r/shacomains•
Rinith

Notes on needed Shaco changes

Goal

  • Lessening the frustration of playing as and against Shaco.

Passive

  • Consistency vs jungle creeps.
  • Item compatibility.

Deceive (Q)

  • Longer stealth duration early ranks.
  • Shorter stealth duration later ranks.
  • Remove the cooldown reducing auto-attack buff.
  • Shorter cooldown.

Jack in the Box (W)

  • Shorter arm time, scaling with champion levels.
  • Ammo system, increased cap with ranks, e.g, 2/3/4 at ranks 1/3/5 respectively.
  • Reduced damage and/or fear duration to compensate for the aforementioned box changes.
  • Revamped HP scaling of boxes to scale better into mid-game.
  • AoE damage reduction.

Two-shiv Poison

  • Higher base damage and bAD scaling at early ranks.
  • Lower bAD scaling at later ranks.
  • Remove passive slow. Possibly moving the slow to the passive and changing it to a shorter, more potent slow.
  • Increase active slow.
  • Adaptive damage: If AD>AP, it deals physical damage. If AP>AD, it deals magic damage.
  • Improved cast time so the ability doesn't fail if target enters fog of war at the very end of the ability's animation (inconsistent with similar abilities).
  • Improved execute threshold.
  • Possibly trade some damage to give it a DoT poison effect that, e.g, applies grievous wounds (to reflect the "Poison" part of the ability's name).

Hallucinate

  • Reduced cast time (delay before vanish).
  • Fixing the consistency of the vanish buff's duration, and it being applied it in the first place (bugfix).
  • Making turrets target the clone instead of Shaco when reappearing from vanish (bugfix).
  • Increased reliability of the Explosion and Mini-Boxes part of the ability.

 

Thoughts?

Posted Sep 5, 2019, 2:14 PM UTC

48
Reinfernus1,719,995 Cðulrophobia•

i disagree with a lot of stuff:

Boxes:

  • shorter arm time would help during ganks, i don't see why not. Although it gives us more power during ganks/teamfights (assuming nobody kills it) therefore im unsure whethever its necessary

  • ammo system is unnecessary

  • as i mentioned, ammo system would broke our kit partially. Assuming that they have 4 second cd, you will be capable of setting up a kill with super relative ease. If our traps would be that strong, then we as a champion would suffer.

overall box changes sound like forcing us into playing around them.

Two-shiv:

  • no reason to remove the slow on autos, its a great tool that saved me / helped me secure kills. (example of saving: your clone autos the enemy that chases you down)

  • adaptive damage sounds unncessary, magic damage is good for both versions of Shaco

  • DoT effect sounds nice to reflect Poison part of the kit. The issue is that it doesn't balance out and makes Shaco less capable to kill fast. Our kit requires us to kill enemies asap and get out. I don't see any reason to give us grevious wounds.

Hallucinate:

  • fucks with our timings, and we'd have to relearn Shaco for a while with R

  • turrets shouldn't target clone over Shaco, but the champion closer to him rather than real Shaco. Therefore it would be a straight up buff, rather than a bugfix.

  • i'd be fine with removing mini boxes from R, and giving us more damage on explo / more power to clone himself.

3
RinithOPhttp://euw.op.gg/summoner/userName=rinith•

Lets dance around in circles then, because I disagree with your counterpoints.

Boxes:

  • Shorter arm time makes them usable reactively instead of just place a minefield of peel for sieges/mini wards etc.
  • Ammo system plays into Shaco's identity of a trickster, allowing for quicker deployment and in-fight deployment of them, makes that a possibility. More mindgames, more skill expression.
  • It won't break our kit due to being too strong, as I mentioned in the original post, damage and fear duration will be nerfed accordingly to offset the increase in power.
  • Also, it'll be a much needed QoL change for the AP Shacos out there (I don't know how you do it).

