Gauls Who Collaborated With Romans
According to the book Gallic Wars by Caesar, when he went into Gaul there were some tribes and villages who almost immediately accepted Roman rule, while other areas rebelled. The tribes who rebelled were mainly decimated.
The question I have is: has anyone investigated the possibility that the tribes who readily accepted Roman rule may have been not ethnically part of the dominant culture of Gaul at the time?
From what I hear the main culture in Gaul was Celtic, although there was possibly German tribes too. But as far as the Celts are concerned they too were said to have invaded Gaul at some point in time subduing and perhaps to a degree displacing a previous population that would have been more indigenous to Gaul than the Celts.
And so what the Romans did in Gaul may have been a repetition of what the Celts did, militarily subduing a previous population.
So with this information it leads to the speculation that its possible that the tribes who readily accepted Roman rule may have viewed the Celts as invaders who had displaced other ethnic groups, and perhaps that could have been a reason why some tribes who accepted Roman rule were quick to accept Roman rule.
However this is speculation on my part, I don't know if anyone has investigated this sort of thing or if investigating it would even be possible. I have also heard that Celt referred more to a culture than an ethnic group, and the Celtic tribes were often hostile to each other.
Posted Aug 25, 2019, 11:29 PM UTC
As your question covers three aspects, namely ethnicity and culture in independent Gaul, their organisation and institutional strength, and the reason why Roman conquest and romanization were particularly quick, we'd have to covers each separately.
On the matter of ethnicity, first. What we'd call an ethnic group nowadays might not be the best tool in our mental toolbox to address ancient societies : we tend to consider ethnic groups as strongly particular groups distinguished by a core value, with groups being similar to their neighbours except for one of these core values (say religion), being treated as different ethnics. While the concept of ethnicity or relative ethnics might be more useful there, we can spare the expense and go right at the matter at hand.
It is important to stress right away that as far as we can tell, and in the conditions of its emergence during the Iron Age, Gaulish culture is largely indigenous, and is not a product of an elite invasion in recent history : while it have been argued since the XIXth century, archeologically, a continuity is rather observable since the Bronze Age in most of Gaul.Does that means that Gauls shared a similar culture, or represented a same ethnic group from Pyrenees to Rhine? It's quite more complex, and we shall look at the periphery first.
When Greeks landed in Gaul in the VIIth century BCE, they immediately contacted local peoples and called them Lyges or Ligurians, who spawned from the Arno to the Herault rivers.It would be tempting (and many were tempted since the XVIIIth century) to consider these Ligurians as a group of related people, culture-bearers of either a remaining larger Ligurian culture replaced by invading Gauls (Amédée Thierry's thesis), or an hold-out of a non-Celtic culture which had been tentatively identified with anything remotely plausible and then some (from Etrusceans to Phoenicians, including Basques, pre-IE, a first iteration of Celts, etc.).
The main problem is that while Ligurians does participate to a meta-civilisation of oppidae (which covered the Mediterranean arc from Spain to Italy), they are not really different from their neighbours in the hinterland, and tend to differ among themselves : it is why the term Ligurian is now more and more considered with extreme caution and rarely an option of identification.But if Ligurians, in terms of material culture, can't be differentiated from Celtic or Italic peoples, what would have they been?
A first element of answer is in their name : it is now assumed that Lyges is a Greek word for "Howlers", comparable to Barbarian in the sense it names people unable to speak properly, because Greeks were just this polite and tactful. The Ligurian shore, the Ligustikè, would then be a Barbarian shore defined first and first-most from a Greek geo-social point of view. Hecate of Milet, by describing Ligurians as one of the "outermost" people with Scythians and Ethiopians (themselves not that well defined either) is making a similar conceptual point (and it's interesting to note that Ligurians hold the same place that Celts would have for Greeks in this matter).Greek scholars doesn't give us much about what these Ligurians were, except telling that Greeks settled among them when founding Massalia (the Ligurian tribe they dealt with bearing the quite obviously Gaulish name of Segobriges).By the Vth century BCE, Greeks begin to use a different name for these peoples, at least in Gaul : Celto-Lyges, or Celto-Ligurians. It was traditionally understood as the result of a Celtic invasion or takeover by a Gaulish elite : then again, not only it is not attested in tradition, there's no real archeological evidence for this.Dominique Garcia, Sophie Colin Bouffier and Philippe Bossinot (following the idea proposed by Roger Dion) if Ligurians are not a precise people but the barbarous societies Greek encountered there, the addition of Celto- might be a tentative to refine the definition with the new knowledge obtained by Massaliots.
