r/tennis•
Readed_it

honest question: does anyone here prefer WTA over ATP, and why exactly?

I really don't mean this is a rude way, but are there any people who prefer WTA over ATP? Just can't really imagine myself to be honest but i figure theres probably some people who are WTA fans over ATP.

Posted Sep 3, 2019, 8:11 PM UTC

636
chakokat•

I follow and enjoy both men and women's tennis.

23
fuckdillyding•

That wasn't the question.

7
chakokat•

Ok. How about this answer. I don't prefer the WTA over the ATP or conversely I don't prefer the ATP to the WTA. ;-)

Actually that's not true. I'm a Djokovic fan, so when he's playing I prefer to watch him over any woman BUT if say Fed is playing I'd rather watch Osaka or Barti or Gauff or Serena or....

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

21
PrincessCuculina•

More variety, it can get rather samey on the ATP with the same people always winning.

17
DuranchDressing•

Variety is not always a good thing. There was variety in the early 2000s before the Big 3 and that era was one of the worst. It’s the same few players winning, but the matches are so much more compelling as a result. We’re watching the three greatest players of all time. We’re going to miss this era when it’s over.

19
Mythic88•

Andreescu is going to change that. Go BIBI 🇨🇦

4
Tomarsenal12345•

Because going into a slam there are 15-20 players in with a shout of potentially winning it.

17
GeosaurusrexAndy is love, Andy is life•

WTA is more interesting for me because it's less predictable, you don't get the same winners every time (I hate knowing exactly who's going to win a tournament like you do in the ATP at the moment), and I feel like the young talent coming through for the ladies is a lot more promising than anyone coming through in the men's at the moment.

13
azarath19•

I prefer WTA, mainly cause of the fact that there’s a lot more younger talent having real breakthroughs as opposed to the ATP (because of the Big 3, I know) and I also like the more open field where there are many contenders for a title. I also think there is a better variety of play styles on the WTA compared to the ATP.

10
TomasBerdshitWristy Mess Khachy•

More variety in WTA? Please.

-1†
azarath19•

Definitely more players with creativity in the WTA than ATP

8
TomasBerdshitWristy Mess Khachy•

Wrong. Theres a bigger mix of game styles, like mischa zverev, sascha bublik, that guy who hits two forehands(look it up). Plus theres a more even keel when it comes to OHB and THB. For example I think theres 3 in the top 10 with a one handed backhand. The majority of women's tennis is hard ground strokes with minimal net play( like Konta, Keys, Pliskova, Williams, Osaka) I could go on. Yes, players like andreescu and Townsend have added a breath of fresh air, but overall the atp has far more variety still

-2
AbbyNormalJr•

Every single wta player is a baseliner. There is literally no variety.

-6
GeosaurusrexAndy is love, Andy is life•

Not sure Su-Wei Hsieh will like you saying she has no variety.

8
AbbyNormalJr•

Ok I give you her. One.

0
azarath19•

Not necessarily, there are a lot of creative players such as Hsieh, Andreescu, Radwanska (although she’s retired now), Maria, Niculescu, Barty, etc.

2
XxslythererxX•

Which maria? Certainly not sharapova?

1
azarath19•

Tatjana Maria

2
ph404•

do you have any numbers/things to back this take up? take seems like complete nonsense on its face to me, but if say it turns out that wta players go to net 3-4x less than atp players then i'd eat crow.

anyway, hsieh like ppl said and taylor townsend are very much "variety" players.

and take keys and halep -- they play super differently despite both being "baseliners". barty, kerber, etc are different style players too.

and anyway, what atp players (especially top ones) can be said to not be "baseliners"? even fed is bascially an aggressive baseliner with elite net skills that he mixes in. but remove him and you have different versions of "baseliner"; occasionally a one-hand backhand i guess.

2
hsc434Nadalep•

At the very top level I prefer ATP because I find the quality of matches between the top 10 men to be higher, but I find matches between lower ranked players on the WTA are more interesting

10
felixflitwick•

I hope this question is asked in good faith. At first blush, it seems either very naive or asked with blatant disregard for the value of women’s sport. I hope it’s the former! At the very least, think about girls and young women seeing themselves reflected at the highest levels of the sport—I bet many of them enjoy the WTA over the ATP. Further, plenty of fans have affinities for WTA players just as others do for ATP players. Please think critically about how this sort of question and underlying thought has the potential to diminish women athletes and athletics. It is important that we all question the lens through which we view such issues and what alternative perspectives might exist—I hope that you approach these matters with that spirit!

