An open letter to u/Topps_Admin

Firstly let me say that this post comes from a place of caring. I’ve been on the app since April 17th 2015, 4 years 5 months exactly. In that time I think I’ve taken one 2-3 week break. Other than that I’ve been on many times every single day. So clearly you’ve done something right.

But it is getting more and more concerning to see so few players in the app now, and it’s only getting worse. People have been predicting the demise of the app ever since it launched and it’s still going, but it really would be great to see more people coming back or signing up. So I’ve tried to be as constructive as possible with some of the issues I have with the app right now.

The biggest issues I see are: lack of cheap/affordable sets to bring in new users, no missions to keep people coming back, never-ending premium sets like International Posters and CTIs, the switch to almost every new set being “collect 10 cards in 24 hours” instead of a new card dropping each day, barely anything ever dropping into credit packs that’s going to have any trading value later, the unobtainable Vader meditation card, no discounts for buying in bulk

  • Lack of cheap/affordable sets to bring new users in and keep them engaged: with all mobile or “freemium” games you have to bring people in with something for nothing. You get them to play the game, do a few bits for free and then dangle the carrot of “buy A for 99c and it’ll help you get B”. For example, in Huddle there is the Archives marathon, a nice and easy 10k a week card for 22 weeks. We have nothing like that in SWCT and haven’t for a long time. The closest we’ve had recently was the 4 card First Order Badges set at 900 credits for a 1:20 shot. But even that all dropped at once (of course) and there’s no award for getting all 4, so no sense of achievement for anyone thinking of collecting them.

But if I was a new user getting my 25k a day credits now I wouldn’t have a clue what I was supposed to collect or do. Even the odds in a the Padawan store are a joke. As long as I hit the odds I could get a Clone Wars Youngling Blue once a day, or save up for 2 days to get a vibrant vessels grey, or 4 days for a Triptych. Where’s the fun in that? And I can’t trade because all I have are base cards or maybe one or two OEs from the free packs, which everyone gets. There’s nothing else to do on there either, no side missions, no other ways to help keep me engaged. At the beginning of the app it was fine, most people were in the same boat. But for those joining now I don’t see anything in the app that would keep me coming back day after day.

You’re quite fortunate that people found fun in hoarding. It’s a shame that we had to go looking for our own fun though, we shouldn’t have had to do it because there should have been enough to do in the app.

  • Premium sets like CTI and Posters have some incredible artwork and are great ideas. But give people a break! Posters have been never-ending for about 4 months now. Every week another one drops with no end in sight. And CTIs have been on a similar run since 2nd May this year, again it feels like they will never end. And the counts on all of them keep dropping as people get more and more bored by them. Its crazy, people bored by CTIs. But you need to let people enjoy what they’ve collected, and the sets they’ve put together. We don’t get that opportunity with CTIs and Posters though because as soon as the set is complete you start the next wave. Again there’s no sense of achievement so you’re left wondering what the point was. And what the point of continuing is. It's bizarre to think you've dropped marathons down to 12 weeks but sets like these don't have an end in sight.

  • This switch to drop 10 cards at once, collect all 10 in 24 hours for the super award, or in 7 days for the standard award. I actually have no issue with this type of drop….as long as it’s just one of the types you do. The issue is this switch to every set having the same mechanic like this. Does it need to be every single one right now? What is the problem with having this mechanic for some sets but daily drops for some of the others? I wouldn’t mind so much if some were reasonably easy, cheap for the newer players, but they’re always anything from 500k to over a million in credits to put together. Again impossible for the newer players.

If you collect the set in 24 hours then there’s little else to occupy you on the app for the next few days (depending on what you’re doing with marathons). If you don’t do it in 24 hours then you wonder if it’s worth doing at all as you’ve missed one of the awards already. That’s obvious because the counts on the 24 hour awards and the week long awards don’t actually differ that much.

