New iPhone camera's Night Mode is exclusive to newer models. Kudos to Google for enabling Night Sight on older Pixels!

Even though I switch phones fairly often, support for older devices is a key factor in deciding my phone of choice. Hope Google continues to add new features to older phones to keep making them better!

Posted Sep 11, 2019, 1:30 PM UTC

3.2K393
jmartin72Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

Apple is the king of making new features only available on new devices. How do you think they sell so many phones....

477
r4gs•

It’s especially irritating that even the wallpapers aren’t made available on older models.

150
dleriumPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlwhite: | Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

Odd that same issue happens on Pixels too.

62
nyansliderPixel 2 :pixel2black:•

At least you can download them, even the live ones.

64
dleriumPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlwhite: | Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

On XDA? I get that's reasonable for enthusiasts like us, but should not be expected for any average user.

33
fugozi666•

Wow so you must not get to download them on an iPhone? That’s weird that I can download any wallpaper on my iPhone XS Max

0
jmartin72Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

They say they aren't doing this anymore, but don't forget intentionally slowing down older devices after new OS upgrades. A real classy move....

19†
Edenz_•

How is this in anyway true? Performance has been going up the last few versions of iOS

39
chasevalentino•

After they got caught doing it. That's the point that guy is making. They wouldn't do it had they not got caught

60
jmartin72Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

Like I said, they don't do it anymore, but they have publicly admitted it in the name of saving battery life. You can Google it.

12
rrfg1•

Yeah... they shot themselves in the foot with iOS 12 and it's performance gains on the older phones. It gave people who were on the edge of upgrading a reason to keep their phones at least one more year because of the performance gains.

4
Chris20nyyQuite Black•

It's true, it's been documented, and admitted by Apple. Not sure why this is even contested

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
WaZQc•

It was to save usage on the battery if I remember correctly. Someone correct me if I'm wrong please.

1
downvoted_your_momPixel 2 XL•

They do that to maximize battery life and prevent shut downs, this has been talked about before. News articles just used that headline to trigger ppl.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

They say they aren't doing this anymore, but don't forget intentionally slowing down older devices after new OS upgrades. A real classy move....

There were technical reasons for doing so. With how quickly batteries degrade, it prevented or at least reduced incidents of random reboots, shutdowns, and bootloops. This isn't a case of Apple gimping your phone just to make you buy the next one. The slowdown wasn't even all that noticeable to the average user.

3
Claide•

Why would a new version not have worse performance? Do you expect them to release unfinished software and slowly clean up the trash or do you expect new OS versions to have less features?

1
AppropriateOkra•

at least they're dead simple to get online virtually from launch day.

1
pvtjace•

Really?

1
Unique_account_•

What the heck do you mean

1
Ph0X•

Is it me or there was basically no "features" at all this year. All I saw was a couple camera improvements (slofie, night mode, wide lens). Other than that, it was just a basic spec bump.

From leaks alone, Pixel 4 already has many camera improvements, soli, face id, instant google assistant, and much more.

15
PrudentPlant•

To me, the only real improvement for most users is the lower price. Innovation through lowering the price.

Night Mode is simply a software feature for the most part and there are apps for that.

Slofie sounds like a dumb party trick.

Wide angle is good. If you are serious about photography, and really have the $$$, the iPhone Pro looks pretty nice.

This year was just an incremental upgrade.

(Former iPhone user, if that matters. Context here.)

12
Superyoshers9•

Ultra wide is more useful than people are thinking, you don't know what it's like until you don't have it.

3
CRR3355•

What are the "many camera improvements...and much more"? Also if you're going to throw out face ID as new then iPhone is getting the brand new night mode... Not to mention the rumored 90hz display on the P4 most likely destroying the insultingly tiny battery. And all signs point to soli being a gimmick at best with leaks showing only 2-3 basic functions. Also not including a ultra wide on the back is laughable and why the P4 deserves to be compared with the 11 basic and not the 11 pro.

6†
torrewaffer•

Unfortunately very true 😞

1
torrewaffer•

The Pixel 4 will have the exact same sensor and some software improvements, so...

1
Ph0X•

iPhone has soli? Also pixel 4 isn't even launched yet and you're basic things off rumors.

1
torrewaffer•

What does Soli have to do with anything?

1
jmartin72Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

What was the difference between the iPhone X and the Xs.... Nothing

1
torrewaffer•

The camera was much better, specially in terms of dynamic range. The iPhone X had laughable cameras while the XS was one of the best when it comes to dynamic range. Low light was also improved.

1
251CaneQuite Black•

Advertising.

People don't want new iPhones because they are the best. People want new iPhones because they think they're the best.

11
jmartin72Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

I couldn't agree more. iPhone users are sheep, and very pretentious.

-13
i_am_wood•

Good thing you aren't ;)

5
PrudentPlant•

At the end of the day it's just a phone. iOS and Android are both good. Pick your poison.

5
jlvlawrence•

That goes both ways. Lots of pretentious Android users out there too. I still have quite a few friends using a 6S or 7 and are getting along just fine.

1
pppp2428•

lol you must not be around this focum much. you should compare the devotion people have to the pixel at this forum to the devotion people have to apple at the apple forum.

1
rossisdead•

I still remember when the OG iPhone didn't have support for MMS. Then they claimed only the iPhone 3G could support it due to "hardware limitations" even though any jailbroken OG iPhone could get MMS support before the 3G came out.

6
PrudentPlant•

I generally don't trust Apple when it comes to stuff being "out of date." It's crap. From personal experience.

1
TurboFoolPixel 3 XL 128GB :pixel3xlblack:•

Yet they get SO much credit for applying updates to older phones while people ignore this core difference.

