marcuspowersOP•

I found his analysis of how different (less tough) our current generation is than our grandparents' generation who had to deal with WW2/Vietnam/Cold War, etc very interesting.

I like his discussion about how technology/logistics/management can make a fighting force who is "less tough" defeat a fighting force that is "more tough", however I think he doesn't factor in the extent that modern technology can help make a military force deadly.

1
tach•

Well, both Hitler and the japanese regarded the US as an effete and decadent society, pampered by luxuries and wallowing in the moral decadence of jazz.

And we know how the guys that stormed Omaha and Iwo turned out.

2
marcuspowersOP•

When push comes to shove, right? If there is no option to surrender then the only way out is through everything and that has to build the "toughness" that Dan Carlin describes.

1
tach•

I believe so. The first combat experiences of the US were dissapointing - philipinnes, kasserine pass, mostly by overconfidence and inexperience. But they quickly got their act together.

Even then, there were glimmers of what was to come. For example, look at the defense of Wake

1
[deleted]•

The Spartans certainly felt that way.

1