited

1836
Bouwistrash•

Man I don't know if that Rodgers guy is a lock. Haven't seen him do anything in preseason

22
freetogoodhome__•

He has a clean sheet so far

2
KrookedasFuck•

I think Tonyan is a bigger lock than Lewis or Kumerow.

20
vanweOP•

Lewis is a great blocker, which none of our other TEs are. In addition we just signed him to another deal this offseason. The Staff obviously likes him.

Kumerow is a big lock, partly because we're starting to use him on ST, and we need some offensive players to contribute on ST. So far, Tonyan hasn't.

7
KrookedasFuck•

Lewis was a great blocker, but he’s 35 and wasn’t particularly good last year. He’s also guaranteed only $500K. It wouldn’t be a shocking cut if they think he doesn’t have anything left.

5
vanweOP•

He still blocked great last year, when they actually used him. But they only used him on 17% of the plays last year. Instead they kept tasking Graham to block, with predictable results. Our misuse of our TEs last year was one of my bigger complaints.

2
Arkaein•

The few scouting reports I read said that Lewis was no better than an average blocker last year. If you have reports otherwise, I'd like to see them.

I'd reverse Tonyan and Lewis. Tonyan is basically a lock at this point, and Lewis has shown little since he's joined the Pack to say he needs to make the roster. His position early in the season looks stronger with both Graham and Sternberger dealing with injuries, but otherwise I don't see a big role for him, regardless of the type of offense La Fluer wants to run.

3
Bouwistrash•

You can't be serious... We NEED a blocking TE and Lewis is by far our best blocking TE currently. Now I think we probably keep 4 TEs but Tonyan isn't a lock over Lewis and sure as hell isn't a lock over Kumerow who now with the unfortunate injury to ESB is our WR4 at the least and might crack the top 3 as the season goes on (emphasis on might).

-1
vanweOP•

Offense

OG Turner starts at RG. Elgton makes the roster as either a backup or starting LG. If Elgton starts(and I think he will), I think we try to trade Taylor. This is the only reason he is not a lock, and if we can’t trade him, he is a lock. If he gets traded add Patrick to this list. Madison has looked good in pass pro, less so at run blocking. He is still quality depth if either Turner slides over or Elgton has to move to C. McCray makes the team as basically the 3rd string RG,C, and LG. I could see keeping Patrick over Madison as Patrick is not PS eligible and Madison is. But I don’t think that happens because Madison would get poached by another team.

OT Bahk, and Bulaga are possibly the best OT duo in the league. I expect Light to be the primary backup, with Turner able to slide over as an additional backup.

C Linsley is rock solid. Elgton will serve as his backup with McCray able to take snaps in a pinch.

QB Rodgers. For his backup it looks like Boyle. Through week 1-2 Boyle and Kizer looked effectively the same. But that was Kizer with the 2s and Boyle with the 3s. This week, Boyle looked noticeably better than Kizer had with the 2s, and Kizer looked noticeably worse than Boyle had with the 3s. The competition isn’t over, but Boyle has a solid lead now. I imagine we are trying to trade Kizer, but I think teams know he is going to be a free agent soon.

RB Jones is the starter. For all the talk of a committee, I expect him to get the majority(~60%) of touches as long as he stays healthy. J Williams will be used to spell Jones. His usage will be mostly to keep Jones fresh and healthy. Vitale has killed it so far this preseason. I expect him to see usage in most 2 RB sets, and splitting work with J Williams. This is of course if he’s back to being healthy, which it looks like he will be. Dexter has a solid hold on the remaining spot. He won’t see much usage if the 3 ahead of him stay healthy, mostly because of his well documented catching issues. Tra Carson played well last night, but that’s really the only time so far this offseason he has. Hall and Ford end up on the PS.