Two-shiv Poison:

  • The passive slow on autos is braindead, no fun to use, and extremely anti-fun to play against I assume. It's also an area of Shaco's kit that can easily be removed to allow for the other changes.
  • Adaptive damage would solve AP Shaco's problem of not being able to build penetration items (which I've heard is a massive problem), while also allowing AD/Lethality Shaco to keep building his penetration items. Changing it purely to magic will make itemization extremely awkward for AD Shaco, as it currently is for AP Shaco. Which is the reason I don't like changing it purely to magic dmg.
  • Introducing DoT would allow for Shaco to have more damage, without overloading his instaburst, (almost) no counterplay assassinations. Look at Talon passive, Zed ult, Akali's everything. They all have both burst, and delayed extra damage, there's no reason why Shaco can't have the same. It would be more healthy assassin gameplay. Grievous wounds was just an example of an effect they could add on top of the DoT (fits with poison theme).

Hallucinate:

  • Yeah, we would need to relearn the timing, but it would actually allow us to reactively dodge with it, as opposed to guess at the timing of the enemies' abilities. Camille R is instant, Fizz E is instant, Zed R is instant etc. I'd much rather have it be instant, than the shitty delay it currently has.
  • Turrets already target clones/minions/pets before champions. It worked correctly in the past, it's a bug that needs fixing.
  • As for the explosion/mini-boxes I'm up for anything really, never liked the ability. Removing either part, or completely reworking the ability, idc, as long as it becomes a consistently useful ability.
1
Reinfernus1,719,995 Cðulrophobia•

okay

Boxes:

  • i don't mind shorter arm time, but honestly it might be stronger than people think.

  • if we get this ammo system, it will end up with several stuff that no Shaco main wants. It will lead us to the point of maxing boxes 1st/2nd since they're most effective. Both AP/AD's Shaco will have way worse clear since you want to tone down the damage on boxes. Both versions of Shaco will be menace to enemy junglers & objectives, since setting up boxes will be super easy. Its a change that both Shaco's would benefit too much from. And nerfing fear is impossible since it has 2 parts: Startle > Flee. Shaco's boxes lvl 1 are only capable of "Startling" for .5 seconds. Each point into box makes enemy flee for .2 seconds. The issue with ammo system is that it gives way too many opportunities which we shouldn't have.

  • Nerfing damage and duration will nerf our clear, which already has its issues. It will push Shaco into support /top more, while gutting jungle Shaco (either that or he will become a full on counter jungler)

  • Thats not a QoL that will help AP Shaco, AD will benefit from it just as much. (at least early)

Two-Shiv:

  • i personally think its actually not braindead and forces Shaco to play smart to not throw Shivs instantly upon ganks. It also wouldn't allow for other changes since the ability itself has little counterplay.

  • No, AD benefits from Magic Damage just as much. Armor as a base state grows way higher than MR. On top of that its easier to build against physical damage (especially for squishies) We're also just buying items like LDR because people are buying armor and we're forced to do so. (this point is pretty bad because Shaco always used to deal magic damage on two-shiv, and nobody had issues with that. This season they even nerfed physical damage, and lethality items are garbage.

  • i don't mind DoT damage, i just believe that they'll remove other parts of the kit like execute for that kind of ability. Also if that happened physical damage on two-shiv woul stay, and they'd make DoT Magic.

Hallucinate:

  • w/e i guess

  • clones are treated as champion usually. It focused closest target, not clone. But it does need a fix.

1
Sugipn•

Two-Shiv:

Shaco's E could have some kind of passive 3-hits effect that applies Slow AND Poison.

1
Reinfernus1,719,995 Cðulrophobia•

eh, you wouldn't be able to proc it most of the time, Shaco doesn't have any auto resets.

1
[deleted]•

I'm not really sure I understand any reason to make a damage type adaptive on an execute mechanic unless that ability had high scaling damage based solely from bonus ad or ap.

2
[deleted]•

An ammo system ok shaco is just a bad idea. It doesn't sound fun to play againist. Currently when I get an enemy to jump on me in the middle of my boxes they know they were out played, that I set that trap up and that they fell victim to it. They don't react negatively to it, but an ammo system would shift that respect into frustration and annoyance. Shaco is already an annoying champion for many to play againist with his Q and survivability with R. There's no reason to add that level of frustration with our W. You would have to greatly increase the Arm time or just remove damage entirely if you had an ammo mechanic on his W. Your W proposal doesn't seem thought out.

1

People frustrated with Shaco should probably look at Riot's latest releases to gain some much needed perspective.

1