6
epichigh•

Wow, you have to be trying pretty hard to convince yourself that Google is better at supporting older devices than Apple.

That is one area where Apple absolutely crushes Google. Google only pulled off this trick because they haven't changed the camera sensor in years while Apple actually has good hardware.

2†
Kn0thingIsTerrible•

Yeah, this sub is a fucking cult.

Apple has had a 5-6 year support cycle for every iPhone.

Google hasn’t supported any first party phone for longer than three years, and if you buy a non-first party android phone, you’re not even getting a full year before you can no longer update to the latest version.

But literally all that matters on this sub is “fuck Apple”

8
boolim86•

Agree and that's also if Google hardware can last that long 😂

2
PrudentPlant•

The antagonism is weird. It used to be that way in the Windows world long ago. I mean, you have a choice of phone platforms. You pick one, get on with your life. Both are good. They are different.

The update thing has me concerned. I won't buy a $1000 Samsung if they don't have the updates after 2 years. Some people say this is not important due to plateauing of features and the Google updates are catch-up to the Samsung skin.

2
ideal_josh•

What people always forget is that most features don't make it to older Apple devices, the older the device, the waaaay less features are in the update. secondly, Google updates most of Android through the play store. All apps that comes with a Google phone are updated on the app store and this is done all year round, no need for an event to say we have redesigned the music player like Apple would.

1
Rem4g•

Actually the Pixel 2 had a 1.4μm pixel size sensor with 12.2 megapixels while the Iphone X was still using a sensor with 1.2μm pixel size at 12 megapixels (meaning the pixel 2 had a larger imaging sensor for less noise and better low light).

It's only with the Iphone XS that apple caught up and started using a sensor with 1.4μm pixel size, still at 12mp.

Not sure what the pixel sizes will be on the Iphone 11 Pro but it's using 3x 12mp sensors so we'll have to wait and see the specs. But it's safe to say you've used a bad example regarding the camera sensors!

6
PrudentPlant•

Interesting. The proof will be in the photos that come out on each phone. Not the professional photographer bullshit from Apple, but everyday people.

3
epichigh•

Not really, I think you just missed my point. The pixel 2 and pixel 3 use pretty much the same 12MP sensor so my point was that they can push out an update from the pixel 3 to the 2.

Regarding iphone, well you made my point for me. They improved it between X and XS and each new generation has new software features that are built for that gen.

All of that is beside the point though. Apple is clearly much better at supporting older devices. 6 year old phones get OS updates.

0†
Rem4g•

Oh yea I mean I guess it depends what those features are and whether they were dependant on very specific camera sensor changes. They still upgrade the Pixel sensors, it's just the newest model of the same specs which are a good sweet spot for smart phone photography across the board, so the improvements are mainly in things like Auto Focus and Optical Image Stabilisation etc.

Something like night mode MIGHT not be something they can offer on older phones if their processing is tuned specifically for the hardware on the Iphone 11 Pro. The A12 on the Iphone XS in terms of computing should easily handle it though so it depends how versatile their AI algorithms are to handle slightly different input.

The gap between the Iphone 11 Pro and Iphone XS sensors are going to be minimal so you'd hope they can offer the night mode and some of the other imaging improvements to Iphone XS users eventually.

3
torrewaffer•

You're right and actually Google has been using VERY similar sensors since the Nexus 6P!!! Anyway, I strongly believe Apple actually could bring the new features to the older models... Long exposure stacking (night mode) for example is a software feature, not a hardware one.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
PrudentPlant•

On principle, support for a 6 year old device is commendable.

We don't know the future, though and what support will really happen. For instance, night sight could have been available for older phones.

Anyway, for all practical purposes, hopefully, everyone can upgrade at least every 3-4 years.

But the Samsung 2 year support (when the update gets rolled out) is not really acceptable. On principle.

0
noes_oh•

#courage

1
Dazz316Pixel 2 XL 64GB :pixel2xlblack:•

That crap with the animojis. It's not a feature I want, but older iPhones actually had the software on them for it but Apple just locked it away. To get it you had to jailbreak and simply enable it. Total BS move.

1
ImNotB3Pixel 3 XL 64GB :pixel3xlblack:•

Apple is the king of selling you less for more.

1
PrudentPlant•

What is less? What is more? Even if Apple were "mediocre", they are pretty solid with their offerings. You feel taken care of with Apple due to updates and such. Google doesn't really provide that feeling. Just saying as a consumer.

1
ImNotB3Pixel 3 XL 64GB :pixel3xlblack:•

Yeah I understand but on my Pixel I get monthly updates, Apple just doesn't innovate anymore there's not much new this year, but for example OnePlus 7 has a pop up camera, all display, 90hz display and in display fingerprint scanner, that's all new from OnePlus 6 > 7 but what about iPhone xs > 11? A new camera and that's about it

1
pppp2428•

“Apple doesn’t innovate”... 2 years later google copies Apple’s Face ID.

1
HMILOG8•

Google knows their shit hardware won’t last anyways.

1
EcstaticResolve•

Incorrect. They add new features to older devices all the time.

1
AppropriateOkra•

Semi related, I'm suspicious that Apple can vastly reduce the "notch" on iPhones but is waiting to do it to give people an extra reason to upgrade. Basically they'll milk the notch by leaving it in as long as it can be tolerated and then they'll reduce it and nearly eliminate it like some newer androids have.

1
pppp2428•

where's your tin foil hat? people on this same sub are talking about how pixel's thick top bezel is just awesome because there's so much tech squeezed in there.

1
Superyoshers9•

I mean they still update their old phones for like 5 years soo ¯\(ツ)/¯

1
JimboTheArtist•

Well for one in my company they give them free.Even tho most of them own a samsung as their main phone.So forcing on people it increases their sales for sure.

