Wasting my time/money with a masters after years in industry?

My background: I’m currently working in industry with 4 years of experience doing fairly standard software engineering/web-dev stuff at a couple of different startups. I’ve progressed through the ranks pretty quickly and have a pretty inflated title partially due to the nature of the startup industry. My undergrad is in CS from a top-10 liberal arts school that isn’t particularly well-known for CS, but I found the courses pretty rigorous even if cutting-edge classes weren’t offered. While I still like working with computers and software I’m getting a little burned out by the software engineering world. My goal with a masters was to try and break into more work with AI/ML and CV or try and land a job at a research-oriented institution where jobs seem to be gated by MS requirements. I also happen to like school and thought going back and taking more courses that I couldn’t get to during undergrad would be fun and interesting.

I was accepted and going to be starting the University of Chicago’s MPCS program part-time while I continue my job, but now I feel like I was misguided by the advice I got when I was applying. I knew going in that this was a professional-oriented masters but it seems like this program is target more towards people who want to change careers rather than people like me, so I feel like I may be really overqualified and wasting my time and money. Does anyone have experience with this program in particular or masters programs in general that could offer me some advice? Thanks all!

Posted Sep 26, 2019, 2:26 PM UTC

1515
mahtatsPython Developer•

The best advice I was given during college: "Don't get a masters in what you already do"

So I swapped it up and now I'm finishing up my MSSE so I have a breadth of experience for my company to use.

31
pat_trick•

On the flipside, I am wrapping up a MS in in CS, and it has expanded my knowledge in areas that I didn't get exposed to previously.

3
mahtatsPython Developer•

An MS in most topics will of course expand your knowledge in a limited subset. I’m only stating that by exposing ones self to another topic, their toolset is vastly expanded rather than only enhancing a specific tool.

Consider the tool analogy to be your BSCS is your socket wrench, and your MSCS is an extended torque wrench. Now you know exactly how much ft-lb you’re applying, but the problem set didn’t change as it’s still a socket. Obtaining an MS outside your tool set expands your belt to say a screwdriver set, or a nail gun, or a table saw, etc.

Now not only can I effectively design a system using solidified SE principles and practices, but I can also implement said system; or I can even take on a managerial/architecture role for a system of systems and help developers since my core foundation is CS. In my eyes that has more value then an MSCS where I may become better with spatial structures or optimized doubly-linked-lists.

2
a_brainOP•

What was your background before entering the MS?

1
pat_trick•

BS in CS, BA in Theatre. I double majored in underground. Also had 10 years in industry before returning to school.

1
a_brainOP•

Interesting... your background is similar to mine albeit with much more industry experience than I have. Did you do a more professional-oriented MS or was it very research-based?

1
seasweTech Lead•

Real, intense, focused research is going to require a PhD. Full stop. Applied R&D (implementation) is going to require...experience, really. MS programs simply don't offer the depth or the breadth to really equip you to get involved in the sort of thing you're looking at out of the gate, and are absolutely worth less than full time work experience in the same domain...and, worse, if you do it full time, a lot of companies are going to "reset" your level on the basis of the fact that you're a "new grad" or otherwise rusty. It'll set you back years (and at a tremendous financial cost: opportunity and otherwise) for virtually no benefit (side note: the one and only particularly good reason to get an MSCS is to improve your standing in the visa lottery if required--otherwise, nah).

Of course, that leads to your chicken-and-egg problem: how do you get that experience to begin with? The short answer is to join a large, established company that actively funds R&D-like work in the space that interests you, and then work next to or for one of their R&D teams in an implementation capacity (these groups will pretty frequently take in "generally smart" people on the software/implementation side without any prior background or expertise; they need people to do the relevant "grunt work"). This will expose you to the craft and people and, gradually, you'll build a network and expertise to be credible in the space, which then leads to future opportunities. You won't find this in the startup world for obvious reasons (the downside is that you'll have to work for large companies, which brings a different set of challenges and frustrations).

You may be surprised at how quickly those gates (which, by the way, will often say "MS or relevant experience") fall away when you have a body of work to show and/or know somebody who knows somebody (or even even know them directly). If you're just throwing resumes into a portal, you're probably up against it even if you're the world's foremost expert in that domain, and you're definitely screwed if you aren't.

I should add that "ML" and "CV" and the like are largely tired buzzwords at this point. Most of the software work involving either is just plugging shit into libraries/APIs and iterating; the real heavy lifting is mostly done by data scientists/mathematicians and research scientists.

Otherwise, I agree with the others: if you were to get a Masters, get it in something else (tangentially related, or not at all), ideally on the business side of the house.

14
a_brainOP•

Thanks for the thoughtful response. I’ve recently felt disenchanted with traditional software development and a little bit pigeonholed since I’m good at my job. But my dream job would be to work on a big science project since I also have a background in physics or in an R&D role that exists mostly outside of a traditional business context. I don’t know anyone with a masters personally but based the responses in this thread it seems like a masters isn’t going to get me there any faster (or even at all) since most of the programs target towards people looking to get into software engineering than looking to get out like I am. I’m not super interested in a PhD... going back to being paid almost nothing for long hours for questionable career advancement is not something that I want to take on since by the point I finished I could have almost a decade of work experience.

One thing to note is I’m less concerned about the financial impact than I am about the opportunity cost. I have enough money saved up to do it part time without incurring debt.

3
seasweTech Lead•

Yeah, I definitely wouldn't recommend a PhD at this point (or possibly ever). My own brother has one (among other people I know) and while he generally enjoyed it and it was probably the right thing for him at the time, it also (as best I can tell) did next to nothing for his career: he started at the same entry level as anybody else, never did industry R&D (while I did!), and isn't really doing anything related to his research area at all now--though what he is doing is deeply technical and utilizes some of the unique specific skills he picked up along the way. As with the MS case above, he could've gotten there without the PhD, and probably in less time (none of his immediate coworkers have one, as far as I know).

What most of us envision as research or cutting edge software development isn't at all what PhDs and pure researchers actually do in many cases. We want to hack on gadgets and experiment; they're mostly there to brainstorm and publish papers.

2
brysonwf•

Get a masters in business admin, finance, accounting, managment, anything that would bolster your CS degree and make you unique. A masters degree in CS is only worth a few years on site doing real life CS.

3
throwawat434•

what if you dont want to go into management or anything business related and want to stay as an individual contributor on the technical side of things?

2
brysonwf•

no reason to get a masters then...

4

Yeah I agree don’t get the masters

1
rgr555•

ya

1
ExitTheDonut•

Don't be shy, share with us the details of the experience that got you to come to that conclusion. Be as detailed as you can.

1
DifferentRoads•

Map out your options using something like Smarter Graduate (it’s a mobile app). Look at the costs of going to college, how much it increases your income, your lifetime income potential, student loans, etc.

My wife did this when she was considering medical school as a second career. She used that app I mentioned, but you could always create it yourself in Excel if you’re good at it. This will give you peace of mind about understanding the financial impacts pros/cons.

Wish you the best.

1