At first glance, it only pushes the problem into the definition of Celts, that u/Typology well put there : without entering the debate of the accuracy of the name Celt in modern historiography, let's focus on what the word meant in the Vth century for Greeks, and maybe for Gauls. *Keltoi might have been a Ligurian people, or a Ligurian confederation of people as Salyes, Cavares, etc. that would have formed out of the necessity to deal with Massalia in matters of trade, exchanges but also war (as local peoples began to push back Massalia out of its coastal hinterland at the same period). As such an alliance (*Keltoi would have meant something like "Associates" in this context) had obvious benefits, it would have met with a regional success, with most people there joining the Celtic bandwagon.From there, Greeks would have acknowledged the existence of a specific group, maybe different culturally from Ligurians in Corsica or Italy, and would have called their neighbours "Celto-Ligurians" to refine their point of view just like we use "Amerindian" instead of "Indian".From this point, Celt had been used by Greeks to define the whole of the barbarous hinterland, just like Ligurian had been used for the whole barbarous shore. In the same time, the use of Celt to name not only the general alliance, but the grouping of related people might have led to its systematisation in a good part of Gaul although never, regardless what Caesar said, used as a cultural endonym.
Does that mean there was not any Ligurian specificity? Probably not, but it's hard to assert which ones due to both the lack of evidence from one hand, and nonsensical affirmations made since the XVIIIth century. Linguistically, the -i/oscos and -ica radicals might be indication of some particularity (although they are found elsewhere in Gaul) and it's not impossible that a stronger non-Celtic substrate might have influenced the local language. But, from what we know of both Gaulish language, and the study of Celto-Ligurians names and place names, it seems unmistakably Gaulish.
Cultural differentiation among Celto-Ligurians took rather the form of a much stronger Hellenistic influence in urbanism, the use of a Greek script to write Gaulish, and a lesser grasp of Druidism on the artistic representation (while Gaulish art is strongly aniconic generally). Celto-Ligurians might have realized their difference with other Gaulish peoples, and have asserted their specific interests in their relation with Massalia (either peaceful or hostile), and have formed their own assemblies to deal with local matter among them. It remains highly speculative, but not unthinkable in the light of Gaulish institutions we'll talk about later.While considered as Celtized, some Ligurian peoples or tribes in Italy are generally not lumped together with Gaulish Celto-Ligurians in modern historiography.
They weren't the only people Greeks first met, tough, and the case for Iberians in Celtic Gaul is quite interesting : indeed, Greeks weren't the only traders appearing in the region, and Phoenician trade with Spain bolstered inner dynamics and commercial networks in the peninsula. As Gaul was rich in grain and metals (which would remain its main exportation until the IInd century BCE), Iberian traders went north, participating to a prosperous trade and incidentally leading to the cultural iberisation of local population, maybe Ligurians (and certainly Ligurians between the Herault and Rhone rivers). While there is no trace of invasion, the cultural make-up of the coastline by the VIth century BCE is clearly changing, and not only material culture but Greeks accounts as well as short texts (from coinage, especially) in Iberic language and script are all converging to prove this.Iberians of Celtic Gaul would have been, like Bretons in Armorica, or Romans in Gaul, culture-bearers on a native (probably more or less Celtic) population.