0
jmartin72Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

I have the same issue. My work phone is an iPhone 7, but my personal is a Pixel 3 XL

1
JimboTheArtist•

This year a lead asked to get a pixel 3 xl as a company phone cause he really hated apple and they granted his wish.Dunno why the default is iphone.

1
provoaggiePixel 3 XL 128GB•

But at least they get the new version number on their old phone. I hate it when Apple fanboys brag about how Apple is still giving updates to old phones when in reality they are stripping those updates of features that shouldn't be stripped.

-6
Romeo9594•

If you think the difference between an 8 and X or even X and 11 is just the bigger number then you are straight up delusional

5
provoaggiePixel 3 XL 128GB•

I'm not saying anything at all about the new hardware. I'm talking about software updates. People praise Apple for updating older phones with the latest iOS but they are always removing software features from those updates with the only reason being is that it devalues the new device. The older devices can run these same features just fine (and in some instances have). The problem is that if they release the full update to older phones then it doesn't give users any reason to upgrade. They get the new iOS version number on their phone but they're missing half of the features it's supposed to come with.

1
Romeo9594•

You honestly think that an iPhone 7 can run things like Animoji and AR and tape measure and Face ID despite not having the hardware needed to do it?

Seems to me like all that's missing this time that will actually work on older devices is Night Mode in the camera, something that yeah, is borderline criminal and indefensible. But it's not (imho) the big deal everybody is making it out to be for one very big reason: Your phone has always been able to take decent night shots. I mean, as good as a phone could that is.

Apple is actually one of the best for this, because they give you access to manual exposure and ISO in the default app itself. Failing that, there are tons of third part camera apps that have had an automatic Night Mode for years

I will still concede that it's really, really dumb to not have an auto night mode in the default camera app on a phone that can handle it. But it's even dumber to be complaining about "not getting" a feature that you've had available to you for half a decade

2
PrudentPlant•

I had this experience with my MacBook Pro. Doc synching was NOT supported on my 2009 machine for iCloud. HOWEVER, iCloud doc synching is supported for Windows XP and really old hardware runs XP.

Did this do this for performance? Did they do it for stability and not supporting everything under the sun? I don't know. All I know is that I dumped my Mac and got a Windows machine.

1
SnipingNinjaPixel 2 64GB :pixel2blue:•

They're talking about the OS. They're saying the new version number for those still hurts the old phones.

(Just clarifying what's being talked about, no arguments about it being legit or no

1
Romeo9594•

Yeah, he just clarified his statement to point out he was talking about OS. That's what I get for Redditing pre-coffee

I mean, he's still wrong. But wrong in a different way than I thought. Like, yeah they didn't make FaceID, Animoji, or AR features available on the iPhone 7. But that's because it literally doesn't have the hardware needed

It's like complaining that they didn't make the Kinect work on the original Xbox. Could they have technically done it? Probably. But it would have meant a lot of work to make a hamstrung version of the device for little to no financial gain and probably a lot of complaints from users

I have no defense of Apple nixing Night Mode from older devices that it would work on, and will agree that it's a dick move. But to think that every single new feature is kept from older phones for profit alone is just silly

2
PrudentPlant•

I'm not going to agree or disagree with a generalization. That may be true for some features, not true for others.

0
assorted_poptarts•

In terms of "support for older devices", I think Apple does a better job than anyone else at keeping older hardware viable.

Edit: Not to say that Google doesn't deserve kudos for bringing Night Sight to the older Pixels. I think it's great they did that, and it's impressive how well it works on the older hardware. Just pointing out that overall, Apple does a pretty solid job of keeping their devices up and running.

148
aaecharry•

This. Got an iPhone 8 Plus and a galaxy s8 around the same time. S8 has since became a pain to use, and the iPhone is still not showing any sign of slowing down.

Google makes great androids stock, but when a manufacturer start fumbling with the os, it’s just not as enjoyable anymore.

64
tiniwings•

I think that is the reason Google started Pixel lineup and they are even shouting about it in the latest Pixel 4 promo video (The google way)

They waited all these years to settle down with OEMs and now they are ready to show how the android phone should be as OEMs are not in position to abandon android now.

24
Proxi98•

Idk, my Pixel 2XL is becoming really laggy after 2 years and I just got a RMA replacement... There are times where I have lags opening the fucking home screen. Not all the time of course, but it happens.

7
PalmTree888•

Is this only an issue with the Pixel 2? I’ve heard MKBHD talk about it which again marred my thoughts a little on Pixel performance since the earlier reviews showed that the long term performance was good. The only performance complaints I’ve heard about the 3 were related to the camera app

1
Temporary_JackfruitPixel 3 :pixel3black:•

Yeah. I switched from the Samsung S7 to the pixel 3. Never going back to Samsung.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3†
edwinc8811Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

have you really used any phone that's newer than an s7? I used to think my s7 was just "fine" until I got a Pixel 2xl and made me realize how laggy and slow the S7 was

19
AlfaNagasakiPixel 3 64GB :pixel3black:•

Also had a S7 and confirm what you said, I didn't know it was laggy until I get a Pixel 3.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
aaecharry•

Yeah I had my hands on multiple phones due to my work. There’s some app testing and debugging, so phones do get reset frequently.

I think a phone will feel fine because as humans we allow ourselves to get used to incremental slowness. I’m using multiple phones concurrently and the difference is quite noticeable.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
forlornshepherd•

That's the real test to see if the hardware can still hold up. Plus it's nice to be pushed into dropping apps you don't use anymore.

