While Some "Leftists" Are Supporting HK Protesters and undermining the PRC, Beijing is attacking HK big businesses and call for a fairer redistribution of land in HK

But before their “revolution” can go anywhere further, a drastic kind of reform – if not quite a “revolution” – with a clear goal seems to be in the pipeline, ironically initiated by a call from Beijing for fairer redistribution of land, one of the city’s most precious resources.

Firing the starting pistol was a lengthy commentary by the official People’s Daily, which, together with other state media outlets, slammed Hong Kong developers for focusing only on earning every “last penny”.

They also urged the Lam administration to be proactive and decisive in making the best use of existing legal tools such as the Lands Resumption Ordinance to confront “vested interests”, so as to speed up affordable-home building and give young people hope.

....

Soaring property prices have been widely seen as a major driving force behind the deep grievances and frustration among the city’s youth. That could explain why Beijing, through state media, has called for a fundamental “readjustment of short-term and long-term interests” warning that the city’s “finance-property bundled” model cannot work perpetually.

This article is from a bourgeois media so be mindful of the anti-communist bs.

As much as leftists love to argue how revisionist China is, they are still the one that understood the material conditions of China the best (what a fucking surprise).

Posted Sep 16, 2019, 6:20 AM UTC

9023
klqwerx•

those sneaky authoritarians at it again, brazenly addressing peoples need by urging mild reform through legal means

24
koopaShell3•

lol

1
[deleted]•

As much as i support china, i think there are real problems that needs immediate solutions because frankly they're impossible to defend. Labor laws do exist but theyre not implemented well enough, like there is no excuse for foxconn to exist in china when its known that its an incredibly shitty workplace that indulges in child labor. Also china has to fix their foreign affairs, their support for fascists like duterte needs to go.

6
ComradeLinOP•

I'm sure there is a lot to be criticized about China. But I'm not educated enough on the working conditions in China so I can't comment. Also criticism alone is not good we also have to come up with a solution, especially as an outsider.

​

Also china has to fix their foreign affairs, their support for fascists like duterte needs to go.

Unfortunately this stems from China's extreme neutrality that they don't care to have business with whoever in power either they are fascists , libs, communists, or whatever. heck for example China is trading with Israel but at the same time also trading with Palestine and Iran.

If for example China refuse to have ties with Duterte because he is actively doing some terrible shit in his own country that means China is indirectly meddling in Philippines' internal affairs which is not a "neutral thing" to do.

Whether this is bad or not is debatable. The good thing is this meant that the global south have more freedom to act, free from global superpowers. While the bad thing is like what you've said, sometimes China become supporting of a reactionary government.

14
[deleted]•

Also criticism alone is not good we also have to come up with a solution, especially as an outsider.

100% agree on that, i believe china is overwhelmingly positive. They are waging a war against poverty and homelessnes, deradicalizing religious extremist youth in xinjiang and tibet, are actively on the tail of the billionnaires etc. Its just there are few significant issues that need to be ironed out for me to say i 100% support their party line.

9
rando_97•

Tbh china always had terrible foreign policy and relationships. A lot of falls into China first or very odd judgements like the sino-soviet split, I mean a history of getting invaded and crippled did affected how they would take foreign approach which again lead to questionable choices. I won't deny china support for reactionary governments like Israel and Duterte as it is bad.

Like you I can't say for sure as I'm not educated in China's material conditions but that might be the key factors along with the current administration priorities.

4
[deleted]•

Im more worried about the massive inequality going on. Like China is the country with the second largest number of billionaires.

Ot: Action needs to match rhetoric

0
[deleted]•

I mean its natural that the net number of billionnaires is high in a country where like a billion people lives. And PRC is trying to get rid of them, it just takes time after decollectivization that started happening in the 70s. I believe in xi to bring it back though, he seems pretty decent and has backed his rhetoric with actions thus far. But yeah there still are some places where he could do better so i hope he pulls through in those fields too. Shitty workplaces and supporting fascists isn't cool.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
[deleted]•

Capitalist class was strengthened under deng and strong capitalists take time to take down. You can't just confiscate wealth and shoot the billionnaires anymore when they can just escape with all the money they hoarded. Also, realpolitik exists, just removing the entirety of capitalist class in a day would pretty much kill all trade china is making currently and would weaken the state. They're trying to do it slow enough that they don't lose power. And if you think im talking out of my ass, there are non communist articles complaining about how businessmen are treated as second class citizens in China and China regularly jails them when they step out of line.

