Blizzard support response regarding trading gold between Classic and Retail, no mention of/dancing around the subject of suspension.

Posted Sep 13, 2019, 7:05 PM UTC

Posted Sep 13, 2019, 7:05 PM UTC
they aren't dancing around the subject. they are simply stating that they will not intervene in any way if you get scammed out of such a trade because there are no in game mechanisms to facilitate a secure trade between retail and classic. it's like cross-realm trading, and this has been their stance on this since the vanilla days. it's not against the rules but it is absolutely at your own risk.
I doubt they'd suspend you for doing it. Not like it breaks the game. They're just saying you're risking it by trusting the person to give you the gold on Classic.
If it were against TOS, they would come out and plainly state it was against TOS. They did not, therefore it is not.
Wish they plainly stated either way. If you read the thread there's 2 things:
"It's clearly against the tos retard"
"It's clearly not against the tos retard"
Regardless, I guess I am a retard for trying to get some conclusion on it, but there is none and people are still divided.
This has been known for awhile. Does not go against the TOS but if the person just steals your in-game currency it is at your risk.
Ya that's why people were talking about setting up third party groups to move gold. A trusted guild for example.
Real question though, are you willing enough to trust someone over the internet enough to do this. At some point there will be a breakdown. That's how a lot of the major wars in EVE Online start.
If it's a guild that's making a small % on transaction fees? Ya I'm going to trust them. They are making gold off of it.
That's exactly how it works on EVE Online in some cases as well.
Yeah but this isn't like financial services in real life where you have heavy regulations and legal recourse. If a single person decided to cut and run with a bunch of gold you're shit out of luck.
Blizz has zero incentive to stop this, and it wouldn't be an easy thing to track or prove either. I don't see them trying to do anything, and they're right, it'll be really easy for people to screw other players over trading gold between two separate games.
Now if someone started managing an escrow account for classic, so that they could act as an impartial middle man and take a small cut? That would make the problem much worse, but also would probably be shut down pretty quick.
Anyone know rates? ( Just out of curiosity )
Not supported =/= against the tos
It literally means what it says, there is no in game mechanic to support the trading of currency between games, it’s not supported.
All that needs to be set up is a trusted middle man. I used many people that were trusted on Guild Wars 1 to move objects and gold between Pre-Searing and Post-Searing.
I asked if they can issue a statement SPECIFICALLY about whether gold trading between Classic and Retail is against the ToS, but the answer is still ambiguous... there is no mention of breaking the TOS or resulting suspensions, just no implication in resolving scams...
They said it’s allowed but it isn’t something they control so they won’t be able to help you if you have problems/got scammed.
"Not supported by us" doesn't sound very "allowed" to me. It's still ambiguous.
He told you exactly what he meant in the message, stop trying to read between the lines. Not supported means Blizzard doesn't support it or facilitate this feature, not that it isn't allowed. Much like playing on WINE on a linux box. You are allowed to, but Blizzard is not going to help you set it up or troubleshoot problems you run into.
Read this thread, people are still split.
“If you do it, you run the risk of getting scammed” doesn’t sound very “against the rules” to me.
dude are you for real? theyre saying theres no way for this to happen normally. meaning itd have to be done "illegally" and yes youll be banned. ppl like you are why support can take time to respond to legitimate issues.
It doesn't say this at all
Read this thread. People are still split on it, it's an ambiguous statement.
I wanted to get a real answer to finally settle it, whether it breaks the ToS or not, and was given yet another ambiguous response.
Literally making up mystery where there is non lol. They clearly say they don’t give a shit 😂