2
PalmTree888•

I can attest to this. Got my 8 Plus around the same time as a family member got their Note 8 back in 2017. The Note 8 still feels like a great phone to use but definitely has inconsistent performance with simple things like launching the camera and even just hitting the home or back button in a way I find probably once or twice on my phone. Would you guys say a Pixel replicates the iPhones consistency well or is it in between an iPhone and Galaxy? Sucks since Samsung has great hardware, display and design that inspired me to switch to an S10+ and after playing around with it I could generally tolerate the known “downgrades” in terms of the lack of iMessage, compatibility with my Apple Watch (which thank god I got for free from a rewards card but I honestly don’t use beyond having a stylish digital watch) and no day one software updates . But after 48 hours, the main issue was a strange constant battery drain that made the phone take 7 hours to charge from 20 to 90 (which made me want to take it back to the store within the easy replacement period) but ultimately decided to return it since after paying all that cash, realising the front camera was somehow worse than my 2yo 8 Plus, the rear cam video recording indoors was really soft and far less detailed and having a couple of apps already crash and freeze the whole phone for ~30 sec which has happened on rare occasions on the 8 Plus but it only occurs over 5 seconds and yea I feel overall if the S10 out of the box was performing slightly worse than my two year old existing phone, I honestly don’t want to know how it will perform in a year or two down the road when I can’t easily use that reason to switch phones. Honestly thought Samsung had ironed it out after all these years but I should’ve probably been less optimistic and used the Note 8 as a guide

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dentistwithcavityPixel 4 :pixel4white:•

What? It is getting security updates.

1
techguy1231•

And the iPhone 8 is getting feature updates

1
masterpcface•

You mean the Samsung wasn't a pain to use on the first day? That's unusual.

1
provoaggiePixel 3 XL 128GB•

Apple does this a lot though. I first noticed it with Siri. Siri was a 3rd party app that Apple bought. It had been on the iPhone for a few years at that point. After Apple bought it they pulled it from the app store and disabled it on devices that had been using it for a couple of years. And then they released it with their new iPhone but said that they couldn't put it on older devices because they couldn't run it.

17
Tito1983Pixel 3 :pixel3black:•

I agree with you if you compare Apple against any other OEM. But if you compare Apple with Pixels I would say Google has catch up Apple and in fact is doing a better job so far (bringing Night Sight to 3 year old phones like Pixel 1, bringing Wellbeing to all line, updating to new OS all line at the same time, etc).

9
condoulo•

In terms of features, yes. In terms of overall longevity, Apple, sadly, still takes the cake.

11
DependentInternal•

updating to new OS all line at the same time, etc).

Apple does this....

5
Tito1983Pixel 3 :pixel3black:•

I know, but other Android OEMs apart from Google with the Pixels do not.

-1
DnB925Art3 XL 128, 2 XL 128, XL 128, Nexus 5, Nexus S 4G:pixel2xlpanda:•

Hey don't forget the Essential phone!

5
newton91•

Do you believe that Google will provide more than 3years support at their devices at the future ? ( I’m really considering to buy a pixel instead of another iPhone )

1
PalmTree888•

I hope they do. Honestly it kinda excites me that there is another phone that can match the iPhone’s consistent OS updates so I hope the Pixel 1 is supported as long as possible. When Google advertised “3 years of OS updates” I rolled my eyes a bit since why can’t they just match Apple on 5 years but I’m glad they’re heading there. It’s about the same age as the iPhone 7 (Late 2016) so I hope that both devices will be on par and get their last updates late next year to last them till 2021.

1
newton91•

I agree , I think google will provide 5 years of os support when pixel devices will be at a high market share at few countries

1
Tito1983Pixel 3 :pixel3black:•

I think so. At least with the Pixel 1 they have done it.

0
newton91•

They supporting pixel 1 more than 3 years ? Link ?

1
Ph0X•

It's a big pet peeve of mine when people compare iPhones to "all android phones", even the cheap 200$ ones.

Comparing to Pixel, which has only bee around for 3 years, Pixel 1 still got the Q update, so they've been doing pretty good so far.

8
assorted_poptarts•

Definitely agree. Flagship Android phones and flagship iPhones are basically up to personal preference at this point. Not fair to compare iPhones to budget Android phones. Google's done a good job so far with supporting the OG Pixel. Remains to be seen how long support will continue. If you base it off the Nexus line, Apple still wins out at longevity.

1†
DnB925Art3 XL 128, 2 XL 128, XL 128, Nexus 5, Nexus S 4G:pixel2xlpanda:•

But the Nexus never really was a real part of Google. They were iPhones manufactured by other OEMs in partnership with Google. But the Pixels, although built by some OEMS like LG and Foxconn for example, are basically fully Google phones, designed from the ground up by Google, whereby the OEM but is just a contractor to Google.

7
201680116•

The Nexus slight is part of the reason I've been afraid to take the pixel seriously, 3 years is not long enough to support a phone. Hopefully pixel gets longer support.

1
dleriumPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlwhite: | Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

I think we can all find examples of phone makers including Google and Apple and others who at times port features back to older devices but at other times keep new features exclusive. I honestly don't think that most of the time it's because some executive says "Yeah let's screw over our old loyal customers," but instead it's about a tradeoff of development resources, and maintaining the full experience.

0
mynamesjefffffs•

Well you have just been proven wrong lol

-21
anderaj57•

I mean they may not get all the features as newer models but the iPhone 6s that came out in 2015 has support for iOS 13. Not many Android developers support their devices for 4+ years. They also supported the iPad 2 for 5 years. I love the pixel and what Google is doing with it but its hard to say Apple does a bad job of supporting older hardware.

