A follow-up to the open letter - ideas...

OK so I posted my list of issues yesterday for u/Topps_Admin to think about. One of the things I didn’t really do was look at ways they could improve things. So I’ve worked on a list of ideas to try and bring a bit more fun back into the app.

  • There needs to ALWAYS be some sort of set that people “should” be able to complete with their daily credits. Whether you make that a 25k per card set or a 5k packs, 1:5 chance card is up to you. But there has to be something going on everyday for new users to keep them engaged. And not this drop 4 or 5 at once set, it needs to be a new one each day to keep them coming back to collect the next one. Older users will complain, but we do that with everything anyway. Might as well do this and at least the new users have this to chase.

  • Prize wheel. This would help answer the point above. I can’t believe the wheel has been on the other apps for as long as it has yet hasn’t made it to SWCT (or Skate) yet. Surely it’s so easy to introduce and again it brings the new users back time and time again to spin and see what they get. Not expecting anything amazing on there but still nice for new users to get the OEs, or even do some chase sets using it. I think Slam do something similar with theirs.

  • You’ve got to make one of the marathons more affordable. 50k-75k on average. Last wave we had two available for 100k each week. This wave the cheapest is Resistance for 125k, next is McQuarrie or Alliances which is twice that at 250k.

  • Just to do the breakdown, during the last wave the costs each week were: Dual Sigs: 500k or 1000 crystals, Space Opera: Bronze 100k or 500 crystals, Gold 5000 crystals, McQuarrie: 250k or 500 crystals, TC: 100k or 500 crystals, Scum & Villainy: 100k or 500 crystals, Purple 5000 crystals.

  • This wave: Comics: 750k or 1500 crystals, Alliances: White, 300k or 500 crystals, Red: 1.5m or 2500 crystals, McQuarrie: 250k or 500 crystals, Retro-Active: 250k or 500 Crystals, Green 5000 crystals, Resistance: 125k or 250 crystals, Green: 1250 crystals.

  • So to complete the lower tier set each week last wave cost 1.05m credits or 3,000 crystals. To complete the lower tier set each week this wave costs 1.675m credits or 3250 crystals. That is a huge increase in credits. It isn’t much different for crystals and I get it, the idea is to get people to spend more real money. But you’ve got a declining userbase. You’ve got to at least give people one or two that are reasonably cheap to get them into marathons and wanting to collect. Like I said in the letter in the previous post, the idea with freemium games is to give new users a taste of things for free. That’s virtually impossible for any of the marathons this wave on the weekly credits they get unless they get extremely lucky. Or they love Resistance, which was not a high profile Star Wars show.

  • Regarding above. Yes the counter argument from you would be, should everyone be able to collect everything for free? Shouldn’t the idea be they pick and choose what they want based on what they can afford? And if they want more they’ll have to pay in crystals. I understand that argument 100%, but you aren’t actually giving people much choice right now with the options above. Certainly not the new users that you should be attracting.

  • Unsold cards…I don’t understand why anyone would buy a combo pack. They are so full of base variants no-one wanted previously so aren’t going to want now. I would love, love, love you to just chuck them all into credit packs, maybe 75k packs of 25 cards, 3 inserts/variants guaranteed, 1:3 of an additional 2., 1:20-1:30 chance at a proper rare card (perhaps gilded but not necessarily to that level). And obviously I get it, need to try to make some money so a crystal version as well, 500 crystals for the equivalent pack, 1000 crystals for double the inserts and 1:8 chance at the proper rare cards.

  • Some sort of mission system. Back at the start of the app we had the “collect these three yellow base cards for this Orange base card”. Or for Reflections you had to pull the right base card to access the pack that contained the card. And as you pulled a higher tier of that base card you got access to a pack at better odds. The S1/2 pink bubblegum border cards were meld a whole bunch of golds quickly to get one of the 10 counts. Stuff like that was good fun, stressful but fun and kept you engaged in the app. Looking at what you’ve done recently that’s been good: the Mos Eisley race, the asteroid field set, I mean it took forever but it was interesting.

