An open letter to u/Topps_Admin
Firstly let me say that this post comes from a place of caring. I’ve been on the app since April 17th 2015, 4 years 5 months exactly. In that time I think I’ve taken one 2-3 week break. Other than that I’ve been on many times every single day. So clearly you’ve done something right.
But it is getting more and more concerning to see so few players in the app now, and it’s only getting worse. People have been predicting the demise of the app ever since it launched and it’s still going, but it really would be great to see more people coming back or signing up. So I’ve tried to be as constructive as possible with some of the issues I have with the app right now.
The biggest issues I see are: lack of cheap/affordable sets to bring in new users, no missions to keep people coming back, never-ending premium sets like International Posters and CTIs, the switch to almost every new set being “collect 10 cards in 24 hours” instead of a new card dropping each day, barely anything ever dropping into credit packs that’s going to have any trading value later, the unobtainable Vader meditation card, no discounts for buying in bulk
- Lack of cheap/affordable sets to bring new users in and keep them engaged: with all mobile or “freemium” games you have to bring people in with something for nothing. You get them to play the game, do a few bits for free and then dangle the carrot of “buy A for 99c and it’ll help you get B”. For example, in Huddle there is the Archives marathon, a nice and easy 10k a week card for 22 weeks. We have nothing like that in SWCT and haven’t for a long time. The closest we’ve had recently was the 4 card First Order Badges set at 900 credits for a 1:20 shot. But even that all dropped at once (of course) and there’s no award for getting all 4, so no sense of achievement for anyone thinking of collecting them.
But if I was a new user getting my 25k a day credits now I wouldn’t have a clue what I was supposed to collect or do. Even the odds in a the Padawan store are a joke. As long as I hit the odds I could get a Clone Wars Youngling Blue once a day, or save up for 2 days to get a vibrant vessels grey, or 4 days for a Triptych. Where’s the fun in that? And I can’t trade because all I have are base cards or maybe one or two OEs from the free packs, which everyone gets. There’s nothing else to do on there either, no side missions, no other ways to help keep me engaged. At the beginning of the app it was fine, most people were in the same boat. But for those joining now I don’t see anything in the app that would keep me coming back day after day.
You’re quite fortunate that people found fun in hoarding. It’s a shame that we had to go looking for our own fun though, we shouldn’t have had to do it because there should have been enough to do in the app.
-
Premium sets like CTI and Posters have some incredible artwork and are great ideas. But give people a break! Posters have been never-ending for about 4 months now. Every week another one drops with no end in sight. And CTIs have been on a similar run since 2nd May this year, again it feels like they will never end. And the counts on all of them keep dropping as people get more and more bored by them. Its crazy, people bored by CTIs. But you need to let people enjoy what they’ve collected, and the sets they’ve put together. We don’t get that opportunity with CTIs and Posters though because as soon as the set is complete you start the next wave. Again there’s no sense of achievement so you’re left wondering what the point was. And what the point of continuing is. It's bizarre to think you've dropped marathons down to 12 weeks but sets like these don't have an end in sight.
-
This switch to drop 10 cards at once, collect all 10 in 24 hours for the super award, or in 7 days for the standard award. I actually have no issue with this type of drop….as long as it’s just one of the types you do. The issue is this switch to every set having the same mechanic like this. Does it need to be every single one right now? What is the problem with having this mechanic for some sets but daily drops for some of the others? I wouldn’t mind so much if some were reasonably easy, cheap for the newer players, but they’re always anything from 500k to over a million in credits to put together. Again impossible for the newer players.
If you collect the set in 24 hours then there’s little else to occupy you on the app for the next few days (depending on what you’re doing with marathons). If you don’t do it in 24 hours then you wonder if it’s worth doing at all as you’ve missed one of the awards already. That’s obvious because the counts on the 24 hour awards and the week long awards don’t actually differ that much.
-
lack of anything that rare or with great trade value in credit packs. I get it, there are/were various farmers gaming the system, automating their pulls, pulling things for credits and selling them on at hefty prices. But why can’t every now and then you have a set like the Fantasy Performers set in Huddle? Credit packs and a reasonably easy (1:3, 10k credit packs, 11 base cards to collect) set with a 1:15 or 1:25 shot at a sig/relic or something else fun. At least that way it’s a reasonably easy set to complete and you might get lucky with a relic or sig that you can trade on for something nice. You have bills to pay, I’m not expecting premium content to be available for credits all the time, but throw people a bone. Would it really hit your profits that much to do something like this just once in a while? Couldn’t it even bring more people in the app, keep current users in, thus giving you a bigger audience to try and sell to? Galaxy at War is one example you could have used it on, but it's still well expensive to put together, and you may get lucky with a lower count, different coloured variant. Really isn't that much of a bonus.
-
Very simple – the Vader meditation chamber (or as my wife said the other day, is that his bedroom?). This dropped a few years ago with a count of 100, at stupid odds and only in like a red base pack (IIRC). Card number 13,036. Only one was ever pulled so there are still 99 not sold but not available in any pack. Why not put the chance of pulling one in every pack that’s available but at long odds like 1:50,000 or something. Maybe take a long at how many packs are sold each day in the app and put the odds at enough that on average 1 would get pulled each day. Something like that. Just get those things out in the open!
-
lack of discount for buying bulk, in fact just bizarre pricing in general in the crystal store. Everyone knows, you go to the supermarket, store, whatever and if you buy in bulk the cost per unit is lower, and continues to be lower the bigger you buy. So why is the daily deal at 250 crystals for 99p a better crystals:pence/cents rate as the most expensive deal at 22,500 for £99.99? I know you can only buy it once a day, or should only be able to buy it once a day. But it doesn’t make the larger bundles look like good value at all. Isn’t the whole idea, from a business point of view, to get people to buy in bulk as often as possible? I thought that was the whole idea of having bulk buys at discounted rates?
And I’ll leave it there, I could go on about a great many more things I’m sure but I feel that’s more than enough to go on. As I said at the start this is meant to be constructive. It just gets frustrating thinking about how good the app could be. It can never be perfect for everyone, it’s impossible. But I feel like some of these things really could improve things, and anything that helps bring in new users, and keep them here, have got to be worth trying before we lose any more users.
Posted Sep 17, 2019, 1:07 PM UTC · edited
u/topps_admin I agree with everything about this post but just want to underscore how strongly I agree that the abandonment of daily credit chase sets have been incredibly detrimental to the app
I agree completely. It’s made the app extremely dull. It feels like there’s never anything to do, until a set randomly drops. Marathon timing going all over the place hasn’t helped either.