11
chasevalentino•

I don't think it's 'not many', I think 0 android phones in history have been supported for more than 3 years. I was hoping by getting a pixel that wouldn't be the case but it is

2
DnB925Art3 XL 128, 2 XL 128, XL 128, Nexus 5, Nexus S 4G:pixel2xlpanda:•

The OG Pixel already got it's 3rd major OS update from Android 8 to 10 this month so if it still gets monthly updates starting next month, that's technically more than 3 years. I would be super amazed if it got Android 11 a year from now.

0
filipebattPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlwhite:•

Because of one feature?

All companies do this to try and force people into the new tech. But apple has the least fragmented software, most of what is available in the 11, is available on the XS, and on the X.

10
mynamesjefffffs•

That's because there's like no new stuff on the 11? The most basic night mode, they can't even let the last year's 1000 dollar phone has budget version of it

-14
[deleted]•

Like Mr. Wolf said in Pulp Fiction, "let's not start suckin' each other's dicks just yet, gentlemen." I'm keeping my kudos for after the release of the Pixel 4.

99

Do you think they'll do the same for the astro cam?

75
abtimanPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlblack:•

One can only hope

42
svellePixel 3 64GB :pixel3white:•

That would be so awesome! That feature got me really excited for the next Gen. Also the Soli sensor, but mostly the astro cam...

19
abtimanPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlblack:•

Yeah same here man. I know the soli sensor is still gonna be in the building phase so it will probably have limited features at the moment. And honestly I'm cool with that, because they need to still test it out first to make it better. But as for the Astro cam, that thing got me wishing, hoping, and praying it's on the older models lol.

P.s. forgive my terrible grammar.

11

I completely agree and your grammar is A1!

6
chepi888•

Probably pixel 4 until Christmas time

1
patatonix•

I don't think so. The fact that they're coming so hard with the Pixel 4 makes me think that there's going to be a breakup feature wise towards older models. With astro cam I really want to be mistaken.

13
fperezgamonalPixel 1 XL 128GB :pixel1xlblack:•

I have an OG Pixel XL and would be so happy if it got ported but the difference in camera hardware may too much (hope not)

2
TresFacilement•

Isn't the Pixel 4's sensor the same as the Pixel 3?

5
fperezgamonalPixel 1 XL 128GB :pixel1xlblack:•

According to the leaked review it is right? Just wondering where they got that info from, though (code?)

2
Rem4g•

The main cam will still be 12mp but I imagine it will be a newer version of the sensor. Probably larger pixel size than the current 1.4 µm. If not larger pixel sizes they will still be newer versions of the sensor modules so should be fine.

1
RaitosuPixel 1 XL :pixel1xlsilver:•

Im also still rocking my OG Pixel XL and I'm glad that the camera is still on par with 2019 flagships. It may not have fancy features like OIS or a processor dedicated to processing images, but the end results are almost always nearly or as good as other pixels.

2
patatonix•

Well, I was talking about native support, the community porting features is a hope you can always have on Android I guess.

1
Ph0X•

Eh, I don't see why not. It's probably a similar text to Night Sight, with some tweaking of parameters specific to night sky. Probably even longer shutters since it's a static scene. If they could do night sight, they can do this too.

1
LooneyCat•

Wait, what is the astro cam? I haven't really been able to keep up with a lot of the updates and news lately.

9
chasevalentino•

Basically pixel 4's main camera feature will be the ability to take Astro photography ie: pictures of the stars

17
Rem4g•

I guess the main feature is subjective. I heard there's a motion photo mode that manages to prevent movement blur in pictures etc, not sure whether it will be automatic or an actual mode though. For me that will be a great feature as I've had many a smart phone picture ruined by fidgety subjects!

1
Caffinz•

Stuff like this but actually good. (Though to be fair my hand was shaking a bit at the time)

6
OldIndianMonkPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlblack:•

Click pictures of the night sky and such

5
ParrotofDoom•

That's pretty cool but the one thing that would make me immediately upgrade from my Pixel XL is a camera with a UV sensor. I would love to be able to see how well I've applied sunblock to my skin.

2
F1islife•

Even if they don't, you will probably be able to side load once someone makes it available. 'XDA_developers' has a ton of stuff you can load on your Pixel, and they are legit.

6
SnipingNinjaPixel 2 64GB :pixel2blue:•

u/cstark can probably do it, assuming it's possible

4
myalwaysthrowaway•

I'm thinking it might somehow be reliant on the dual camera setup for light collection or something, but I have no proof so we have to wait and see.

5
TrustMe_IHaveABeardPixel 2 XL :pixel2xlpanda:•

if not, I'm pretty sure someone on xda will port that. just like it was last time :)

2
torrewaffer•

Independent devs have already done it, so...

1
supercakefishPixel 3 128GB :pixel3white:•

Hopefully also motion sense camera feature.

1
-deteled-•

If have to bet special hardware is needed for that.

0
BookEmDano82•

primarily because Apples Night Mode seems to be hardware dependant... whereas Google's Night Sight is primarily a software build. Now Night Sight on the Pixel 3/3XL is a bit better than on the Pixel 2/2XL, it still looks amazing nonetheless.

49
gggiuliano•

Apple's version is heavily computational. I'd say it's as computational as the Pixel's. And even if it was purely based on hardware, how bad can you say the Xs hardware is that it just can't handle even a handicapped version of the new night mode?

42
Vince789Just Black•

Exactly, Google got Night Sight running on the old mid range Snapdragon 670

There's no way the Snapdragon 670 is faster than e.g. an A9

18
DemachePixel 3A XL•

Its not really that old, only a few months older than the 855. So the CPU featureset is pretty modern.

