r/sonos•
Seber

<Are Play:1s still worth buying?

I would like to enter the Sonos world with a stereo pair of speakers. With the recent release of the One SL replacing the Play:1, how future proof is the latter? I use android, so I don't really care about the added AirPlay functionality.

From my understanding, the speakers are the same internally, so Play:1s would be perfect for me. However, If Sonos one day decides they no longer work, they'll be dead pieces of plastic. I'd assume this happens to the Play:1s way before the One SLs.

I might just go with a pair of Symfonisk, assuming they'll be equally future proof compared to the One SL, but are $100 per piece cheaper than the SL ($200 total).

Given these options, which one would you go with, and why?

  • Two Symfonisk for $200
  • Two Play:1 for $330
  • Two One SL for $400

Posted Sep 12, 2019, 1:17 PM UTC

217
CubsFan1060•

I think the One SL is $179? So your price for those would be $360.I agree with the other poster though, the Play:1 will likely see some deals coming up.

Personally I'd probably get the regular One's if you have Android. Not guaranteed, of course, but it sounds like there's a good chance auto trueplay could come to them.

I have the Symfonisk, and I don't agree that they are close to the 1's/One's. They are cheaper for a reason. I also have Play:1 and Sonos 1 to compare them against.

4
Eyetron2020•

I don’t think you need to worry about Play:1s simply not working anytime soon (unless there’s a failure of course). The original ZP100 (original Amp) still works and came out in 2004 (15 years old).

Play:1 is only 6 years old from 2013.

4
splitplug•

I only own Play:1's now. They are perfect for all my indoor and outdoor needs. They often go on sale for $150 or less, especially around the holidays.

3
mjlp716•

Watch this about the Symfonisk's, they are pretty close to just being larger Play 1's internals wise. So if you decide on Play 1's you might as well get the Symfonisk's since they are cheaper in my opinion. He does mention the capacitors aren't great, but then shows the board from Play 1's having the same ones. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZB413S8KDmo

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
lanceuppercuttr•

With the SL, the price for Play 1's may drop soon. Wouldn't be surprised of they phase the Play 1 out. Sonos supports old stuff for a long time and the Play 1 must be one the most popular sku over the he past 5 years so its really doubtful they'll ever really stop supporting it. Play 1 are still great speakers and still probably the most appropriate speaker for rear channels in a 5.1 set up.

If it was me, Id wait to see the SL release and watch Play 1 prices. If the SL is 200 each, what os the One G2? Im skeptical of the iKea gear as I have not done any personal comparison.

1
IcyKettle•

This. They already dropped the price when the One came out and now they'll probably drop again and eventually discontinue them. But as someone who has no interest in voice assistants or AirPlay and actually prefers the legacy design with physical buttons (I hate the touch buttons on my AMP), I'm planning on picking up a handful more soon if they really do go on clearance. I see no evidence Sonos won't support them for several more years and they sound great.

But also plan to pick up at least one Symf as a stopgap in rooms where I just want low-level background music.

1
SeberOP•

Regular One is $230. I don't care about voice assistants at all though. I mean I've got one on my phone that I never use.

I guess I'll wait for deals on the Play:1 and then decide. There's also Black Friday coming up, but patience is none of my strenghts.

1
CarlRJ•

Perhaps we should establish what you mean by "$". The Sonos One is $199 (USD) on the Sonos website.

1
SeberOP•

By $ I mean US$. Since I'm not based in the US but most users on here are, I converted the price I'd have to pay.

1
CarlRJ•

Ah, okay, thanks. Makes more sense now.

2
lassehjorth•

I have both Play:1 and Symfonisk - and i am happy with both.

I wouldn’t be nervous about Play:1 becoming unsupported, - they have been sold until recently.

I would likely choose the Symfonisk, depending on where they should be installed - the original Sonos, is somewhat smaller and have a nicer look (imo).

/Lasse

1
CarlRJ•

Of the three, the Play:1's are the ones most likely to be found for a substantial discount - I got a pair at CostCo some weeks back for $270 (just checked, they're still the same price), quite a bit lower that your list. Changes the curve somewhat. As others have said, they'll be supported for a very long time to come. And the Play:1's and One SL should sound exactly the same, while there are varying opinions on whether the Symfonisk's sound as good (close, sure, but possibly not quite as good). The Symfonisk are also quite a bit bigger, which may or may not be important to you.

1
Notuniquesnowflake•

Symfs are great for the price, but they have a smaller driver and produce less bass. I'd get them for a bedroom or other secondary space. But I'd still recommend the Play:1s or Ones for your primary listening space.

Especially since, if you're patient, you'll probably be able to find a great deal on some clearance or open box Play:1s or first gen Ones.

1
stan_qaz•

The One SL is a lot more flexible than the Play 1, haven't seen the specs on the internals yet but they may be better too.

The Play 1 does have real buttons on it, a very handy thing in some situations where the touch controls are an aggravation. I don't regret buying my Play 1s.

1
McFeely_Smackup•

I would not pay those prices for any of those speakers except te Symfonisk. Why are they priced so high? are you in Australia?

0
SeberOP•

I'm in Switzerland, but close to the Austrian border. Those are the cheapest prices I could find comparing both countries.

1
McFeely_Smackup•

Ah, that' makes sense...although it's interesting that the Symfonisk price is the the same as the USD price while the Sonos branded speakers are much higher.

1