  • lack of anything that rare or with great trade value in credit packs. I get it, there are/were various farmers gaming the system, automating their pulls, pulling things for credits and selling them on at hefty prices. But why can’t every now and then you have a set like the Fantasy Performers set in Huddle? Credit packs and a reasonably easy (1:3, 10k credit packs, 11 base cards to collect) set with a 1:15 or 1:25 shot at a sig/relic or something else fun. At least that way it’s a reasonably easy set to complete and you might get lucky with a relic or sig that you can trade on for something nice. You have bills to pay, I’m not expecting premium content to be available for credits all the time, but throw people a bone. Would it really hit your profits that much to do something like this just once in a while? Couldn’t it even bring more people in the app, keep current users in, thus giving you a bigger audience to try and sell to? Galaxy at War is one example you could have used it on, but it's still well expensive to put together, and you may get lucky with a lower count, different coloured variant. Really isn't that much of a bonus.

  • Very simple – the Vader meditation chamber (or as my wife said the other day, is that his bedroom?). This dropped a few years ago with a count of 100, at stupid odds and only in like a red base pack (IIRC). Card number 13,036. Only one was ever pulled so there are still 99 not sold but not available in any pack. Why not put the chance of pulling one in every pack that’s available but at long odds like 1:50,000 or something. Maybe take a long at how many packs are sold each day in the app and put the odds at enough that on average 1 would get pulled each day. Something like that. Just get those things out in the open!

  • lack of discount for buying bulk, in fact just bizarre pricing in general in the crystal store. Everyone knows, you go to the supermarket, store, whatever and if you buy in bulk the cost per unit is lower, and continues to be lower the bigger you buy. So why is the daily deal at 250 crystals for 99p a better crystals:pence/cents rate as the most expensive deal at 22,500 for £99.99? I know you can only buy it once a day, or should only be able to buy it once a day. But it doesn’t make the larger bundles look like good value at all. Isn’t the whole idea, from a business point of view, to get people to buy in bulk as often as possible? I thought that was the whole idea of having bulk buys at discounted rates?

And I’ll leave it there, I could go on about a great many more things I’m sure but I feel that’s more than enough to go on. As I said at the start this is meant to be constructive. It just gets frustrating thinking about how good the app could be. It can never be perfect for everyone, it’s impossible. But I feel like some of these things really could improve things, and anything that helps bring in new users, and keep them here, have got to be worth trying before we lose any more users.

Posted Sep 17, 2019, 1:07 PM UTC · edited

4849
dsigalDSIGAL•

u/topps_admin I agree with everything about this post but just want to underscore how strongly I agree that the abandonment of daily credit chase sets have been incredibly detrimental to the app

20
cappazushi•

I agree completely. It’s made the app extremely dull. It feels like there’s never anything to do, until a set randomly drops. Marathon timing going all over the place hasn’t helped either.

9
BBFETT1974BBFETT1974•

I for one have grown tired of trying to engage Topps on twitter in a positive matter with no response. I was one of the most positive people in the app (even in the dark times). I have finally gotten to the point I no longer care. They get .99 (free google play money mind you) from me every 6 months or so. I used to spend $10 to $20 a month. I now leave for months at a time! The app is impossible to enjoy. High credit packs and long odds. Sick of saving a million credits and feel like it still not enough to chase anything! All I got. Hope I ramble well... MTFBWY #Yaddled

15
dsigalDSIGAL•

Bigger picture yes, I agree. But there are some notable exceptions. In the last two weeks we've had a set that was 1:20 in 900 coin packs (so only 18k per card on odds) and a set that was 1:5 in 5k packs (so only 25k per card on odds). So they've been ok on this front. It's just less noticeable since the set just drops once rather than every day for a week or two.

1
BBFETT1974BBFETT1974•

What was the 1 in 5 packs one? Must have been limited packs cause I missed it? The 900 coin was garbage. And I am someone who loves open edition Still have them all. They traded so well... Sorry you have not changed my mind. Thanks for the feedback though.

1
dsigalDSIGAL•

Human/Cyborg Relations. The 1:5 packs were limited to 15k total but that lasted a couple hours and after that they were also in 5k packs at 1:15 odds

2
BBFETT1974BBFETT1974•

Had no idea. Thanks for that info. I can only check app a few times a day. I miss all limited credit packs. Have a great night.

6
mzrebekah•

Those are the ugliest cards. Han and C-3PO Looking Left, Han and C-3PO Looking Right, Han and C-3PO Looking Down.

2
riborsRIBORS•

Thank you for posting this, I know it took a lot of time and effort.