But still your right, if a 670 can handle it, an A9 could.

3
Vince789Just Black•

True, I meant to emphasis that it's not a brand new SoC with the leading edge DSP/NPU tech, which would give a major advantage over older Apple SoCs in ML/AI

e.g. the 730 is faster than the A12 in INT8 ML/AI (and possibly FP16?) as it has a similar DSP (with a NPU) as the 855

But the 670 is essentially just lower bins of the 710, which was released Q2 2018, and is a generation behind the 855

i.e. A75s, Hexagon 685 and Spectra 250 ISP in the 670. Vs the 855 with A76s, Hexagon 690 (with Tensor Accelerator) and Spectra 380 ISP

3
jeblis•

It's not whether the processor can handle it, it's that Apple has designed specialized hardware to do it. For the older phones to also do it, they'd have to implement it in software. Essentially doing the work twice.

5†
masterpcface•

You mean the firmware in the camera? That seems unlikely. It's not the lens or the sensor; those are just capturing light. It wouldn't make sense to build a camera that has a night sight mode within it's data capture firmware.

They could have a special image processing chip, which is what Google has done. But if that's the case it is imaginable that whatever code/algorithm that runs on this chip could be scalable (eg some sample setting) so that it would be detuned for the devices without dedicated hardware.

In any case, they've definitely decided that they aren't going to do this for existing devices. It's possible, but in the Apple way they prefer to just sell a new phone.

1
ICEman_c81•

They use the neural cores of the SoC for that stuff and they claimed new A13 is again leaps and bounds ahead even of A12. Hopefully Anandtech will be able to verify this, but at the moment typing this on Xs I'm rather pissed that night mode is an 11 exclusive. At least some folks at the event mentioned that Night Mode on 11 has real time preview on screen. Maybe they couldn't make that work at 60Hz on old phones?

-1
sylocheed•

Do you have a source for Apple's night sight being hardware dependent?

27
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-7
marm0ladePixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

No, Google's is not hardware dependent. The image processing chip you are referring to (Pixel Visual Core), makes image processing faster. It is not a requirement. The Pixel 3a does not have the Pixel Visual Core yet still has Night Sight mode. All of the processing is done by the CPU instead.

10
InsaneNinja•

How fast is it? Curious.

2
BookEmDano82•

No. But the way that Apple presented their new, improved night mode yesterday. they heavily emphasised the new camera module as the driving force behind the feature. where as Google breaks down Night Sight as using machine learning to achieve its goals. Therefore based on the software, Google is able to bring it to previous Pixel devices much easier. Now im not saying that software isnt a large part of it as gggiuliano stated, as he is probably 100% correct as well... i just believe that the hardware has more of an impact. Plus, the fact that if Apple was able to bring the enhanced Night Mode to previous iPhones, and given that, in my opinion, the iPhone 11/Pro/ProMax are really incremental upgrades from the previous gen, less people would be lining up to spend another $999/$1099 on the newest iPhone.

-14
downvoted_your_momPixel 2 XL•

You don’t have a source but you’re telling everyone it’s hardware dependent? Dude ....

24
BookEmDano82•

Just changed the wording on my initial comment. My apologies.

3
downvoted_your_momPixel 2 XL•
5†
BookEmDano82•

well thats good for them then. i based my statement entirely on Apples previous practices and what they say and/or don't say in their reveals. I spent ten years selling iPhones for Verizon and very rarely did they make certain super popular features available to older models.. and it was mostly due to hardware constraints. So now it seems that many of those constraints have been lifted.

-3†
dleriumPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlwhite: | Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

Sounds like implicit bias. You made an assessment not based on current facts.

4
Vince789Just Black•

Fact is that night mode is exclusive to the iPhone 11/11 Pro. Source

That post is showing Smart HDR's output is better than the viewfinder, just like HDR+

Speaking of Smart HDR, that's another software feature Apple refused to bring back to older iPhones

3
downvoted_your_momPixel 2 XL•

So you sold iPhones for years and that exempts you from making statements without facts? K buddy lmao

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
chasevalentino•

No one's nightsight is hardware dependant. A phone sensor is only so big. The closest we've got is Huawei but even then their standard mode photo is most of the time as good as their night mode photo

3
dleriumPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlwhite: | Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

HDR+ is too, and as someone who's used HDR+ on a Nexus 6P, Pixel XL, Pixel 2 XL and now Pixel 3 XL, performance has improved over the years.

Let's say hypothetically HDR+ didn't come out until the Pixel (it's like the SmartHDR feature on iPhones). Now one of my biggest gripes with the 6P was how SLOW it was with HDR+ and where the phone could totally lock up if you shot a few photos in rapid succession. I could imagine a VP at Apple saying "Hey the experience on our old phone is subpar, so let's not roll it out to the old phone." That's not the same as someone saying "Hey let's screw our old customers." I could see the argument going either way. As a 6P owner, I loved HDR+ but it was also EXTREMELY frustrating with how slow it was and how you could clog up the buffer if you're not careful.

This happens with Google and Apple honestly. For instance Night Shift rolled out in 2016 in iOS 9.3, and was available for even the iPhone 5s (2013). Meanwhile Google copied the feature into Nougat in later 2016 and the Nexus 6p was supposedly incapable of having that feature despite seeing some XDA mods out there. I think that instead of always blaming these phone makers and saying they're deliberately trying to screw customers over, maybe there's a more detailed story and reason for their decisions.

2
afcanonymous•

hardware dependant.

The computation is accelerated by the hardware... Like the Pixel visual Core. The difference is Nightsight doesn't need the chip to run, but is accelerated by it.

