mfa: Out with the old, in with the new. Starting from bottom up. What do you think of these shoes I'm looking at.

So quick back story, its time to get rid of my old clothes and pay more attention to my fashion. I have a few good outfits but I need way more. I also didn't rush for fashion since a lot of people I've met in my city look down upon men for wearing decent clothing. A lot of the people wear sports shirts, baseball caps, and polos are considered dressy.

So I wanted to start with getting decent shoes. I'll be looking into getting nice dark jeans, slim fit khakis, sweater vests/v-neck sweaters/ solid t-shirts, the works really.

So here are the shoes I've been looking at, brutal honesty or alternative recommendations whether because you see a better style or something cheaper but similar are very appreciated.

Sperry Boat Shoes - Nice shoes, I'm unsure about the color.

Puma Sneaker - For that sporty casual look. I really like the color and design but not a big fan of all the logos they throw on their shoes.

Converse All Star Suede for casual or maybe slightly dressy attire. Main point is for this shoe to be worn with almost anything casual I throw on.

Loafers - Need something dressy yet can be worn with Jeans.

Kennth Cole Reaction - I think MFA in general is not a fan of KC?

Sperry Top Sider - Looks great. Is it too similar to the boat shoe style?

Smooth leather oxfords - Lastly some nice dress shoes.

Yays, Nays, or alternative recommendations are appreciated. Unfortunately all I have to reimburse your time are upvotes. Thank you.

Posted Aug 19, 2010, 9:44 PM UTC

1034
zestways•

Sperry Boats - Go with a darker brown leather. They will weather and wear better than that canvas. Don't even think about ever wearing socks.

Pumas - They really don't look or wear nearly as good as they look new. I have had friends buy them and have them look horrible within a month. If you are looking for sporty/casual, go with some Adidas Sambas.

Converse - Not bad, I do like them.

KC - Toes should be round, not square or pointed

Sperry Tops - You really only need one pair of boat shoes. Yes, they are that similar.

Ox - a little reserved and plain, nothing to really complain or rave about, but a cap toe would look a little better

5
marcuspowersOP•

Thanks for pointing out the Adidas Sambas. I just need to figure out if I want them in black or white now.

2
zestways•

Both look good, but I think that black are a little more versatile. You can dress it up a little easier with black than white.

Don't ever worry about being overdressed. You can most likely tell what the expectations of any place or event that you go to are. One of the best pieces of advice that I ever got was that no matter the place, event, or company, you are better off being slightly over-dressed, than slightly under-dressed.

2
Andoo•

Might I suggest something besides the Adidas just for looking purposes. Not that the Sambas are bad, but they are worn a lot. I'm a big fan of the Onitsuka Tigers.

a good leather substitute

even an all black looks good

if you wanted some contrast

Honestly I love the way I look in these shoes and not a lot of people sport them compared to other shoe brands.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Andoo•

I'm just trying to match what he's showing me.

If he posted this

Then I would have suggested wild colors, but he didn't. So please fuck off with extra smiles!

1
josemanan•

Upvote for Samba's, got them when I started playing indoor soccer and now they're my go-to's.

1
notacceptable•

imho, from bottom to top:

Smooth leather oxfords - Yay.

Sperry Top Sider - On the fence...

Kennth Cole Reaction - Nay.

Converse All Star Suede - Yay.

Puma - Nay.

Sperry Boat - Nay, due to the color.

That's just me. I'm pretty new to MFA and still learning, and too lazy to dress how I should... so... take it as you will.

2
chrispyb•

for the sperrys, just get one classic standard leather topsider, with laces, not that lacesless one

agree with the rest this man above has said.

3
marcuspowersOP•
1
chrispyb•
4
notacceptable•

I really like these two a lot more than the Sperry's.

1
epicviking•

I want to like these, but leather soles on a boat shoe dont make much sense to me.

1
marcuspowersOP•

Wow nice find. I'm tempted to buy those shoes in your first link. Out of curiosity, do you personally wear your boat shoes/mocs with both casual and dressed up attire?

1
Andoo•

If you are gonna check out those LL Bean and might be in that price range, take a look at the

Hembree Penny1

Hembree Penny2

These will offer a different style for your boat shoe look. Not saying they are better or worse, just something else to look at here

1
epicviking•

Classic, get dark brown or light brown

Eurotrash

Get classic canvas in white. no reason to mess with something great. If you want upscale chucks get jack purcells.

Ugly. do not get. If you want loafers get some penny loafers or something with a leather sole.

meh. not a fan of the laces on the side. would want a plainer venetian.

again, meh. For dress shoes be prepared to spend 200+ You cannot get around this. Quality leather and construction is costly.