As someone who’s been here since 2015 and am still here, obviously I still enjoy playing so they have done something right from my perspective. I am not one who gets overly emotional in the feeds; you won’t see me complaining about Topps endlessly in every transmission like some. I love discussing digital cards here, in the app, and in chat groups. I try to stay level headed, but it can be hard to stay positive at times and we are in one of these times now. Right now there is a lot of frustration in the userbase and there’s a feeling that things aren’t getting better and in fact keep trending downwards.

A lot of great points have been raised and I don’t need to repeat them all, but will discuss a couple in depth.

The lack of transparency in regards to never ending Premium Sets is highly discouraging. This topic was discussed fairly recently here with particular regards to CTI and International. I even got a response here from u/Topps_Admin that he would bring this to the attention to the team. But nothing has been addressed, the International transmission still says “...there will be future waves of this release...”. The cc on Whites have dropped from 873 at its height to 373 last week with no end in sight. And as an insult to those chasing they already have proclaimed there will be no overall award.

Another point that needs to be addressed is the functionality of the app itself. It has been nearly three weeks since the feedback rating was broken. Nobody’s feedback score has increased during this time. Why has it taken so long to address this? There hasn’t even been an acknowledgement that there is an issue. Why not post a transmission stating you’re aware of the problem and are looking into it? Heck, there was a time when you use to get notifications when a trade was accepted. Then it simply stopped working one day and we all assumed it would be fixed, but it never was....that was years ago. I hope that is not how this turns out. And this is just one small thing, but is just an example of how problems arise and are never fixed.

It just feels like Topps is not taking any particular interest in how the users - especially the hardcore ones here - are interacting with the app and addressing any of our concerns. Very little interaction anymore on Twitter or Reddit and especially not in the app. Where are the Q&A sessions? Why hasn’t Topps reached out to the Hoard Illuminati gang to make an appearance on their show? You have a dedicated group that has been pumping out one or two podcasts a week for over a year talking about not only SWCT but all your apps; they’ve had guests from other digital companies but not Topps. The userbase keeps declining, show some respect to the customers who’ve been here for years on end before they drop out too. The most interactions I see from Topps these days are from Topps Mod who is playing whack a mole on users who are quitting and want to sell their cards.

Today’s new Retro-Active is the same exact image that was used in the last Retro-Active set. Someone in that transmission posted “Topps, could you try less harder? SMH”. That about sums up how many of us feel.

15
Acthedestroyer•

Thanks for the shout out. We always leave the door open to any of the app representatives or developers to join us on our show as a guest or as a feature. We’re ready whenever you are u/topps_admin. Just contact one of us here or email us at hoardcast at gmail dot com. Do it!

6
SnTrooper•

Agree completely with everything in this post. I've been around since April of 2015 and the lack of affordable sets for credits for months now has bored me to the point that I'm considering quitting. And when there is a cheaper set it has limited packs and is gone before I get there or it isn't compelling enough for me to want to collect it. Like the First Order Badges set, I collected that just because it was cheap and I was bored senseless not because I had any interest in it. And fifteen minutes later I was done with no sense of accomplishment, just of collecting scraps thrown out in the back ally.

Lately I've felt like SWCT is Wuher and I'm C-3PO, "We don't want your kind here. You credit users. You'll have to wait outside."

13
LEFEYETTEOPLEFEYETTE•

Haha excellent analogy!

5
cappazushi•

I’d also like to add that I have two college degrees and it usually takes me multiple readings of the transmission posts to actually understand set mechanics, recently. Can’t we just have something straightforward for a change?

12
mzrebekah•

Amen.

2
Angry-EwokTK92184•

For me, the most discouraging thing about the app is the very long odds on credit packs means I have nothing to trade for with other members of the community. I've opened something like two-dozen packs and I have nothing to show for the days and days of logging on faithfully for the credits. I brought several people onto the app at the same time as me and I'm the only one that checks it daily, after just two months.

9
diewompratdieIGN: DieWompRatDie•

This x1000. I've been here about as long as lefeyette and I'm just bored. The only thing I can possibly chase is the McQuarrie marathon.

TWD has daily chases, which, even though the show has waned in popularity and my interest, keeps me engaged in the app.

Please bring back easy daily chases.