1
nimajnebPixel 3a XL•

Is that true? The Pixel 3 has a dedicated processor for image processing. I just assume the Pixel 3 can do more complex image processing with it. I mean I'm sure Night Sight is better on a Pixel 3 than my Pixel 3a XL.

1
BNSoulPixel 3 :pixel3white:•

The 3 and 3 XL are just faster, the end result is pretty even.

6
nimajnebPixel 3a XL•

ah, I wasn't sure if the image processor is for speed or to do more complex stuff.

1
BNSoulPixel 3 :pixel3white:•

Well, the main purpose of the Pixel Visual Core is to help 3rd party apps achieve the same image quality as the Google Camera app. In addition, this dedicated hardware also accelerates HDR+ processing and saves battery (it's more efficient with regard to HDR+ image processing than the CPU on the Snapdragon chipset).

3
dleriumPixel 3 XL :pixel3xlwhite: | Pixel 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

Is the result pretty even? Has anyone shown 100% crops and pixel peeped and argued over it? No offense to you but a lot of people make sweeping claims about camera performance without offering any detailed assessments.

1
BNSoulPixel 3 :pixel3white:•

No offense taken. The 100% crops and argumentations you're looking for are here: https://www.dxomark.com/google-pixel-3a-camera-review/

2
Rem4g•

Pictures are pretty much the same but video noise reduction is really bad on the 3a compared to the 3 at least with the selfie camera (from some videos I saw). That's probably just the lower spec processor though rather than the lack of the visual core (maybe it's both?)

Ideally it's not the best thing in terms of power efficiency to have a separate chip for the image processing though, especially if its not got the most efficient architecture. The Snapdragon 855 on the Pixel 4 has decent neural AI processing built in so maybe they'll use what's already available on the 7nm architecture SoC and help the power efficiency slightly too as a result *shrug*

1
calamitysirPixel 2 XL :pixel2xlblack:•

*adds deeper color contrast and brighter display*

Nobody:

Apple: Let's call it Super Retina Display XDR!!

26
NoTimeToKYS•

I hope they sell some peripheral glasses, because the real world must look pretty dull after looking at that display for a while.

6
TomCruiseFor2020•

Meanwhile Samsung “Super AMOLED infinity”

3
Sharpshooter98b🅱ixel 1 :pixel1silver:•

Does Samsung even use the full wordings anymore? I thought they have been using the name "Infinity something something" display? Like infinity edge, infinity o, etc.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
epicandstuffPixel 4 XL :pixel4xlblack:•

It's also behind Google, Huawei, and Samsung's versions of low light photography. I'm sure it will catch up eventually, but as it stands they're unfortunately behind and it doesn't help that both Huawei and Google are probably going to announce improved versions in the coming months. But I am glad that iPhone users finally have it at all though.

21
mitchytan92•

Way behind? Is there any demo of it already?

12
mynamesjefffffs•

If they were ahead they would've showed the competition like they do with their software update speed and availability

25
mitchytan92•

No I am asking if the night mode on iPhone 11 series is it inferior as compared to Pixel 3 series' night sight.

5
mynamesjefffffs•

No one would know as of now. No one has the phone to test

17
ReggyDawkins•

That’s some dumbfuck reasoning

1
hkyqsupppper silver•

Yeah at the Apple presentation yesterday there was a demo

2†
mitchytan92•

I thought it is just a before and after and not a real demonstration and the night mode seems okay?

8
NvidiaforMenQuite Black•

Yeah, well their before and after in their own ideal conditions was worse than googles

-2†
bartturner•

Yes on Google. Google is really on a complete tier when it comes to computational photography.

2
joekzy•

It’s being broadly lauded as better than the Pixel’s night sight photos, you can see the example here “So the iPhone 11 camera does better in bright light than the Pixel 3 and Note 10, and Night mode beats the Pixel 3 more often than not. If the deep fusion update improves medium-to-low light performance as much as Apple says it will, the iPhone 11 will take better photos than the competition in every lighting situation.”

Also here “In addition, whatever juice Google is using to get these images out of a single camera and sensor, it suffers enormously on a detail level. You can see the differences here in the rock work and towers. It’s definitely better than having a dark image, but it’s clear that the iPhone 11 Pro is a jump forward.”

Thee are various other reviews putting Apple’s implementation above Night Sight.

2
epicandstuffPixel 4 XL :pixel4xlblack:•

Yes now that there are more examples available I've seen that Apple's lowlight photos are better. I still prefer the pop of the Pixel, but Apple's is very good.

1
LivingInGammonPixel 2 :pixel2white:•

Why are you glad for that? And why unfortunately? Who cares about iPhone users? It's not like they're forced to buy them.

0†
epicandstuffPixel 4 XL :pixel4xlblack:•

I care about iPhone users? Some people are tied to the Apple ecosystem, or are just used to iPhones for various reasons and I think it's nice that they also get lowlight photography now. It's one of the best smartphone camera features to come of the last couple years and I think everyone deserves it.

5
LivingInGammonPixel 2 :pixel2white:•

LMAO sorry bro. Just an odd stance to hold, not that you're wrong, but it's just funny.

0
theJamesKPolk•

Pretty sure Apple is doing this in near real-time, without a user needing to switch to another mode. Also, Apple’s goal isn’t to “brighten as much as possible”, but to include more light while still making it clear that it’s a night-time/dark photo.

Regardless, no one has the phone to fully test and compare it out, so saying it’s “behind” those other OEMs is premature.

0
Fran6coJL•

I like Apple hardware and software but this is what kills me about them.

Why is my iPhone camera max that was the ultimate shit just two day ago not able to do night sight lol

If it weren’t for the Apple Watch and my love for iPad I would have switched.

