Alternatives to CIO?

Has anyone had any success sleep training (or other) their baby without letting them cry it out? My baby is way too young to sleep train, but I've been reading a lot about sleep when I can. I have never been a good sleeper and it has really affected my life. I want my son to be a good sleeper and learn to put himself to sleep etc. Everything I read is basically CIO in some fashion. Extinction, Ferber, modified Ferber, being in the room while they cry, sleeping beside their bed while they cry etc. Is this the only way? Has anyone bad success sans the crying? How old was your LO when they started sleeping through the night?

I'm not sure what my stance is on CIO yet (except extinction), but my husband is very uncomfortable with it. Tell me your bedtime secrets! We already use blackout blinds, sound machine, bedtime routine etc. Thanks!

Posted Sep 1, 2019, 9:56 PM UTC

224
dontcryfergusonedit below•

It’s not the only way. I’d have been open to doing that with our son if that’s what it took, but literally all we did was have consistent, solid sleep cues, track wake times, and then have baby a solid 4-5 minutes on a stopwatch before responding to him if he was already asleep once he was over four months old. This helped him learn to stop and look around and get a chance to tie his sleep cycles together on his own.

3
Synesthesia4OP•

This sounds like the easiest plan! Thanks. I've been trying to let him cry for 2 minutes but I have a hard time even with that. I should keep trying.

1
dontcryfergusonedit below•

So many times he would wait until 4 minutes and 50 seconds and then pass out lol. I really recommend using a timer and waiting. It’s hard, but it’s only five minutes. I never let him go longer than that, and would go back up, hold him, rock him, calm him down, then set him back down and so long as he wasn’t crying, leave and restart the timer if he started crying again. I’d not leave if he still was crying and would just rock, settle, set down, and repeat. I also never left the room or turned lights on; sort of making it not optional that he’s going to have to sleep in his crib eventually lol. My kid might be less persistent than others, but usually within three tries of setting him down, he’d accept it.

1

I didn't sleep train, he was a frequent waker for a long time, but letting him cry was not an option. Yeah I got plenty tired, but I knew that would be the case when I had a baby. At 12 months he was only waking once a night, and by 18.months sleeping through - as in, all night long (sleeping through is usually considered 5 hours). Now he's nearly 2, and his sleep trained peers are waking more frequently, climbing into parents beds and resisting bedtime, whereas my guy is sleeping like a log.

We kept it loose up until 4 months (read up on the fourth trimester) and then followed his cues and worked out a routine. It didn't take long before he knew what bedtime was, and despite the frequent wakings, he would always go back to sleep very quickly after I attended to him.

3
Synesthesia4OP•

That's good. I'm glad you're having such success now. My son is really great at night as well. He does wake more often than I'd like but he always eats/gets changed and goes right back to sleep. We are pretty lucky!

1

About 7 months when she slept for about 7 hours. I didn’t sleep train I’m pretty against CIO for the obvious reasons. But we just stuck to a strict nap and bedtime schedule. She calmed down after we picked her up and she eventually stopped when she was ready.

2

This is what we did - found an appropriate schedule so babe would be "ready" to nap/sleep but do our approach if putting him down. Started with rocking to sleep fully, to rocking him to just about to close his eyes, to rocking then putting him down and patting, and step by step, we've gotten to putting him down awake and walking out.

No crying it out here - that being said, this approach obviously takes longer to "work", but we are happy with it 😊

2
Synesthesia4OP•

Thanks for your reply. I love hearing how it's going for other parents. I appreciate it

1
Heatherleighann•

We didn’t move her to her own room until she was 15ish months but I just lay with my daughter until she falls asleep. She will sometimes go in her room and go to sleep on her own. Otherwise she grabs me and asks me to read a book and cuddle. I don’t personally like CIO so I don’t let her cry. She goes to bed at a decent time and it doesn’t hurt me to cuddle her to sleep when she asks me too.

She’s 20 months now. For reference.

2

I love cuddling to sleep, it's so lovely to wind down together at the end of the day.

1
Synesthesia4OP•

That's awesome. When she was younger and waking up through the night would you feed and cuddle back to sleep for every wake up?