8
jeffreybrownrq•

These are all great thoughts. I've been on since day one, but have decreased my play steadily over the past couple years, and went f2p at the beginning of this year. I still log in every day, but I'm only collecting the McQuarrie marathon at this point (especially when daily credits aren't enough to chase and I end up having to trade for the cards after going 0/40-50 packs every few weeks). Occasionally some card or set almost tempts me, but mostly I end up feeling meh. Too much base, too many variants. And because the original players keep leaving, it's become impossible to trade for and chase the old sets. Hopefully something changes...but not the interface, please.

8
wingend1977•

Yup, Day 1 user. I dropped the CTI this wave because after posting here and being told by u/topps_admin that he’d check into it we’re almost at Card #4 with no answer as to how many waves or if there’d be any overall award. I log in a couple times a day, usually post nothing and look at the 1-2 releases. It’s almost all boring, and/or over-priced without enough new sets to keep anyone’s interest. I dropped McQuarrie after wave 1 of this marathon...too expensive and too many re-used images. If there were an easy way to sell my cards without doing individual eBay listings I’d have done it already. I definitely have never seen so few people posting and 75% of the posts are spam or hoarders. Not a good look going into Episode 9.

8
GorillaTapedSlippersOMGSHUTUP•

I just want an app that's not dogsh*t and some credit packs that aren't garbage. Seriously any worthwhile set for credits has limited credit packs and drops randomly. "Hey this looks cool. Oh wait it was only available for 5 minutes two hours ago." And the app is still clunky AF. Why does clicking a card work half the time? Buttons have 'dead spots?' I have a flagship phone. I used to spend money regularly in app, now I view it as a chore to use.

7
tangentJBIGN: tangentJB•

A thousand times yes. I would add one more item - the price point. I don't have a problem with crystals and any casual look at my collection would suggest I am happy to spend on the app. My problem is that the prices generally are too high. It's the same point as your comment about "lack of cheap/affordable sets to bring in new users", but not just new users.

What does Topps think are the bands for different types of players? Who are the customers? The way I see it, there are three broad groups:

1/ Free players who might occasionally pay money for something nice

To remain engaged, these players should be able to collect one marathon plus one other set regularly but not constantly (say one set every 3 weeks) with an occasional chance for something bigger.

2/ Casual payers - the goal is to turn as many free players into casual players as possible

For Topps - this is where the money is. For players - this group is needed (as well as the free players working on a particular set) to have active trading.

Paying something like $5-$10 per week, these players need to be able to collect several sets (including marathons) and have something to do every day. Also have some choice about which sets to collect. Able to occasionally get something premium (maybe one set every 6 weeks, or a premium card once a week).

3/ Premium

Paying more than $30 per week. Topps doesn't want to lose them by making casual pay too attractive.

The only way to do this properly is to think about every release, where it fits in the above categorisation and price accordingly. Which group is it targeted to? Does the artwork justify the $1, $5 price? Has that customer group already been saturated? Is there enough choice so that paying players are able to get something they like with their money? The schedule of releases should be managing the mix of daily/weekly cheap/mid/premium sets without needing to know in advance what those sets are. Some sets can be bigger or smaller, but always work out what the cost is (in $) and see if it's worth it.

And final comment, if a set is premium, don't devalue it by releasing lots of waves or the same content with a different name and border etc.

7
Acthedestroyer•

Agree wholeheartedly with this assessment. Galactic Heritage is a set that sold like crazy with limited count (750 before melds) then they raised the counts (1000), then they messed up with TFA and created 3 additional variants, then proceeded to release multiple waves of every other movie/show including 5 waves of clone wars (100 inserts) with no regular Count Dooku insert!

They pummeled the set, buried it, unearthed it multiple times and left it to rot in the sun.

The finals counts on the last wave of resistance ended in the high 80cc range.

Don’t get me started on the Heritage signature and meld cards. I have every heritage insert and pack art but am still missing 18 signatures and 35 awards! That’s right I have nearly 500 heritage cards in my collection and am still missing 50+ premium cards.

3
mzrebekah•

I’m glad I decided early on not to chase those. The GH Set became huge. Wow. 500 cards and you’re still missing Awards. They must be very low count.

2
Acthedestroyer•

It’s actually over 600 cards. I went back and counted later on...

Some of the awards I’m missing are in the hundreds, some in the 20’s. I love and hate that set simultaneously.