These Iberians are more well known than Ligurians, and not only we know of several of their names, such as Sardones or the Elisyices thanks to their tradition of mercenariate in Carthage, but they took the same interest than their eastern neighbours in trade, although attracting Phoenicians, then Etruscans (who founded an important trade post in the mixed Ligurian-Iberian region at Lattara) and Italic rather than Greek.By the IVth and IIIrd century, tough, the Celtic world knew a period of expansion coming from the Upper Danubian regions : it is best known trough the expeditions in Italy and Greece, but not only it led to a strong Celtic presence in Central and South-Eastern Europe (as well as Anatolia), but some peoples seem to have moved westward, in smaller and more scattered groups maybe, but in an archeologically attested manner. Some of these formed groups called the Volcae, who settled the modern Languedoc and seem to have slowly took the lead in the region : mostly trough political absorption, but the utter destruction of the oppidum of Pech-Maho in the wake of the Second Punic War could point Volcae did resorted to warfare too for affirming their power : by the early IInd century, they dominated the region that they might have re-Celtized rather than ruling as overlords in a foreign land.
A third component of this southern Gaulish world is clearly the biggest counter-example of what I said above : Aquitains were utterly a foreign part of Gaul. Their language is obviously not Gaulish but related to Basque, they do not tie stable relations with Gaulish peoples or dominion (to the point resorting to help from Spain against Romans rather than Gaulish), their religion seems to have been different as well...The only reason Aquitaine was considered part of Gaul, is that the border of Gaul was considered to be the Pyrenees by Greeks and Romans, which probably came from a Gaulish conceptualisation. From time to time, a Celtic tribe came to settle there, as Boii or Bituriges, but roughly, anything beyond the Garonne river had few chances to be Gaulish and Strabo is spot-on when he remarked that they were rather more like people in Iberia than in Gaul.
Now, if we look at how Romans took control of southern Gaul in the IInd century, and assuming that either Celto-Ligurians or Volcae ruled over a culturally or ethnically distinct population, following your hypothesis they should have submitted pretty much quickly. They did not, and in more than one occasion actively tried to revolt, leading Romans to shatter these peoples in smaller entities (the division between Volcae Tectosages and Volcae Arecomici might be a Roman decision) with several military colonies in the midst : Aquae Sextiae, Narbo Maritius, etc.On the contrary, Aquitains, while we know their region was culturally homogeneous, put a fight in -55 and quickly submitted afterwards, including without fighting.
Southern Gauls, whom Michel Py famously said, "weren't your everyday Gauls", exception made of Aquitains, simply don't look like they were part of a different cultural ensemble from their northern neighbours.
These northern neighbours, incidentally, were they really all Celts? As you said, and as both Caesar and Strabo said, while there were Celts inhabiting most of Gaul, you could find Belgians and Germans too. Maybe the cultural make-up didn't played a major role, at least in Celtic Gaul, but what about these?
Gaulish regional ensemble in the late -60's
Let's look at Caesar and his commentaries first :
At first glance, this is pretty much obvious : we saw Aquitains weren't Celts and barely considered as part of Gaul, and Caesar seems to confirm Belgians as well had a different language and society.The problem is that, beyond this first part, Caesar never precise what was different in Belgian Gaul.
Strabo, writing in the same period, and using a same secondary source as Caesar, the accounts Poseidonios made of his trips in Gaul some decades before; is rather of an another opinion.
While Strabo acknowledges dialectal differences, social and institutional particularities, he lumps Belgians and Celts together as part of a same Galatian, i.e. Gaulish, ensemble (after having said that the Transalpine province of Gaul before Caesar was formerly part of Celtic Gaul. He makes there a distinction between Celt and Gaul that Caesar tends to mix up (although not entirely). His description of Belgian society, furthermore, is largely similar to what we know of Gaul as a whole.
Trough various sources, either linguistic, historical or archaeological, Strabo appears to be entirely right there.