TE For all the hate, Graham played like an above average starting TE last year. Combined with the fact that we save almost no cap space by cutting him, he is a lock. There is no possible way we cut a 3rd round TE before his rookie season, Sternberger is a lock. Lewis has been one of the best blocking TEs in the league for several years. Coincidentally that is something no other TE on our roster is good at. Combined with the fact that we just signed him, he is a lock to me. Tonyan has looked very good all offseason. I could see him being the odd man out if we absolutely needed the roster spot at another position, but don’t bet on that.

WR Adams is elite. GMo looks as good as he did early last season, MVS looks much improved, and Kumerow has been killing it this offseason. In addition, Kumerow has shown willingness to be a ST gunner. They are all obvious locks. ESB looked good last year, however he has looked lackluster this offseason and just had an injury last night. Depending on the injury he could be a surprise cut. I find it more likely he starts on IR and bumps someone off the roster when he’s back to being healthy, which is why I have him on my list. Davis and Shepard have both been playing very well, both as WRs and as returners. I think they both get roster spots. Moore looked good early in camp this year, then the 1st preseason game came around. He’ll go to the PS, though another team might poach him. I could see Lazard making the 53 if ESB is on IR, but I think it’s more likely going to a ST guy like Jamerson or Redmond.

6

great write up, most of which I agree with. I think Tonyan has become a lock, and that we'll go into the season with 4 TEs.

Lewis is a free agent next year, and while Jimmy has another two years on his deal, he can easily be moved on from after this season. Meaning while Graham/Lewis may be the slotted in starters this year, neither one is going to be here long term.

Sternberger was obviously taken to eventually replace one of them. And I think the team believes Tonyan can also be a long term starter after Lewis and Graham are gone. He's only 25 and was often running with the first team in 12 personnel during camp. He may be the 2nd best receiving TE on the roster tight now, and has been consistently improving while he's been in Green Bay.

Tonyan potential role in the future of the offense is much more significant than anyone we'd keep at the 7th WR spot or 4th RB spot, and I think that locks him in.

3
vanweOP•

I essentially agree about the plan next year. I have Tonyan listed because I think he makes the team. I don't have him as a lock because he is a possible cut if something unforeseen happens and we need the roster spot for another position. He's not the only player in that position, nor would he be the first to go.

He may have more of an impact than a 4th RB, but there is no way we go into the season with only 3. Jones and J Williams's injury concerns are often overblown, but they do exist. And Vitale has an injury this preseason. 4 is kinda the minimum for RBs if you don't have a bellcow.

I could see him picked and only one of Davis/Shepard on the roster, but I don't think that will be a choice the FO has to make.

2
WL1054•

Tonyan over lewis as a lock got TE

2
vanweOP•

Defense

CB I think this lineup is pretty set. Jackson looks improved enough, Tramon is valuable depth for both CB and S and Brown has been killing it so far. I would like to have a spot for Ento, but I think Hollman has clearly outdone him, and there’s just not enough room for both. Our depth actually looks very good with 6 CBs. Ento will be on the practice squad and called up when an injury happens.

S Amos is clearly a starter. Savage is likely starting beside him, though Greene has made a solid case for being more than depth. These 3 are locks. I think Campbell takes the 4th spot because of his veteran status. He is a solid depth player. I think there is something going on with Jones. There were the reports early in camp that he wanted out, and now he hasn’t played at all in the preseason. He’s gone. We might try to put him on the PS, but he wont stay there. Jamerson is likely a practice squad player this year.

NT I think 2 is all we keep. Clark and Lancaster are clearly the #1 and #2. Sagapolu is on the PS. This is quite thin, but we will likely only have 1 of these players on the field most of the time. And expect ZD and Gary to take some snaps as IDL.

DE Lowry, Adams, and Keke are locks. The 4th spot goes to the best special teams contributor, which looks like Looney to me. F Brown will be on the PS. This might look thin, but again remember that ZD and Gary are likely going to taking some snaps at “DE”.