2
mzrebekah•

That makes you a true fan (:

1
mzrebekah•

This comment is insightful. I gradually moved from Free Play to Daily Deals to Premium spender. It’s my Entertainment Dollars that I choose to spend in the app instead of in the cinema. $10 popcorn. Harrumph! Last year, I got a Luke & Yoda card I love: the tree is burning and Yoda is laughing. Then I got it with a new border and then a 3rd border. I don’t mind because I love the card. However, this year i feel like Topps did a 180. Boatloads of Exclusive cards filling out that section, all new images! But only 150-300cc. Noooooo! Don’t waste the new Qi’ra on a low count Exclusive. Let everybody have a chance at getting the card in a set. Anyhow, nice comment about having better quality artwork for sets.

  • Force Powers: Force Spirit.
  • Training on Ahch-to: Master Yoda Returns...
  • TLJ mega-set: Yoda and Luke’s Lesson.
1
LIMI-MERCER•

Agree with everything here, but I also think there some different things happening in the app which look like attempts to make some changes. The 3 set drop yesterday was interesting and I personally like the 30cc signature mechanics, though you can see that popularity has dropped because low cc's in general don't sell out. I went 2 months without chasing anything until the K2 sigs dropped the other day. Maybe that's because I'm occupied with Marvel which is simply newer and more fun with easier ways to feel rewarded. Topps is in the perfect position to see what's working on one app and learn from it for another app. The Marvel brand is popular right now and the app is new, but we've got a bunch of new Star Wars releases coming soon and Triple Force Friday on the same day/weekend of New York Comic Con. It'll be interesting to see what's released from Topps.

If I were Topps and I know I'm not and i know they don't care about what I think really... I would create a MegaBox that includes everything that's not sold out and make the odds of getting a gilded or low cc card pretty decent and wipe the floor of the past and start over. You could even limit each account to 1-2 mega boxes. I know that means all these alt accounts get access to these cards, but it doesn't look good having all this stuff available or not sold out. Sell them for 15$ each for 100 cards, 50% chance of gilded, 1% chance at a 2nd, 25% chance of an under 100cc and throw tons of other crap in there that doesn't do anyone any good sitting in packs no one is buying.

Lastly... and it's a big one. The design quality of Topps created cards has declined recently. In particular the Concept Maybellines. It's hard to imagine that you could mess up a concept card, but you definitely did. The design around a Concept card should be as minimal as possible. It's about the art, not the card design. These cards are 60% card design/border and honestly the font choice and curved treatment are laughably off brand for Topps and/or Star Wars. There's just a little bit too much FONT recently. Less is more... let the photos and art speak for themselves, or at the very least give the designed borders purpose and make them relevant to the set theme. That's the main reason I've dropped off lately. The cards have to look good in order to sell.

6
LEFEYETTEOPLEFEYETTE•

Good suggestions, to be honest I’d love them to do anything other than the awful combo packs. They at least threw some unsold cards into credit packs recently so that was good to see.

At the end of the day we don’t get to see the balance sheets. They may be making more money now than they were a few months ago. But if the user base keeps declining then it can’t be sustainable.

I’m not expecting things to change, but at least posting it here means it’s more likely u/Topps_Admin sees it rather than sending an email to the help desk. And people can add to this and put their own ideas forward as well. Again, something it’s be great to see Topps do more of but that we end up doing for them.

5
pavementalpavemental•

u/Limi-mercer , I’d love your perspective on how switching SWCT to the Marvel app could be handled and used to address OP’s points.

I hate the Marvel build and sadly it’s just a matter of time till it comes to SWCT. But you hint at some interesting points of how the app build could be more appealing to new users. And as a long term player who was very engaged in SWCT, I’d love to hear more from that perspective. Like you, I really like quality art best but I think the Marvel app is a terrible presentation of art, the thumbnails are all too small etc.