- Belgian language is entirely understandable as Gaulish, with some archaism being possibly spottable such as the preservation of -kw-/-k^(w)- as in Sequana (Seine) while this sound gave -p- in Gaulish overall (Epona, and not Equona).To be exaustive, we could mention the North-West Block hypothesis which postulate the existence of either a pre-Celtic language (pre-IE or Ie) concurrently to Gaulish in the population ruled by a Gallicized elite, or the influence of such language as substrate. While not impossible, it suffers from a lack of evidence. Names and language was as far as we know, Gaulish.
- Belgian polities, contrary to the political development in Celtic Gaul which saw the fall of most royal lines in favour of oligarchic regimes, seems to have kept more systematically a royal leadership, while not entirely archaic (some of these were "constitutional" kingship, and at least for Eburones a federal kingship). Some of Belgian or Armorican (wait, who are those? more on that later) polities seems to have been particularly decentralized and without chief oppidum before the Augustean reforms.
- It seems that, while most of Celtic Gaul departed from Druidic influence in their society (maybe due to a decline of Druidism in the IInd century), Belgians kept abiding to much of its aspects : while Celtic Gauls mostly went trough a representative dissociation in their coinage, or with a "caricatural" representation into Arvern art; Belgian art went up to sheer abstraction.
Belgians while quite probably issued from groups having settled in northern-western Gaul by the IVth and IIIrd centuries and intermixed with locals more or less deeply (although Remi seems to have kept a non-Belgian aspect until the conquest, and Belgian elements were found beyond Caesarian Belgica).
Let's note, finally, that Strabo have a different definition of the Belgian territory : while Caesar considers it is essentially delimited by the square made of the Ocean, Seine, Marne and Rhine (more or less Hauts-de-France and Belgium nowadays), Strabo included as well to these regions the peoples set between Loire and Rhine, the Ocean and the "middle of plains" (roughly Ile de France, very roughly). We'll see later why it's a particularly interesting prospect, but for now let's just point that Belgians and Belgica aren't the same, further hinting that the regional division of Gaul might not be that cultural based.
What about Germans? Okay, we get it, Gauls shared a same culture and differences might be exaggerated (lacking strong or proper evidence in historical or archaeological sources), but Germans were certainly a particular part, as they caused Gauls to side with Caesar, fearing another invasion.
Like Celt, German is a thrice-edged concept and many cut themselves trying to handle it. Exactly like Celt, German was reinvested with a romantic and nationalist content especially as Gustaf Kossina more or less imposed his point of view on material culture, which could be summarized as "one culture = one folk = one language" not any of these elements couldn't cut from the others : if a material culture was found, its bearers might have been a same people and spoke the same language. if we found anything remotely German, then the people living there were Germans.
Let's just say that, post-1945, something made scholars reconsider the idea.
The core idea there is that people can borrow cultural elements, either material or immaterial, without challenged with own identity. This identity is less a matter of inner dynamics, than being a result of a double-definition toward the others people trough perceived relations and distinctions. It could frankly take a lot of forms such as genealogy, rites, political alliances or even territorial or cosmological considerations. From these identities born out of what was called the "tribal zone", meaning a territory where developed polities met early forms of social organisation and where the encounter forces a double dynamic of tribal definition.
By the VIth to IIIrd century, Celts that lived in modern Germany weren't really that different from the ones that lived in Gaul : either in terms of material culture or language, they were pretty much similar to Gauls. People living in Gaul called them "Neigbours", "Kinsmen" which was translated in Latin as "Germani". In the same time, these Germans met, every now and then, people who spoke a different language and that lived mostly in the North, on both sides of the Baltic and North Sea. They didn't interacted a lot, but the northerners borrowed their technology, some words and when Celts went trough a period of territorial development in the IIIrd, some of the northerners joined in the bandwagon.
What they didn't knew, is that by moving south, Northerners just made their first step...into the Tribal Zone.