6
[deleted]•

[removed]

-10
[deleted]•

Uyghur working people are held in concentration camps.

No they're not. The ones in the re education camps are religious extremists, because uyghurs have a massive problem with those. There are records of uyghurs joining ISIS or other fundamentalist organizations, they've bombed shit in the name of an "east turkestan", a country where sharia would be the law, and women would be the property of men. Deradicalization is great and i wish my country had the same as we've come to a point the imams here often talk about shit like "chess is haram", "wearing jeans is haram", or "mohammed wed with a 9 year old so quran doesn't have a specific age of consent" while they keep having scandals like raping 8 year old boys. These disgusting bronze age beliefs should be fought against,its not compatible with a proletarian country and progressive values. And people who come out of these camps often have improved mannerisms and are deradicalized fully while the uyghurs that live there aren't being treated poorly at all and can visit their relatives at weekends so its more like a boarding school of bringing the radicalized youth into modernity with job skills than detaining uyghurs because, honestly idk what the liberal reasoning is to why they're doing it. Maybe theyre bored or something i dunno.

but when two thirds of the proletariat of HK are on the march against an oppressive bureaucratic state, it is our job to intervene.

Who are this two third ? They're being largely supported by the US, they're waving imperialist flags, drawing art that glorifies US, mocking the workers in china so much that i actively believe that the riots are racist in nature. They're just doing shit that they know will piss off the central government and mainlanders because they hate the mainlanders.

11
RhombusAcheron•

but when two thirds of the proletariat of HK are on the march against an oppressive bureaucratic state, it is our job to intervene.

Good god did they really say that?

Watching "leftist" reddit fabricate, repeat, and internalize things that are literally just wrong is unreal. HK's proletariat have horrible living and working conditions, the majority of their labor movement is opposed to the protesting, and the class character of the protestors themselves is decidedly petit bourgeois with the most charitable reading. Certainly analogous to the US middle class at any rate.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
[deleted]•

US border concentration camps are concentration camps because they pick up people who aren't a threat to anyone, i don't think i have to explain why fundamental islamists can be a legitimate threat. Their ideology is backwards, they kill people because they don't adhere to their religion, they treat people like garbage(specifically women and nonbinary people).

And don't even hypothetically promote "re-education" camps in the west. It's fucked when China does it, do you really want the US, UK, France, etc going around picking up Muslims they deem " a risk"?

Who says i live in the west, i live in a muslim majority country and i'd love to see one here to deradicalize the people who are too far gone. Islamic extremism and ultranationalism are two things that are the biggest roadblocks here against progression.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
ComradeLinOP•

Source needed.

​

There are communists intervening in the HK protests, and those are the ones we should support, in my opinion. The ones crying for imperialist intervention and neo-colonialism are to be fought — but when two thirds of the proletariat of HK are on the march against an oppressive bureaucratic state, it is our job to intervene.

Where do you get the info that 2/3 of the proletariat are demonstrating or supporting it?

Also I'll wholeheartedly support them if they are against those that makes their life shit in the first place like for example those goddamn HK tycoons. Those protesters have yet to act in a meaningful way against the bourgeoisie of HK if any.

​

it is our job to intervene.

This is bad take... bad bad take. Are you really supporting a color revolution? At this point I don't even care if China is whatever communist, libs, you name it. Their downfall will only gave way to the western imperialists to super-exploit China. Fucking hell it's like the destruction of the USSR did not thought you anything.

​

There are general strikes, HK protesters wave hammer and sickle flags.

Lol no. Some HKers are even angry at them because they wave those imperialists flag. They don't even have the guts to just wave the HK city flag or just wave something new if they also don't like it.

6
Hai_Wai•

Fuck off libshit

3