Commish veto power without a vote due to injured players acceptable or no?

[removed]

Posted Sep 11, 2019, 9:47 PM UTC · edited

047
Seb_Nation•

If he was dumb enough to accept a trade without knowing the outcome of an injury well that's the game ... Commish should stay away from it to my eyes.

10
justknoweverythingOP•

Guy went back in and finished the game why would you suspect a season ending break? This actually happened with McNabb back when. Finished the game on a broken ankle with 4 TDs

-8

Lol no

Buyer beware

8
justknoweverythingOP•

how when nobody new he was injured and it didn't come out until a day later? Is that really fair? even in a buyer beware, is it fair? the whole point of trade review is that it's fair and not one team taking advantage of another. Injuries shouldn't allow you to screw someone

-8
MyWorkAccount210•

They weren't taking advantage when the trade was made. Them's the breaks.

9
justknoweverythingOP•

makes sense; i guess you can say the trade while actually unfair is not taking advantage and thus allowed

3

What if he gets injured a day later? Two days later?

First play of the game the following week of the trade?

4
justknoweverythingOP•

I lean towards if they get injured during trade protest time it makes the trade unfair.; - I take this back, i'm up in the air if the injury happens after acceptance, but before it goes through. I was more concerned about injury that has happened and wasn't made public.

edit if a game happens during protest time, then I agree to let the trade go through as that is a clear known risk that playing another game could lead to injury still.

0

I disagree

There shouldn’t even be a “trade protest” time

The league shouldn’t “vote” on trades. All trades go through unless they’re obvious collusion. End of it

2
nomnomnompizza•

Don't make trades for players who got injured during a game without knowing they are 100% ready for the next week.

3
justknoweverythingOP•

most logical choice I guess, but you risk the trade being pulled.

1
panduh0225•

No. Vetos are only for collusion not buyers remorse

5
Steak_Knight•

Life is unfair. The info is out there for anybody who wants to get it. Trade stands.

4
justknoweverythingOP•

info wasn't out until next day. in real life the trade would not go through, why is fantasy different?

-2
Steak_Knight•

Because the managers had access to the same info at the same time. Buyer beware. Same goes for "trading a known injured player to someone unsuspecting." That unsuspecting person needs to start suspecting.

6
Vote_CE•

Imo vetoes are only for collusion.

2
manoman1232010•

Dude, suck it up.

You’re arguing with everyone on this thread. It doesn’t look like you want honest feedback, you want people to validate your opinion.

People are telling you the trade shouldn’t be vetoed based on the info provided. They offered their honest, objective opinions. If you don’t like the feedback, fine. Ignore it. Just don’t keep wasting their time with these replies.

2
justknoweverythingOP•

what are you talking about i'm clarifying the situation. There was no info out is what I was making clear. I do want honest feedback and it seems everyone says it should stand and even should stand if one player trades a knowingly injured player to a moron that accepts, so I guess trades are free game to screw people as long as they aren't in on it together. I always thought it was about being a fair trade to the league and not one owner winning because he screwed the moron of the group, which ruins the season fro all imo. If people don't mind that then i guess I don't have much to argue.

​

I did agree with the one saying it was fair when made and accepted and the timing of the disclosed injury is irrelevant

1
manoman1232010•

You’re not clarifying. You’re arguing. Look at your last two sentences, starting with “I always thought...”. Does that look like a clarifying statement or a further appeal?

They don’t have to be perfectly even trades. They just have to be semi-reasonable at the point the trade was accepted.

Again, you’re looking at ranges of outcomes. If the player wasn’t okay with the potential range of outcomes, they shouldn’t have made the trade. That’s my honest opinion. I have nothing to gain or lose by telling you this. I won’t be offended if you ignore me or the other 15 people who I agreed with here.

1
nomnomnompizza•

Because it's a game and not real life

1
Hschieff•

That’s the risk the traders take making a trade in game

1
Juno_Malone•

Because 'fantasy' is, by definition, literally the opposite of 'real life'?

1
justknoweverythingOP•

lol

1
flaamed•

If the trade started with the guy not injured, and was accepted with the guy not injured (publicly) then it should go through imo

3
nomnomnompizza•

No. As soon as that accept button has been hit the trade is valid.

3
nickbrownokc•

Mahomes has broken ankle and is out for season??

3
nomnomnompizza•

lol no. I think OP didn't want to admit he just traded for someone like Henry.

6
Juno_Malone•

that's a bingo

2
Birdgang14•

Lol yeah what the fuck?

2
SnowThrasher•

This belongs in the index, there is some serious AB news right now.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
justknoweverythingOP•

lol there are like 10 threads about AB I don't expect this to get upvotes just want a couple thoughts

0
SnowThrasher•

That is why you use the index thread and I am waiting on updates 11 and 12 for AB.

2
forward1213•

This is why you don't leave trades open during games. Whatever happens is their fault.

2
justknoweverythingOP•

trade was after the game finished. The player finished the game, nobody would suspect someone going back in and finishing the game to be seriously injured.

1
arsenalfc1987•

How is that any different than trading for a player and him getting injured the next day? Why did the person have to accept a trade on a Sunday night? Why not wait a few days and see what happens? Absolutely positively 100% not vetoable. Sucks for the buyer, but that’s life. He should have waited a few days.

2
justknoweverythingOP•

Accepting quickly would be out of fear of the trade offer being removed.

1
manoman1232010•

I would never veto that.

Both players assume the risk and reward associated with the trade. If you don’t have enough information to accept each range of outcomes for players, don’t make the trade.

1
diggersbynation•

Index

0†
spreerod1538•

He's giving a hypothetical.. Mahomes wasn't actually traded in his league and isn't hurt in real life.

5
diggersbynation•

It is not a hypothetical, as you can clearly read in his comments. And there is a league issues thread in the index.

1
justknoweverythingOP•

it clearly is hypothetic wtf

1
justknoweverythingOP•

how?

4
Hschieff•

Ask this in the index is what he meant

1
MecoleScott•

No

0