What are the function of these chords?

Question

I recently wrote a song, and at the end, it uses two chords that lead to the tonic. Here are the chords: Cmin7add9, Bmaj7, Bbmaj. What are the function of the first two chords?

Posted Aug 23, 2019, 6:56 PM UTC · edited

311
Coocoobananas7•

Somebody will probably come along with a better explanation since I'm not a jazz buff, but the half step down to B is a substitution where somebody would usually go to F in a classic II-V-I. So it's a variation on the II-V-I. The sus2, and using Bmaj7 instead of B7, are very nice touches :)

5
cthomas1501•

Correct! Tritone Substitution to be precise

6
Jongtr•

A tritone susbstitution would be B7, not Bmaj7.

1
MyDadsUsername•

Can you explain for me what the "sus2" means in this case? I had assumed the chord could be C7sus2 or Cm9, but never Cm7sus2. Doesn't the presence of sus2 imply no third?

1
Coocoobananas7•

I'm not sure on this one either, but although neither Cm7sus2 nor C7sus2 has the third, I think C7sus2 implies it would resolve to a C7 (as in C major). So the notes are the same, but if we're in the key of Bb, it would resolve to Cm7.

And yea, I think it'd be more common to write Cm9, which has a very similar feel as Cm7sus2 in this context, even though it contains the minor third.

1
bubbleboy222OP•

Thanks for the explanation! Now it makes sense with the ii-V-I tritone substitution. With the confusion on the first chord, that was my fault with writing the name. It's actually a Cmin7add9. Apologies for that mistake.

1
smk4813•

Yes. sus2 is where the third is subbed for the second (e.g., Dsus2 is D E A). sus4 is where the third is subbed for the fourth (e.g., Dsus4 is D G A). C7sus2 would have been the correct symbol.

1
smk4813•

u/cthomas1501 and u/Coocoobananas7 are pretty close. The regular tritone substitution would be ii-bII7-I. Here, instead of B7 subbing for F7, we have the major 7th version instead. So all together it's ii^sus - bII - I. The functions are subdominant - dominant - tonic. Subs retain the function of the chord they're replacing.

3
cthomas1501•

You’re right, I missed the maj7 part! What’s your opinion of the use of the maj7 in this context the dominant 7? I think it gives it a less ‘proper’ sound and that makes it modern and intriguing.

1
smk4813•

What’s your opinion of the use of the maj7 in this context the dominant 7?

Still dominant in function given its composition. With the M7 instead of the m7, the internal tritone of the chord is lost, so it loses some bite/tension. But it's like you said...

I think it gives it a less ‘proper’ sound and that makes it modern and intriguing.

Agreed. It's not 'proper' because we're so used to hearing a B7 instead, but the altered tension that the M7 presents offers a rare and definitely appealing sound.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Jongtr•

Bmaj7 can be interpreted two ways - or ratther two angles on the same way:

  1. Phrygian cadence. I.e., Cbmaj7, borrowed from Bb phrygian mode.
  2. Substitute for the minor iv. Cbmaj7 is Ebm with Cb bass. Ebm is the minor iv in Bb major, borrowed from Bb minor. But obviously the Cb adds the phrygian element.

As mentioned, it's close to a tritone substitute, but that would be B7. That one note difference makes the difference between a dominant sub (B7 standing for F7) and a minor iv sub (Bbmaj7 standing for Ebm), because B7 has the leading tone.

1