r/DMAcademy•
Sethlon

5E Houserules; Flanking, opportunity attacks, 5ft steps

Having extensively played 3.5, the simplicity of 5E is generally really really refreshing. I got a kick out of one of my players just now realizing that he doesn't need to prepare each specific spell slot ahead of time, as a wizard! The lowered level of bookkeeping is definitely nice.

I do find myself missing some of the more tactical movement of 3.5, though, and I've been tinkering with some house rules to bring some of it back in the fold.

Flanking; mechanically and thematically, I think it makes sense for an attacker to be rewarded if they've surrounded their enemy. The optional rule that flanking grants full advantage seems pretty brutal though, especially with the ability to freely move around in an opponent's threatened space. Instead, the house rule I've been using is that Flanking, IE having two allies on opposite sides of an opponent, gives those allies a +2 bonus to melee attacks. A slight increase in number crunching, but so far I've found things to still be pretty streamlined, especially since there aren't many other modifiers that we use for combat, so it avoids piling on multiple +2 modifiers like in previous editions. I do think there should be some other rules for moving around in an opponent's threatened space, though, which brings me to the following house rules.

Opportunity attacks; RAW, opportunity attacks only happen in 5E if you step out of an opponent's threatened space. Fine for RAW, but letting characters move around so freely with some sort of flanking bonus doesn't make too much sense balance wise, and also doesn't make much sense thematically either IMO; a swordsman isn't going to let someone completely circle around them unchallenged. With that in mind, the house rule I've been using is that Moving through more than one of an opponent's threatened squares provokes an opportunity attack. Still leaves room for some positioning and doesn't keep a character completely locked down when they're in someone or something's threatened space, but doesn't let them dance around as they please.

5 Foot Step aka Shift; Another option we've been toying with at my table to give players more movement options. A character who chooses to make a 5ft step loses all but 5 feet of their movement, but gains the benefit as if they had used the Disengage action for the turn. This one in particular I'm not totally sure about. I like characters and players having the option to make 5ft steps for tactical positioning, but it does seem like it hurts melee chars and helps caster chars quite a bit. Having a melee char close with a caster can be a tough position for a caster, since any ranged spell attacks get disadvantage in melee range. Being able to 5ft back and then cast from there kind of removes that penalty, though with the caveat that they'll only be a short step away from their melee opponent for that characters turn.

Thoughts? Fully typing them out, I feel like there could be a cleaner way of implementing these types of house rules. Have you tried out implementing more flanking / opportunity attack rules, and how have they worked out for you?

Posted Sep 9, 2019, 11:20 PM UTC · edited

1018
Loading comments…