Overall, they mixed with the Celts, but kept maintaining their proper cultural features, ending up with groups having Celtic names but made of non-Celtic speakers, Celtic people with non-Celtic rulers, etc. And Gauls had to reassert what their neighbours were : especially as more of them moved south since the IIIrd century in more numbers, more "alien" looking and forcing whole people to move in Gaul, which culminated with the Cimbric and Teutonic wars.It was definitely not a wonderful day in this neighbourhood as far Gauls were concerned. It's not like these new Germans were really that systematically hostile and that aggressive, but they didn't shared similar values or institutions, and were seen as Celts were in the Vth to IIIrd century, as people who could move away and take control of territories pretty much easily.
So, Gauls lumped together Germans, not really interested making the difference between Celtic Germans, Germanic Germans, and of course all the ray of "Half-Celticized Germans", and all the variants : after all, it's likely that among Cimbric or Teutonic groups, there was a strong Celtic element.Renewed political and military warfare in Gaul from the IInd century onwards, with the emergence of militarized elites which were thus far held in check by druidic influence and a relatively contributive (on the domestic scale that is) productive model, provided Germans with opportunities for mercenariship and settlement beyond the Rhine, due to the attract of a prosperous Gaul : after all, contacts and exchange between both banks of the Rhine never ceased (and didn't after the Roman conquest either) and familial, economical and political ties between Galli and Germani remained strong. In fact, Belgians were known to have raided German lands from time to time as well, so Gauls weren't even really passive there.
The complexity if this relationship could be highlighted by the role of Cimbric and Teutonic invasion, leading Volcae to revolt against Rome, or having Helvetii (and other people in Gaul) being labelled as Semigermani because there was a point people had trouble making the difference between a Gaul and a German once they settled in Gaul.Even Ariovist, who is depicted by Caesar as Germanic king of Suebi, bears a Celtic name and knows Gaulish political usages. When a Gaulish people is said to be Germanic, it is first a reference to a territorial and genealogical identity : they might participate or not to Gaulish culture and institutions, notably trough establishing genealogical relation with people they settled on or with their neighbours.
When Caesar invaded Gaul, two things happened.First, a clear cultural and political rupture was made along the Rhine : anything beyond Rhine was Germanic and Rome cared even less about cultural technicalities than Gauls, and Germans answered in kind especially as Rome bring allies from northern Germania to fight against Rhenan Germans (in particular with the Batavian war). Then, some Gaulish people claimed to be "Germans" or stressed their Germanity, as a way to hook on to a prestigious identity in Roman service.
Does that means that there was no difference between newly arrived Germans and Gauls? Of course not, and some people seems to have been particularly distinct. But overall, they were part of a same cultural ensemble, and it's no longer thought that northern Gaul was undergoing a cultural Germanization. But if Gauls weren't really distinct from each other, safe for regional disparities, and if they weren't that different from Germans, Cisalpine or Danubian Gauls, can we even consider there was a Gaul in the first place?
This was precisely the analysis of Christian Goudineau in the 70's in opposition with the lasting idea that Gaul formed a nation, against definitely alien Germans, Romans and Iberians.
For him, Gaul was no more a country before Romans than Central African Republic was before French. Sure they might have shared some features, but it's not like Brittons or Celtic Germans didn't as well; furthermore, Gaul was quite early under the influence of Greeks and Romans, who defined and redefined the territory as they went : Ligustikè, Keltikè, Galatia, Gallia Comata, Belgica, etc.
It was indeed a saving theory, would it be in order to break up with the mould of nationalism and quasi-protochronism in the popular and academic perception of Gaul, but it had been re-evaluted since : what did Gauls thought being their territory? Was it only a local patriotism, or as many peoples in the Mediterranean basin, did Gauls had a conception of belonging to a larger space?
Dwelling into Gaulish politics might be easier than it could be thought at first : Caesar took great care to depict how Gauls managed their diplomacy, their warfare, but also which kind of political regime they favoured or fought against, and how they administered their political life.The general, furthermore, uses a precise vocabulary and does not tend to re-use a word he gave an example of already in another context; so at the least, he proposes a general panorama of Gaulish peoples as polities and not just as human groups.