12
PalmTree888•

Yes I agree on that. Since I’m coming from an older, cheaper iPhone it’s less of a kick in the teeth but I can imagine buying an XS Max and the next day having the feature exclusive to even the cheaper base iPhone 11. Kinda surprised me since I saw Night Sight trickle down on the Pixels so I assumed that Apple would do the same given their general history of bringing OS updates and features to older phones but yea :(

1
aweracle•

Do you know much about galaxy watch? I've got one and I always hear people say the apple watch is the best smart watch but I can never find anything that makes it better.

Just interested in your opinion.

1
thaibeachtraveller•

Apple are miles ahead in terms of supporting older devices. My iPhone 7 still flies, and the fact that support for devices from 2013 is only just about to stop is quite something.

However, my OG Pixel seems way snappier with 10 than it was with 9.

10
KingOfTheCouch13•

I mean so far we can't really say if Apple is miles ahead in terms of support older devices compared to Google yet. So far all pixel devices have gotten evey major update. Even if it does only goes back 3 years lol.

2†
Efrojas16•

Samsung galaxy 8 isnt supported tho?

-4
KingOfTheCouch13•

Galaxy devices are not made by Google. They make the software. We can only consider Pixels here because Google actually makes the software and hardware for them. It's up to Samsung to push the updates to their own phones.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
KingOfTheCouch13•

Nexus devices were different than pixel devices. Sure the software was handled by Google but a hardware oem definitely has impact on how updates are handled as well. Pixel phones are the first time Google handles both and are doing a fine job so far.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†

However, my OG Pixel seems way snappier with 10 than it was with 9.

I'd like to say the same, unfortunately my Pixel is slowing down more and more every day. I think I'll try formatting it.

1
za1us3xl :pixel3xlwhite: pixelbook :chromebookpixel:•

Google has always been great about this with their Nexus line and are carrying into their Pixel line. They should get more credit for back supporting old devices with new software every year.

8
raxiel_Clearly White (UK)•

They still held back superzoom

6
torrewaffer•

And a LOT of other things, like synthetic fill flash, top shot, learned depth on portrait mode, photobooth, tracking autofocus and even HEVC.

2
bartturner•

But rumor is we will get it with the Pixel 4.

If the rumors turn out true the Pixel 4 will be the phone to get this year.

0
raxiel_Clearly White (UK)•

That's good if true. There are some extra features on the modified gcam apk I have, but personally superzoom is the only thing making me use it over stock on the Pixel 2.
I'm more interested in the P4 than I was the P3, but its more curiosity than genuine interest. I can't justify spending the kind of cash they will inevitably be charging as long as my P2 still works.

1
ImNotB3Pixel 3 XL 64GB :pixel3xlblack:•

We sell you less for more -Apple 2019

5
bartturner•

It is looking like the Pixel 4 is going to push the state of the art well ahead of the iPhone if the rumors turn out true.

4
baseballandfreedom•

Not to sound like an apologist, but from what I understand about Apple’s version of Night Mode, once it becomes activated, the viewfinder shows you what the scene looks like in real time in Night Mode even before you take the photo.

As far as I know with the Pixel, you’re shooting into the dark and are unaware of what the photo will look like until after the phone processes it?

I’m not saying a phone like the Xs CAN’T do night mode, but I can’t imagine previewing the scene with Night Mode actively running is light on the processor.

3
TresFacilement•

Dark previewing must be easier to achieve with multiple lenses, maybe the Pixel 4 will have it as well

0
The_Real_FN_Deal2 XL :pixel2xlblack:3 XL :pixel3xlwhite: 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

It’s like they ran out of reasons to get you to upgrade and to justify the poorly received cooking stove on the back. This kind of stuff is why I switched to the pixel, apple can get real scummy.

2†
TomBoysHaveMoreFun•

I’m all for bashing Apple but I cant wait for everyone to eat their words about the camera modules on the back. If the rumors are true the new Pixel back camera will look extreamly similar.

-4
Valiant_Boss•

Yeah but so far Google has had one of if not THE best camera on a smartphone with only one camera on the back. I can't wait to see what they can do with all the extra stuff they added.

7
TresFacilement•

Well said, the software to get things done with a single sensor is nothing short of genius

2
The_Real_FN_Deal2 XL :pixel2xlblack:3 XL :pixel3xlwhite: 4 XL :pixel4xlwhite:•

The videos look good for the Pixel 4 especially the white one. The white iPhone 11 pro looks the worst since all 3 of the cameras have their own black circles which make them pop out even more. I actually don't mind the space gray and midnight green iPhone 11 pro, the square blends a little better and that frosted glass finish is nice. My gripe is that they're pulling another classic apple move and restricting features to the newer phones when Google already proved you don't need the newest, most expensive phone to get their jaw dropping night sight. Imagine spending 1,100 on an iPhone XS max last year or this year, and hearing you won't get Apple's new night mode because they don't feel like giving it to you. What a joke.

1
fiendishfork•

Apples looks really bad, they have a huge square camera bump, and then each lens has its own camera bump on top of that. Googles looks like at least the lens are flush with the overall bump, plus the whole bump is blacked out so the cameras blend in better.

-2
MidwayRoar54•

OG PixelXL owner here. Love love looove the night sight.

2
phuongh•

Google does the same for many features like Dual sim dual standby, super res zoom, portrait mode...

2
bartturner•

This is a big issue and makes 100% sense to share.

Same with the bloatware you get with Samsung phones. Things like unable to delete Facebook.

https://amp.usatoday.com/amp/2522954002 Samsung phone owners reportedly cannot delete Facebook app

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1

They should add the feature where my charging port doesn't fuck up every few months

1