4
LIMI-MERCER•

I'll try my best... Basically if I were designing an app that showcased the multiple varieties of card designs like SWCT or Marvel I would go with a no-design design. Basically I'd use Apples 'Photos' app as my influence. Just make the design smart and simple. Think art gallery... white walls, simple navigation to guide you through. Don't need all of this BS. I completely agree that the Marvel app has a really small hard to use navigational system at times... some of that is because there's just too much functionality jammed in there. A lot of it could be fixed too by simply hiding and revealing more and shifting things around. The interface has way too many beveled edges and too much useless space. I'm not sure what inspired the design of the app. It's reminiscent of old CD-Rom games. The SWCT app currently isn't terrible looking but it lacks in functionality in ways the Marvel app doesn't. One of the great things about the Marvel app is you can click around more easily and if you click on something by mistake and it's taking time to load you can click back home easy and cancel your previous click/s. It might actually layer your clicks in the background some how but the experience is smoother. I also happen to really like that you don't need to add someone as a friend to trade with them. I stopped cross-trading with SWCT because it's just too much of a chore.

Ok. So new users... Marvel has done a lot of things right here. As much as we like having a tight collection, even if we just bought the cards we wanted... it's not that much fun. Trading is a key aspect to what makes it fun. Even if those trades are base for base and in some ways even if those trades suck and you just decline them. Getting trades is a huge part of the game. The credit missions from Marvel are a great way to get more trades, and also force you to trade. I know people take advantage of it and send crappy trades, but I've found hoarding to be better at 6-8AM EST when my 10 month is awake getting fed by my wife and I'm just sitting there. New users coming into SWCT in the state it's in currently has to be intimidating. There's no way to get a good card because there aren't really any good cards to get easily. It's still a gambling game. The low CC's are too risky. Tomorrow in Marvel you could spend ~20$ and get 6 gold comic covers. Then use some credits and probably get 1-2 more before they sell out. Depending on the character on that gold cover you could flip those easy for Thorsday's, FoE Motions etc which were purchased originally for way more and which have higher value. Why? Because those cards sell out in 5 minutes and lots of people miss out on them. There's nothing like that in SWCT. There are too many variants and ~20$ gets you junk... or a small small chance at something low CC that doesn't sell out. I'd love to see SWCT release a nice looking borderless 10 card Rey/Kylo set limited to 25cc each. Price would be 800 Crystals for 1 guaranteed and 10k credits for 1:15 chance. That would mix this whole thing up. Those cards would have value and would be attainable by anyone who happened to be on. Do it a few more times over the course of a month and the entire app changes. New users, old users anyone would start to have some assets to be proud of or trade for ones they could be proud of. This is essentially what happened when Lightsaber Warriors launched. Small card set, 100cc I think, sold out insanely fast. Marvel doesn't seem to care that sets are sold out in minutes... and they shouldn't. The chance of getting a card from those quick to sell out sets isn't bad and it doesn't cost a lot. I know this doesn't cover F2P... I'll have to think more about that but Marvel does make a lot more available to those who don't want to pay and it makes getting credit much easier.

I gotta talk about card design too, because as a designer this is the thing I notice the most recently. The designs are not very good and they are starting to look like one persons portfolio. I'm dying to know how many designers work on these cards. The official stuff (Posters, Premieres, Concept Art) has always been great. A lot of the older Topps card adaptations from print have been great too. Do they hire freelancers? If I were Topps I'd stop doing design in-house and I'd try to reach out to Mondo and see what i could do to get some artists there to let us license their work. I'm sure it's more complicated than that though. One thing that I've noticed recently that I've liked is that we're not just overwhelmed with 3, 4 or 5 releases a day. Gildeds have finally taken a backseat because they lost their luster and the proof is in cards that won't sell out. The Comic Cover Marathon is great though I haven't loved all of the covers so far. Quite honestly if I was a new player I'd be so intimidated by the amount of stuff in the store and the prices I'd lose interest fast. This is why I think Topps needs to bundle up all that garbage and sell it cheap. Give it away almost... but if there's no one in the app it rots... which it's doing anyway. They used to put sales on packs that didn't sell out after a few weeks (S3 expansion 1cc's for example).

At the end of the day I think you need better looking cards (think Essentials, more official SW stuff, good original art, partner with Lego maybe for figure cards like those 8-bits, a Jeffrey Brown set?), do anything even if you lose some money in the process. Test out the market by mimicking some of Marvels mechanics for releases and see how it goes. Smarter card sets, though some of these newer set ideas are really good. The cockpit view idea was a great one but execution... meh. A Concept card with Rey holding R2's severed head!!! I want that!!!... never mind, what did you do to ruin that for everyone? Don't do it again. Bringing back older card releases and adding sigs... I like it. 30cc cards that won't sell out though? How about adding the community into deciding what cards are their favorites to add to the sigs? I'm anticipating a BB-8 5 card sig set, but nervous about the selection of cards. Also, every month maybe include releases from all SW movies, shows etc, some consistent variety would be nice. Just care about your app as much as we do.