ILB Martinez is a lock. But with Burks and Bolton both having injuries, Summers is the only other healthy ILB that has looked like he deserves to be playing there. We will see what the injuries say, and if Bolton is back to healthy by week 1 he is a lock. Burks is a bit of a mystery, we just havent seen much of him this offseason. If both Burks and Bolton are healthy by roster cuts, then Summers is the odd man out. Crawford and maybe Summers on the PS.

OLB ZD, Preston, Gary, and Fackrell are all locks. Gary’s injury does not look severe from reports, so he should be ready early in the season, maybe by week 1. The 5th spot goes to a ST stud, Gilbert.

2
pookachu123•

Lane Taylor is a lock

2
vanweOP•

If you read the breakdown that I posted, I don't have him listed as a lock because he might get traded. If Elgton wins the starting LG spot, I expect us to try to trade him. I also said that if he is not traded, he is a lock.

2
pookachu123•

oh sorry my bad

1
BlueBadger99•

Why would the Packers trade Taylor....I honestly think that’s a really bad idea

1
vanweOP•

He'd be very overpaid as a backup and interior OL is one of the positions that we have good depth at. In addition he is good enough to start for a number of teams out there, so he has real trade value. If he's not gonna start for us, trading him would save cap space and possibly land us a position of need.

I'm not saying trade him for a 7th round draft pick or something. In order trade him away we would need to get something of value in return, like a veteran ILB.

1
BlueBadger99•

Eh his contract is really a bargain to begin with, idk why people fret over a small cap hit like Taylor’s. I’d rather hold on to him and have a high quality backup.

1
Floodingpuddle•

Pretty much the only disagreement I have is I would put Fadil Brown on instead of Looney if he's healthy

1
vanweOP•

I went back and forth between them. Looney got a lot of ST snaps, which is why I ended up going with him.

1
Floodingpuddle•

You may be right, I was just hearing a lot more about Brown in camp before he went down. Also I think Manny Wilkins makes the practice squad

2
highlanderiicSpot 2018 Champion•

Practice Squad - Ento, Jamerson, Sagapolu, Crawford, Sheldon, Keith Ford, Moore, Redding, Lazard, Fadol Brown

I hate when people even attempt to speculate on practice squads because it's not even in the Packers control. I doubt Lazard or Moore clear waivers. Then if they do clear, why return on the PS into a team with a log jam at receiver when they could go somewhere else without one.

add Jamerson if ESB on IR

If ESB is placed on IR he needs to be on the initial 53-man roster. So Jamerson would have to clear waivers.

1
vanweOP•

I debated on whether to include a PS. I decided to go with a list of players I would try to sign to the PS. If you read the breakdown I posted, I mention several players getting poached off our PS.

If ESB is placed on IR he needs to be on the initial 53-man roster.

Does that rule work differently during the preseason or something? My understanding, and what a quick internet search confirmed is that IR players do not count as a roster spot on the 53, though they do count against the salary cap.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
vanweOP•

I did not know that, thank you.

If you read the breakdown I posted I mention either Jamerson or Redmond as taking ESBs roster spot. It would take a couple of extra steps but the result by week 1 would be the same. Name ESB on the 53, then place him on IR. I think at least one of Jamerson or Redmond will clear waivers, so just pick them back up now that ESB is on IR and there you have it.

3
Covertghost•

Shepherd has impressed me more than anyone on O this offseason, honestly.

On paper he isn't tall or super fast, but he's played a lot taller and faster than his sheet says.

1
vanweOP•

He has far outplayed my expectations. I expect him to be on the 53, because there is no chance he clears waivers.

1
Muaythaikrav•

I'd say davis is a lock. Hes the exact type of gadget player their new offense needs. I

1
vanweOP•

He's had health issues and he's towards the back end of the depth chart. I could see us cutting him and using Shep at KR. I don't think it's likely, which is why I have him listed as making the roster, but it is possible.

1
jair_834•

Can you explain why Sternberger is a lock and Tonyan isnt?

0
vanweOP•

There is no possible way we cut a 3rd round TE before his rookie season.

6
GriffinDMighty•

3rd round pick

1