  • Linked to above, the ships melds felt like missions, that was pretty enjoyable, why not bring them back every so often? Maybe build bases on worlds as well as just ships, Echo Base, the Endor bunker, the Kamino cloning facilities, it’d be cool trying to build the Mos Eisley space cantina.

  • Give people the chance to meld their lower tier inserts for a higher tier within a set. For example with Alliances now it’s 500 crystals for the white, 1:5 for the red. We all know you could end up opening 15-20 packs before you actually hit a red. That is such a drain on anyone’s enjoyment. So why not give people the chance to meld whites for the red? Obviously not at 1:5, but why not 1:7 or 1:8? These people are the ones keeping the app going. The last thing you want is them asking why they should bother. At least with this they know there’s an end point if they do have some bad luck. It’s bad enough going 3 or 4 times over the odds with credit packs, doing it with crystals is such a dreadful experience.

  • As above but also with credit sets/cards. Back in the day the first set of space paintings were meld 10 orange to get the equivalent Gold border version. It was brutal but felt so rewarding. Honestly, I think people would really get into it.

  • If you’re going to limit the amount of credit packs available, perhaps have two windows for them. I appreciate that the US is your biggest market but you are a global app. It’d be nice if people on the other side of the world had a shot at some of these. By never giving them a chance at credit packs you’re treating them like second-class users within the app and creates more reason for people to complain.

  • Following on from the point above, are the limited pack drops creating scarcity and excitement around a card/drop or is it creating frustration and anger? I don’t see your balance sheet, maybe it’s creating more sales for those cards, but is it leading to a decline in users because it annoys people? If so then is it sustainable to keep doing this?

  • How about bringing back the old system of 1:40 chance at card X, 1:20 if you buy any crystal bundle? Perhaps not for everything but isn’t it worth a try again sometimes? You’d still get sales of crystals and people can still use credits if they want.

  • What about the Essentials model for sets occasionally for some premium sets like that? That was something like buy a £3.99 bundle and then get access to the pack at 1:20 odds. Those cards were great and they just flew out.

  • Take a break between waves for any set. Honestly, if you want to do endless waves of CTIs because they make money then OK. But at least have a couple of weeks break between the waves. Or dovetail the sets. Have CTI going on, say a 7 card wave. Then when it’s over start a different set the next week for 6-7 weeks. When that’s done go back to CTI. Something like that.

  • Fix the broken rating system (credit to u/ribors). Again that would really irritate me if I was a new user to see my rating at 0 stars the whole time. Or imagine being a new user, you’ve sent 5 trade offers that were terrible because you didn’t know what you were doing, and had a rating of 2 stars. The rating system then breaks and you are now stuck with 2 stars with no idea how to make it better. Every trade you send could be amazing now but you wouldn’t know because your rating doesn’t change. It must be incredibly disheartening. And you guys haven’t even acknowledged it at all in the app. At least explain it to people if it’s going to take a while to fix.

So many ideas, I should be charging you guys consultancy fees! 😊 some of them probably unworkable but hopefully some that are worth considering. And hopefully more people will add to the thread below with other ideas to think about.

As I said in the last thread, I care about the app, I enjoy the app. But it’s not much use if there’s only me and 12 other people in there. It's Star Wars Card Trader. As the user base declines so do the opportunities to trade. If I wanted to just collect things and have no interaction I’d go and log back in on Quidd. And we all know how awful and no fun that app is now.

But more fun = more users = more trading and interaction = more potential customers = more sales…? If we're enjoying the app more we're more likely to support it and spend, that's how my mind works anyway.

There are lots of people that would love to help keep SWCT going and help you make it more successful, with more users. But we can’t do it on our own. We need some support from Topps to make it better, more enjoyable and more enticing for new users.

Thanks

Posted Sep 18, 2019, 8:39 AM UTC · edited

2037
Loading comments…