6
MiltonFett•

I was glad to see you mention Lightsaber Warriors. I've worked on a few easy sets in the time since, but that was the last time I really leaned in on something. Loaded up on crystals, paused dinner prep at 6 o'clock, found a quiet spot, and opened packs with actual excitement. That was over a year and a half ago.

As for the new-player experience... I started on 8/27/15 (1 day AiO9), and 2 months later I had completed Red Yavin, Red Moments Edge, White Visages, and Yellow Collegiate. All with free credits, lots of trading, and some lucky pulls at the tail end of the S1 marathons. That sort of early success should always be there waiting for new folks, and it really just entailed spaced-out drops, cheap-ish variants, and the possibility of pulling a rarer card.

4
pavementalpavemental•

Thank you for taking the time. Lots of great stuff in there.

I’ll have to track down that Rey with R2’s head card. I didn’t even bother getting the General Leia Concept because the Maybelline design is so terrible.

I hate the Marvel build but when SWCT moves over, if it follows some of the dynamics and mechanics that could grow the community, which would make it worth it in the long run.

2
TimToMakeTheDonuts•

seems like a tl:dr would be along the lines of:

"can't retain and engage new users. is frustrating old users. we all miss daily drops. something needs to change."

that being said, i've been around since spring of 2015 but only super engaged since about late '16. anyway, totally agree with some of op's points, kinda agree with one, and totally disagree with one. i'll quickly mention the latter two.

kinda agree - discounts for buying in bulk. while this is nice in theory, this kinda negates giving the noob a decent shot at things, only it's on the crystal scale and not the credit scale. if it is just one more way to make big spenders get more benefits, it'll only piss of the people who can only afford $30 per month more. obviously, i can see the perks to both sides, that's why i kind of agree with this. who is really going to benefit long term and who is gonna feel even more alienated, though? careful what you wish for.

totally disagree - vader meditation chamber? really? this is a point large enough to sit alongside the others in the original post? seems like something very trite to add to a bunch of incredibly valid and overarching points. who cares that much about 1 card out of almost 100k cards at this point? just treat it like any other 1cc and go about your day. i'm just saying that it seems like a weird ax to grind.

everything else is really well stated and said. well done.

5
LEFEYETTEOPLEFEYETTE•

Lol I can see how it’d seem weird to have a dig about the meditation chamber card. I’ll add a bit of context.

I’m not a fan of how they deal with unsold cards anyway, combo packs seem like such awful value for money, but at least almost all the unsold cards are in there. The meditation chamber card hasn’t been available to pull for at least 2 years, probably closer to 3 (https://www.reddit.com/r/starwarstrader/comments/8sjxfz/an_oral_history_of_swct_the_meditation_chamber/)

I agree the other points are more important, but still wanted to bring the meditation chamber up. It’s such an easy one to resolve as well. And the fact they haven’t mentioned it in so long I can only think it’s been forgotten about as people have come and gone within the Topps team.

4
TimToMakeTheDonuts•

yeah, i'm super familiar with the card and it's attached lore, just seemed an odd.

had you mentioned the distribution of unsold cards it'd have made more sense to me. seemed like such a specific point to be upset about.

also, i agree. they should deal with remaining cards differently. i've personally always liked the idea of just selling out the set once the pack isn't on sale anymore. let the number it sells out at be it's final cc. rather than saying a card would have a 500cc total, say it would have a 500cc ceiling. might add a little value to sets that weren't that popular from the jump, ya know?

6
dsigalDSIGAL•

I think you're missing the point. It's not about the Vader Meditation Chamber card. The Vader Meditation Chamber could be one of a billion of unsold cards. He just used that specific one as an example to illustrate a larger point, that's all.

