r/xkcd•
WallofMath

Personally Impactful Comics

I feel like my early internet (but also kinda real) life was informed by xkcd. As in there are a number of these comics that I can point towards as the starting point of a lot of ideas that I think are important now. These kinds of strips also appear in other web comics (this is an example from smbc), but xkcd was the first to really grab me and stick in a certain way.

Some of this is just because xkcd was my first exposure to an idea like in http://xkcd.com/659/ (the paradox of Theseus's ship). Others of them I really really enjoy Randal's take on a concept https://xkcd.com/505/ (what you do with infinite time alone somewhere).

I was wondering if other people here have had a similar experience with the comic and what are your own favorite 'impactful' xckd strips.

Some of my favorite comics like this are linked here (with some needless commentary by me):

https://xkcd.com/48/ -The random chance of loving someone.

http://xkcd.com/847/ - Tolkien quote/dealing with rough times

http://xkcd.com/614/ -doing something nice to something that might not understand why.

http://xkcd.com/701/ -You don't use science to show you are right. You use science to become right. (I like this one mainly because of the alt text, but also the honesty with himself in his approach to relationships.

https://xkcd.com/2013/ - A brief moment of existence then 'nothing'.

​

Edit: I think I'ill try and update this list with what people have recommended below and some others that I remembered while procrastinating going through some old comics.

https://xkcd.com/114/ - Some people believe computational linguistics is a real field.

https://xkcd.com/356/ - Nerd sniping.

https://xkcd.com/931/ - Cancer sucks.

https://xkcd.com/1106/ - Time management is hard.

https://xkcd.com/1259/ - Memory of a flower species

https://xkcd.com/1305/ -This is another we don't exist forever one

https://xkcd.com/1498/ - Terry Pratchett tribute.

https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/1987/03/09 - someone didn't get the hint and posted calvin and hobbes, but they seem cool so its okay.

Posted Aug 24, 2019, 7:02 PM UTC · edited

12417
eliteslaDanish•

701 hits pretty close to home. I actually did something very similar for an anniversary gift (basically, I analyzed our text messages for patterns). Unfortunately, it turned out that all the slopes were negative; we were talking less, meeting less, and our text messages became less affectionate with each passing month. Not surprisingly, we broke up soon after. Turns out she had been cheating on me for a while. Go figure.

Still, it’s kinda cool to be able to make those kinds of predictions

44
connor135790•

How did you go about analysing them?

1
eliteslaDanish•

I don't recall the specifics but it was something along the lines of:

  • Downloaded all the messages through Facebook (there was something like 100k of them. Long distance is a hell of a thing). Importantly, they contained both a timestamp and the nickname of the sender.

  • Wrote a Python script to clean up the raw data and separate it by sender

  • Plotted a moving average of messages sent/received per day and month, the average response time, number of emojis, average call duration

It's too bad that I lost it. It probably would have made a good post on r/dataisbeautiful.

2
Leo_HelianthasBeret Guy but with glasses•

I really like the one about the rock computer you linked, and "find you", but I think my personal favourite is the one about the bee orchid. Make you think about what mark we leave on this world, etc.

27
AnteaterofPower•

Here’s the link for the bee orchid one: https://xkcd.com/1259/

19
WallofMathOP•

My gmail icon for like most of college was a photo of this flower.

2
Jack_of_Shadows•

Terry Pratchett had an incredible impact on my life. This simple tribute is the most beautiful way I could imagine expressing the profound effect his writing had on my world view. I didn't cry the day he died, but I did the next day reading this.

24
WallofMathOP•

I've never read Terry Pratchett, do you have a book of his that I should start with?

2
Jack_of_Shadows•

Probably the best place to start is "Guard! Guards!" Another good one would be "The Wee Free Men", especially for younger readers. The quote in the comic is from one of the books in "The Bromeliad Trilogy", which I'd also highly recommend.

He has published a lot of books so if you decide you like his style you will be entertained for quite a while!

3
badwhiskey63•

Calvin and Hobbes: The Racoon Story. It starts here: https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/1987/03/09 Read them all through until the last one on March 18, 1987. There's a Sunday one in the middle which is not part of that same story thread.

Edit: I missed that this was only a question about xkcd comics. But I'm leaving this because it is so good.

18
tingerfips•

I would say Calvin and Hobbes were very influential on me from 10-college. Xkcd I found while in college and kind of took its place.

I still go back to Calvin and Hobbes every once in awhile. I know I'll have my kids read them some day.

7
LandSharkSociety•

114 is what introduced me to the phrase "computational linguistics", which is what I now study! It's become a bit of a dream field for me. Take that, Randall.

13
AnGenericAccountFell for the temptation of spreadsheet algorithms•

Why is the image an smbc comic?

4
jpzygnerski•

I think reddit picks the first link for the image

10
mrmastermattler•

A lot of the messages here are personal or deep, but one that’s important to me is 365 nerd sniping. Me and my friends really liked the idea, and we’ve taken the idea to mean any time we get someone hooked on our personal interest, they got sniped

3
WallofMathOP•

I think this is the prototypical xkcd. It might have been the first one somebody showed me and its just such a good one.

2
microtrash•

https://xkcd.com/931/ Unfortunately hits home for me and probably a lot of other people. Sometimes I just think 'Fuck Cancer' and I can't help but crying a little.

3
Jellye•

The Choices series was pretty relevant for me at the time, and honestly made me rethink some stuff.

https://xkcd.com/264/

2
WallofMathOP•

I had forgotten about this story line, thank you.

2