WIBTA For telling my aging father I'm upset he broke up our family when I was young?

No A-holes here

My dad is in his mid 60s and retired. He divorced my mom when I was in elementary school even though she wanted to stay together. No one cheated, no one was abusive in any way, they just weren't compatible and he thought he could do better. After the divorce he was still an involved father - made use of his weekends, showed up at my various childhood activities, new my friend's names, etc. So I never really thought much of the divorce, it was all very low drama and I still had my parents.

Since becoming a mother I've realized how much more time my kids get with their dad than I did with mine. How he knows them on a deeper, more intimate level from living with them and seeing them daily in the place they treat as home. I see how much help it is to have two parents instead of one and gained sympathy for my mom trying to work and raise us. It helps me understand her mistakes.

I missed out on much of having a father and had a worse mom than if she'd had real help. It's not like he didn't know this before divorcing her and he did it anyway for reasons that I don't find good enough.

I want to talk to him because I think hearing his reasoning could help me let go of the resentment I've been gaining. On the other hand, this conversation would really hurt him and give him allot to wrestle with for a while. I'm not sure he deserves to spend his final years wondering if he was a good father or not.

Posted Aug 28, 2019, 1:49 AM UTC

014
elisekumarPartassipant [2]•

NAH it sounds like it would help you to talk to him about it and hear his side of it. He may also be seeing how close your partner is to your kids and see what he missed out on.

There may have been more toxicity in your parents marriage than you were aware of - good parents try and shield their children from marital strife and work hard to parent cooperatively after divorce. That can lead the kids to think that their parents could have worked things out but in reality they couldn’t.

I don’t know your parents but assuming that they were both reasonably well adjusted and emotionally healthy people then staying together would have hurt you more long term. You would have grown up with a warped sense of love and relationships and your parents would probably have grown to hate each other more and more over time.

Your relationship with your dad suffered greatly from the family separating. But you don’t know how it would have been had they stayed together. You may have resented your dad even more for how he treated your mother or he may have functionally abandoned you by spending all his free time working so he could avoid being at home with his wife.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
ohhhhhboyyyAsshole Enthusiast [8]•

NTA. He should know how his decision impacted you. He has option to defend his decision or make amends for it. Either way, your feelings are valid and you have a right to voice them. I think you might be surprised by his response.

(I’ll be curious to see the feedback on this on as well. ***divorced dad of two very young daughters at the time due to wife’s infidelity)

3
Pkron17Certified Proctologist [29]•

YWBTA.

If your dad wanted to divorce your mom, then their must have been a reason. Divorce is a crappy thing for the children no matter what, but think about what you are telling him from his perspective. "I wish you suffered for the last X-amount of years from whatever it was that made you want to get divorced rather than having been happier."

I am truly sorry that you grew up with divorced parents, but think about it. Saying that you don't think his reasons for divorce are "good enough" is selfish. He is a living, breathing, thinking human being, and he obviously thought that they were. He did the best he could after the divorce, and if anything you should thank him.

You should still talk with him. Don't unload your sadness onto him, but have a real conversation as adults.

2
funajudoraCertified Proctologist [24]•

NAH for expressing how you feel, that's better than growing resentment and blowing up at him or cutting him out. You're allowed to wish your parents had stayed together so you'd have had more dad time and so your mom would've been less stressed. However, your dad didn't do anything wrong by leaving, especially since he stayed active in your lives as you said. Sometimes parents aren't compatible and staying in a marriage out of obligation could have been way worse for everyone in the long run.

Your mom may have also been an equal part in ending the marriage. I don't know if she told you he left to do better or if he did, but if it came from her then he may have a different story. It's fair to tell him you wish he had stayed but you don't need to come at him angrily, just ask him to explain so you can understand.

Keep in mind that you still enjoyed your childhood and didn't feel impacted at the time. You still had an involved father. He didn't abandon you and run away, so he wasn't a bad father.

2
JaneStuartMillOP•

He definitely divorced her. I found out later that he tried to divorce her three years earlier and she begged him to try couples therapy first. As to his reasoning, I had always suspected but I overheard him talking to a friend once which confirmed my theory.

1
funajudoraCertified Proctologist [24]•

In your original post it sounded like you wanted to hear his reasoning. If you already know it then I'm not sure what you're looking to gain from confronting him besides venting your anger. If that's the case, then I think you'd be TA.

2
JaneStuartMillOP•

Why he didn't want to be married to her anymore and justifying leaving his children (in so far) are two different questions.

1
funajudoraCertified Proctologist [24]•

I mean, he did stay in your life so he wasn't entirely leaving his children. The two are clearly tied together, he left the house to leave his marriage not to leave his children. It's a consequence. But yes, if you believe he'll have more of an explanation it's fine to ask, and he may be able to explain why he thought it was worth such a big consequence.

1
QuitaQuitesAsshole Aficionado [14]•

YTA for a couple of reasons, your father is in his 60’s, that’s not ‘aging,’ assuming he’s in good health there’s no reason to believe he’s frail or incapable of honest conversation. That said, are you angry or resentful because he divorced your mother or because you think he could have been around more? I ask because you talk about having two parents, but it also seems like you did have two parents? And that they weren’t compatible so they divorced?

2
AutoModeratorMODAutomation Enthusiast•

^^^^AUTOMOD The following is a copy of the above post. This comment is a record of the above post as it was originally written, in case the post is deleted or edited. Read this before contacting the mod team

My dad is in his mid 60s and retired. He divorced my mom when I was in elementary school even though she wanted to stay together. No one cheated, no one was abusive in any way, they just weren't compatible and he thought he could do better. After the divorce he was still an involved father - made use of his weekends, showed up at my various childhood activities, new my friend's names, etc. So I never really thought much of the divorce, it was all very low drama and I still had my parents.

Since becoming a mother I've realized how much more time my kids get with their dad than I did with mine. How he knows them on a deeper, more intimate level from living with them and seeing them daily in the place they treat as home. I see how much help it is to have two parents instead of one and gained sympathy for my mom trying to work and raise us. It helps me understand her mistakes.

I missed out on much of having a father and had a worse mom than if she'd had real help. It's not like he didn't know this before divorcing her and he did it anyway for reasons that I don't find good enough.

I want to talk to him because I think hearing his reasoning could help me let go of the resentment I've been gaining. On the other hand, this conversation would really hurt him and give him allot to wrestle with for a while. I'm not sure he deserves to spend his final years wondering if he was a good father or not.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
AutoModeratorMODAutomation Enthusiast•

If you want your comment to count toward judgment, include only ONE of the following abbreviations in your comment. If you don't include a judgement abbreviation, the bot will ignore you when it looks for the top voted comment.

JudgmentAbbreviation
You're the Asshole (& the other party is not)YTA
You're Not the A-hole (& the other party is)NTA
Everyone Sucks HereESH
No A-holes hereNAH
Not Enough InfoINFO

#Click Here For Our Full Rulebook

#Click Here For Our FAQ

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
one_night_on_marsPartassipant [1]•

YTA. he wasn't happy, so divorced your mum. You wanted him to be unhappy his whole life for you? An unhappy parent is not the dad your kids have.

1
onlykindofahoeAsshole Enthusiast [7]•

YTA. They weren’t compatible with each other to be in a relationship and split up amicably. By the sounds of it, he was still in your live the best he could be. The fault isn’t solely on your father, some blame can be given to your mother if you’re looking to do this. They broke up before things got worse between them which is rare for most divorced people.

1