The first thing to understand there is that, in politics, the plural of Gaul is an assembly, except maybe in the basic layers of society, Gauls have various kind of oligarchic or representative (not in the electoral sense, as far as we can tell) assemblies.
The basic brick of the Gaulish polities seems to have been the pagus (often translated as canton) subdivision of larger peoples
It is not really clear how articulated these pagi were with tribes (toutas) : in some case, they seem to fit rather well as with the hundred of Suevic pagi. In other cases, the four pagi of Helvetii would make them disproportionally weak. It's possible that in Gaul, tribes were gathered into larger pagus, and that tribes formed subdivisions of these pagi (which Caesar calls fraction of pagi). It's not impossible that some powerful tribes gave their name to their pagi, tough. A pagus would be then in Gaul a political division, managing the territory into fiscal and military units. Pagi seems to have been more than that, nevertheless, as they could cut off from their people and become either independent or part of another (something that Romans extensively used in Gaul, awarding allies and breaking off defeated enemies) and pagi are shown to act against the decision of their peoples during the Gallic Wars.
Gaulish peoples would be then considered as a federation of pagi, which were in turn a federation of tribes.
But Caesar gives a great attention to these people nevertheless and they are by far the territorial and political division he mentions the most (182 times!), under the name of civitas. Caesar doesn't mean by that Gauls were ruled by an urban power (and they doesn't always fit the Roman civitas after the conquest), but rather to its classical sense of "gathered men" with sometimes a rough territorial definition, completed with finis (maybe equoranda in Gaulish) which then stress the notion of border rather than geography itself. Basically Caesar uses "city" to name peoples, and sometimes state, civitas being synonymous of polis or politeia : in the general view, however, exception made of borders that are explicitly mentioned or considered as such by Gauls trough the establishment of specific places, Gaulish polities' borders were moving, and always susceptible of renegotiation, depending on the power of the people, which doesn't mean they didn't existed or weren't acknowledged, but as with Rome, were a more a matter of control and negotiation : natural borders as mountains, rivers or forests were often used, at multiple levels.
Stressing the social meaning of these polities might be to undermine their federative nature, and the reliance over conventions and assemblies to maintain the political unity : maybe issued at first from assemblies of the people in arms as in Germania, less debating than adopting trough acclamation decisions and Caesar does points that the Gaulish plebs doesn't hold power in Gaul,which could imply a median form between a popular assembly and a noble assembly, maybe something like the Third Estate in medieval France gathering non-noble important people. More important are what Caesar names senatus, whom we have little reason to think they were anything else than oligarchic assemblies mostly recruiting from the noble circles (when he defeats Nervian and Veneti, Caesar claims he decimated their senate as well, as he killed them on the battlefield) : Caesar never names them senator, always equites.
These senates, according to Caesar, represented pagi in a tentative ration of 100 nobles/pagus, and while they might not have been systematically present in all Gaul, seem to have been at least common enough, being the main political body, and naming/electing/choosing the leader of the people. It is possible that this structure might have existed on the federal and cantonal level.
What matters, eventually, is less the territory than the existence of central local places (oppidae and sanctuaries) where assemblies could take place and radiate over the region : this de-centrality of assemblies is illustrated by the recent discovery of a wooden "theater" in the oppidum of Corent.
Thanks! Fascinating answer. In Gallic Wars by Caesar he mentions that Gauls wrote using Greek script.
In the first book, indeed : he write that Helvetii wrote down their numbers in tables, using Greek letters for doing so.
It's a great information, because we have found Gallo-Greek script only in the lower Rhone basin (between Alès, Marseille and Vaison approximately) : it shows that the practices extended at least further on the trade ways; maybe by semi-professional scribes.
Holy fuck, what an answer.
Thank you so much. That was fantastic
I know I say this a lot, but this is a freaking incredible answer u/Libertat.