Looking for a different approach to balancing Terran harass
Most players acknowledge there is a definite issue with the strength of Reapers early game and a broader issue of the strength and availability of Terrans harass units. We have all read the patch notes but for those that didn't Blizzard attempt to fix this was increasing the build time of Reapers from 40 to 45 and Bunkers from 30 to 35. Now I am glad it's a production time nerf over a stat based nerf as I believe Reapers are only an issue because coming too early hurts the opponents economy however too late and the unit is useless.
I suggest a different possible solution which affects all Terran units and makes Terran structures a little more complex. It would be to split the current Tech Lab add-on into two structures, one remaining as the Tech-Lab required for creating the higher tier units from the production building and a new Research-Lab required for the unit upgrades.
Research Lab
Production Cost: 100 Minerals, 75 Gas
Production Time: 50
Add-on to Barracks, Factory or Starport
This would simply mean no hindrance to the creation of Reapers/Hellions/Banshees thus the units remain powerful as harass only units should as they typically fall easily in later fights but you must invest more TIME if you wish to upgrade them. Time because you wouldn't be able to create a Reaper at the same time as Researching their upgrade.
Reaper Rushes would very rarely have Nitro Packs that make them much more deadly, Hellions can get Infernal Pre-Igniter while being created but you'd need to swap the Factory just like you do now to be able to double produce them with a reactor. Moreover Banshees' Cloak would need to be prioritized more as you'd be unable to research and create, very important considering the time cloak research takes.
The idea affects all units as well specifically those that need a tech lab for creation as it would delay Siege Tech on Tanks, Concussive shells for Marauders, the list goes on. On top of which the player will have to be more skillful working out how many research labs they want if they need more production buildings as a result and the APM to keep swapping buildings in and out as typically Terran players get away with ignoring their base while Zerg players have to keep spawning creep/larva and other such APM intensive tasks.
TLDR To fix Reapers and a general imbalance of Terran split the Tech-Lab structure into two different add-ons one for unit creation and one for upgrade research as it would delay upgrades to powerful units but not cripple them.
Feel free to post thoughts and other novel ideas more than just stat/production time changes to fix the general imba consensus.
Posted Aug 28, 2010, 7:30 AM UTC · edited