6
kingoftennissm•

WTA often is more exciting than ATP, on ATP there is usually only pounding the ball and hitting as hard as you can, little to no net game or shot tactics.

On WTA, there is more craftiness player and they use more shots,they use dropshots and volleys.

6
ph404•

I met a woman yesterday at dinner who only follows WTA. Didn’t ask why though but yeah they certainly exist.

I personally like both but prefer ATP. I think imagining myself playing pro tennis in the atp when I was young is a big reason. Also ATP players are the actual best tennis players on the planet which is cool. Also I like 5 sets. Otherwise they are equivalent, depends on the match. Like I’d watch basically any women’s match over Isner Cilic for example. I’ll watch Keys play over most men’s matches. Henin was a must back in the day.

Also I find this question kind of rude even if you say you don’t mean it that way. Because I doubt you made any effort to see if anyone anywhere on the internet preferred wta. Surely you’d find some people somewhere. This makes me think you are not asking in good faith.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
shaqfry•

That wasn't the question.

2†
Voissednot enough wambulances in the world•

Rather than asking people why they prefer the WTA, to those who do, you should tell us why you don't prefer it. Let us be the judge of whether this is an honest question or not.

3†
Sdubbya2•

Uhh okay......The OP is pretty upfront that he prefers the ATP and wants to know why other people might prefer WTA.....Why does him telling you why change anything? How would it make it not an honest question, like what answer by him would change the context so it is not an honest question?....Really don't know what you are trying to get at here.

2
shonami•

The WTA took a different approach as an organization than that if the ATP, putting a huge chunk into promoting the tour in Asia, and more specifically in China. It took them longer to develop a streaming platform and they have a wonky structure that requires you a deep understanding (premier mandatory, 5, regular, international).

The YEC is a place for non slam winners to shine, surface specialists is a thing, the queen has been around for a while and despite almost 20 players having a chance to win any given slam, somehow everyone seems to own either 0 or 2.

It’s simply an odd, incoherent space, but the play is simply fantastic, and not a lot of players can servebot into top50, making it a very competitive scene.

The only thing I can say that favors the ATP outright is the One Hander Backhand. Otherwise they are both fantastic and intriguing in two completely different ways.

3
j8sadm632b•

I prefer the early WTA rounds to the early ATP rounds.

It's rare for an early-round bo5 to be dramatic, but in the bo3 there's the sense of a greater potential for upset. Plus my favorite female player is still Muguruza and she's as likely to lose round 1 as anywhere else. So watching her in early rounds is tense.

There are a lot of players in the WTA that I like pretty well, so it's fun to watch the early rounds and see who's looking good and pick my favorite.

I also find it much easier for me to get into a WTA match where I know neither of the players.

3
goalie3030•

I prefer WTA. I think the game is more interesting and more unpredictable. I can normally tell you who will win the men’s tournament before its even started

3
lady-grinning-soul•

I used to much prefer the WTA back when I started following tennis around 2003 up until 2008 or so. That's when the Federer dominance on non-clay ended, Djokovic really came into the picture and women's tennis started losing consistent high level performers that I was used to watching (Henin, Clijsters, Davenport, Venus was declining, Sharapova you could argue was never the same after her 2007-2008 injuries etc).

2
ElsbethV•

I like both, and fluctuate between prefering one over the other depending on how players play in a given tournament.

I also think the typical style of play changes over time with both. There seem to be years of boring and exciting in both.

I find these days the atp serve-bot matches are a strike against them, as are some of the super long baseline rallies - especially the backhand slice to backhand slice loop. But then theres also unreal athleticism too.

There were years when I found the women's game boring, but the current crop of power hitters and drop-shotters and movers makes for existing tennis.

I think the truth is that both are pretty spectacular at the moment. We really are lucky with the quality of tennis played these days.

2
phdinprogress•

I have always preferred WTA since I was a kid. Steffi is my idol and the reason that I started watching and playing tennis. I find the early rounds of men's tennis very boring as more often not the top 3/4 are going to reach the semis/finals and eventually win. Being best of 5 sets at slams makes the early rounds even more boring to me.

Au contraire women's tennis is much more unpredictable. I also enjoy the characters more on the women's side. I love how strong Serena is, I love Sharapova fights and never gives up when the world is against her, I love how classy Venus is etc.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dustbinasshole•

I prefer ATP on GS because everyone outside Big3 are underdogs and I love rooting/being disappointed by underdogs

1