Dont get a lot of cheap shoes, get a few nice pairs. You would be ok with a pair of topsiders, a pair of canvas chucks, and a pair of nice leather oxfords from allen edmonds in brown.

2
luckytopher•

Must spend 200+?

What an imbecile.

-1
epicviking•

The person asked for a suggestion for a dress shoe. dress shoes almost always have certain features (leather sole, last, certain thicker kinds of leathers). Those features typically cost about 200. I'm just letting op know that. For all we know he could be some business man, and non dress shoes would get him ridiculed at meetings or whatever. different people have different takes on shoes. shrugs

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
gremwood•

On your sneaker selections, you can do a lot more with less money.

If you want to stick with Pumas, I'm going to endorse their El Rey's, simply because its is very hard to go wrong if you avoid the "Patchy" versions. If you aren't afraid to go elsewhere, Adidas has always made their Sambas line!

2
marcuspowersOP•

Not a lot of love for Pumas around these parts. I liked the design in the puma I posted but I really hate all of the logos they threw on it. I'm not sponsored so theres no need for that. Yeah I think the Sambas are where its at.

1
gremwood•

I stay away from the drift cats/whatever. These tend to be cleaner and have less logo crapping. Everyone has a different taste though!

1
r-r-roll•

I'm not sure about what kind of casual shoes you're looking for (I personally wear these, still 16 so it goes well with a bright t-shirt and jeans - looking to replace them soon though, I've had them for over a year) and as for the more formal shoes I wear these. I picked them up while I was in China for about $15 or $20. I wear these every other day or so - usually with slim fit black jeans and a dress shirt, sometimes a suit vest as well.

As for the shoes you've chosen, I think the Pumas look pretty good - but they won't look so good after a while if you wear them anywhere with mud or dirt. If you can take care of them and wash them every few months (which is a pain) I'd say go for it. I'm not a fan of converse usually, but I guess they can look okay at times. Not particularly nice, not bad though.

I like the KC Reactions, I know a lot of people don't like square tipped shoes but I disagree with saying that all are bad in all situations. With a slim build, square tips can look great. I saw it all the time in Japan, and occasionally see it here in Canada. Those are pretty nice shoes in general, but I personally prefer black (shiny too - they're hard to care for but worth it in my opinion).

The oxfords are nice as well, they'd go well with a suit but not so much with regular jeans in my opinion.

It all depends on the look you're going for.

2
marcuspowersOP•

Great. Thanks for the tip about Pumas. I'm a bit older than you so I want my casual shoes a bit more modest/underwhelming and more of that classic kickback look.

Those shoes you picked up in china for 15 bucks are a great deal.

1
luckytopher•

not a fan of the topsiders or the converse, but if they look okay on you, so be it...

for the KC, look at something with laces, even for casual...

Might also add a good pair of cross trainers in there... they make for decent casual depending on your area/weather/etc, good for long days on your feet

1
Synroc•

The All Star Suede look great ! I'm considering them myself.

1
[deleted]•

The classic top-sider with the laces on top is a serious standby for me. Wear them sockless, cuff your pants, show off some ankle. Bitches love a bit of ankle.

1
Liberalguy123•

Overall? Not bad. But for god's sake don't get the Kenneth Coles. Never. Never ever ever. And I'm no fan of Puma sneakers, but that one's up to you.

0
marcuspowersOP•

See I thought I detected a little MFA hate towards Kenneth Coles...any reason?

2
luckytopher•

Because there are a lot of douches in MFA that associate price only and hook onto whatever's trendy to hate as well..

There's no real valid reason. KC makes some decent looking products for those trying to look good on a budget.

2
Liberalguy123•

see my above comment.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Liberalguy123•

most are either pointy or square, which is just loathsome. And they oftentimes have little rivets or graphics which cheapens and spoils the already douchey shoes. On top of that, the soles are of some composite material, not leather as they should be.

0
seydar•

Harsh shit down below.

Sperry Boat Shoes - No.

Puma Sneaker - You've got the right idea, but EVERYONE in middle school has this shoe. Get something new and different. It can still be Puma. http://www.zappos.com/puma-cabana-racer-ii-white-team-regal-red-black

Converse All Star Suede - These are good. Get these (perhaps with a bit of color?)

Loafers - Yes, for when you wear a suit, although I am personally a fan of laced-up shoes.

Kennth Cole Reaction - I'm sorry, but not. I see guys wearing these and I want to cry myself to sleep.

Sperry Top Sider - Boat shoes. No.

Smooth leather oxfords - Theeeeeeeere we go! This is a nice dress shoe. Get this. Drop the loafers. You're a man, now, and real man use shoelaces.

0