1
Heatherleighann•

Usually just giving her a bink and rubbing her back would put her back to sleep but sometimes I’ll cuddle back to sleep.

1
mcnunu•

Any form of sleep training will involve crying. How much they cry depends on their temperament. Even the "gentler" methods of sleep training like shush pat, pick up put down, chair method will all still result in crying. We sleep trained at 3.5mo and our daughter slept through the night from around 7mo onwards, before that we kept 2-3 night feeds. We used Ferber, it took 3 nights and she cried for less than she does when we put her in the car seat. She's almost 2yo now and still sleeps well with the exception of regressions.

2
Synesthesia4OP•

Thanks. That kind of put things into perspective for me because my son cries in the carseat non-stop. I'm glad you had success. Thanks for your reply.

1
HouseHippoWrangler•

With my son I co slept for the first month and then put him in his own bed. We let him nap when he wanted to until we started noticing a pattern and then we stuck to it. He gets a bottle and cuddles to fall asleep at nap time and bed time. When he wakes at night, usually only once, we try and get him back to sleep in his own bed. If hes too fussy we bring him to bed the rest of the night. He's almost 1 now and I've only recently began doing controlled crying. If its his usual nap time and he's tired but fighting it I usually give him 5 minutes alone to cry it out before coming in and trying to get him asleep. I will only do this 3 times. If he just won't nap then we give up entirely. We had the same approach with our daughter too. It's not until they're older than I would allow them to cry it out for longer.

1
Synesthesia4OP•

Thanks. That seems like a pretty gentle approach and it seems to be working. I'm so happy to read this. Thanks!

1
artemis286•

We don't sleep train. We cosleep, and my 7 week old regularly gives me five hour stretches. When she fusses from gas I'm right there and can comfort her before she wakes up all the way, and she goes back to sleep. If bedsharing isn't an option, you could always do a side car or bedside bassinet. I personally will never let my baby cry alone and she's a very calm baby and a good sleeper, she falls asleep on us and then snuggles with me at night. She was sleeping regularly at night by three weeks old. She will give me only maybe two hour stretches when she sleeps alone.

1
Synesthesia4OP•

Thanks for your reply. I'm glad you're getting long stretches. I'm not opposed to co-sleeping at all. I still do it from 3-4am until morning. I did it all the time until about 6 weeks. I am a very light sleeper and any movement wakes me up, so unfortunately I don't think I want to continue co-sleeping although I do love waking up next to my son. He's not a bad sleeper on his own, but after his few two stretches he's up kind of often so I'm too lazy to put him back into his own bed.

1
LJ161•

We had to let her cry within reason. I would be sitting out of sight counting minutes and then go in and replace the pacifier and leave again. It's the only thing that worked for us in the end. It sucks but it's not forever. A few rough nights is all it takes sometimes

0
Synesthesia4OP•

Did that help with night wake ups??

1
LJ161•

It did. Even now I will still go in to replace her paci if she does wake up. But usually I can recognise if it's a help me cry or a cry that's just because shes a bit confused as to where she is if you know what I mean?

Now she generally sleeps 7am to 7pm, wakes up babbling rather than crying the majority of the time too.

However I could never let her cry for more than maybe 2 minutes cause it breaks my heart - now that shes 10mo I can tell the difference between real crying or attention seeking though.

1
InannasPocket•

Our secret: we got lucky and got a naturally good sleeper.

We never had to do any real sleep training, beyond letting her fuss for a few minutes to see if she'd fall back asleep on her own (we responded to actual crying, but didn't rush in at the first peep). She started reliably sleeping through the night at about 4-5 months when she discovered sucking her thumb. As a toddler her bedtime is more challenging because she's discovered stalling tactics though!

0
Synesthesia4OP•

Does she still suck her thumb?? We give him a pacifier but sometimes it's a pain in the ass! Glad you have a good sleeper on your hands. :)

2
InannasPocket•

Yes, she'll be 3 in a few months and she still sucks her thumb when falling asleep or something for comfort.

We tried pacifiers but she was never interested. I know some people don't like thumb sucking but frankly it's super convenient that she has a way of self-soothing that's always accessible and can't be lost/thrown out of bed.

1