2
mzrebekah•

A cc ceiling is a brilliant idea and a perfect solution. I do buy Combo Packs and have gotten some excellent inserts that way, but the most recent pack was only inserts from a set i had already collected, all 3 tiers of the same set. I didn’t realize my sets weren’t SoldOut and will go down in value as more leftovers are placed into Combo Packs. I spent a lot of real money on that set. I want it to be SoldOut now.

1
Angry-EwokTK92184•

Just one more thing: the most fun that my wife and I and a few friends, as a new users, have had playing this app is when random accounts who are quitting dump a bunch of awesome, old cards on our accounts in 9:1 trades for a random white because they can't be bothered to sell them. It is a really bad sign when it makes more sense for me to buy cards from another user directly than to buy crystals from TOPPS.

5
BbaMcFly•

I have to second most of the sentiments expressed here. The app is barely worth logging into anymore. Nothing fun to chase and the trading is dead. Topps sends out mixed messages by requesting feedback at SDCC and doing the survey, but are totally non responsive to any of their social media channels. Which is totally inexcusable as a company.. I too have stopped spending and don’t see that changing unless there are huge improvements. Not sure the future holds much hope unfortunately.

4
tangentJBIGN: tangentJB•

The unresponsive social media is particularly annoying when there's a problem. If a pack is not available, someone usually tweets to Topps within a couple of minutes. Why does it take 10 hours for Topps to find out?

3
alex_xxvALEXTHE25•

I support this 100%. Took a break from the Topps apps four weeks ago and trying to get back but honestly I dont see enough motivation to do it. Same collect-all-in-a-day stuff, boring mechanics, expensive as hell, low quality sets, etc. I dont think I will come back after all. I only see more and more guys spending like crazy and guess this is how Topps measures the success of the app.

4
KeithyT1999KEITHYT1999•

Good post Lee. I'm not sure I have any strong feelings either way, although the lower levels of activity both on the app and places like this sub-reddit are very noticeable as you state (and that's the part I did enjoy just as much as the app)

I bought a few credit packs with real money in mid 2015 to early 2016 but made a decision then to not spend again. The transition to diamonds didn't sway me either, BUT I would still say I'm in category 1 that tangentJB mentions in his post. I'm lucky enough to have disposable income for leisure and the odd £9.99 here and there every month or so would not leave me with buyers remorse. So the spending door is always open in my mind...

I still open the app more than once a day, collect my free credits, have a look at any sets and packs available but more often than not don't even buy any with my free credits due to cost of the pack, or the odds, but mainly just apathy.

I don't hate the app, it doesn't trouble me as it's just another in a group of mild diversions I can click on when a bit bored. But it's certainly not engaging me as much as it did.

4
LEFEYETTEOPLEFEYETTE•

True Keith, we're old VHan buddies so have been around a while and have always enjoyed discussing it :)

The app's been going for 4.5 years, it's so tough to keep people engaged for that whole time. There's going to be peaks and troughs. But as you say, whatever they are doing right now isn't enough to keep people engaged, or to entice older users back in so it really does feel like a new direction, or a few new ideas could really help.

6
Lilly214LILLY214•

Completely agree that there's nothing cheap available with credits. For example with the Rise of the First Order set (nice cards btw). I pulled just 1 insert with 300,000 credits (5k 1:10 odds) and 300,000 credits is 2 weeks of saving btw . How can you complete a set with just credits? Ridiculous...

4
sheldipez•

I've started x trading quite a bit lately and it's really surprising just how many non-base type of cards you call pull across TWD, Slam and Marvel without spending a penny vs SWCT. I'm starting to think that the fact that most of my decent cards (just traded a Seasons card with a nice TWD x trader) have been x trades with people lucky enough to pull something inside of SWCT then rather than with people grinding it out in SWCT itself says something, not to mention the rate I've been filling old base gaps from people quitting has been a bit alarming considering its only lately I've been getting into SWCT. My son does free to play and he says much the same points as LEFEYETTE points out (only rather less eloquently as he's only 10) struggles to find much to keep his interest other than hoarding.

3
cappazushi•

Arguably we are now at a full year of CTI. There was a short break, but other than that Series 6 / 2019 CTI has been going since Fall 2018.

2
LEFEYETTEOPLEFEYETTE•

Yep. I looked through ToppsSWCT tweets and it’s been every week since May. I think we had a month or two break around March, April but it was a few months of drops every week before then as you’ve said.

2