r/headphones•
scgorg

Three-way shootout: Lambda edition

Review
Three-way shootout: Lambda edition

Posted Sep 27, 2019, 6:00 PM UTC

3821
scgorgOPResident estatologist•

Part 1:

I’ve been lucky enough to have 3 different Stax lambdas in my posession at the same time and thought I would write a three-way comparison. While I have reviewed the L700 before I have somewhat changed my mind of them after hearing more headphones and that will be reflected in this review, the other lambdas I will talk about (404LE and SR-Lambda NB) I have written impressions on but nothing more. I will be talking about these as unmodded headphones, so no tack mod on L700 even though I’ve tried it and liked it.

Quick summary: L700

The SR-L700 is the current lambda flagship and a headphone I really fell in love with upon first hearing it. I regretted selling it a lot the first time I owned so when I obtained another one I was surprised to find that it was far worse than I remembered. The fit is quite awkward because my head is so wide that it won’t fit without the earcups being able to swivel more inwards (which you can force but feels really bad to do, and the comfort is still pretty meh).

Starting with the bass the L700 has a very limited bass response compared to our other lambdas. It has somewhat fatter bass than both due to slightly more quantity in the midbass but rolls off much quicker. The L700 also has the worst bass quality of the bunch, feeling boomy compared to the others (but much less boomy than dynamic or planar alternatives). L700 bass is definitely nice for those who like a more typical dynamic response. The attack is slightly blunted and undefined, similar to HE-6/500 or Audeze headphones.

Midrange is quite nice with exception of a peak located around 1k, as with many Stax. My biggest gripe with the 1k peak of the L700 is that it feels like it’s pretty high in Q rather than having a general elevation all the way into the presence region like many Stax do. In total its presence region feels ever so slightly drawn back compared to lambdas but would most likely be considered pretty forward compared to offerings from Hifiman, Audeze and Sennheiser.

Treble is a little uneven but has terrific resolution, no real complaints for me here. I don’t feel like the spikes and dips in the treble affect the overall tone too much, it’s mostly audible if actively listening for it, and I find it more even handed than most planars and dynamic headphones. The headphone has quite a bit of air but it’s nothing crazy.

Quick summary: 404LE

404LE was a limited edition version of the 404 released in 2009 to celebrate 30 years of lambdas. It uses the signature headband which means it has the heaviest clamp of all the headphones compared here, it has the highest quality feeling of all these headphones (and smells really nice). Unlike L700 the bottom of the earcups can actually swivel inwards which makes it a perfect fit on my large head, though I do need to put the strap on max. Ears gently touch the inside of the headphone which can become annoying after a while but unlike something like the L300 it is not painful.

Bass on the 404LE is quite simply the best I’ve ever heard, it’s linear, well extended and has texture and definition to die for. My reference for bass used to be the HE-6 (modded) but 404LE has overtook it. While it doesn’t slam as hard as the HE-6 or TH900 it gets surprisingly close, making it the most physical electrostat I’ve heard yet. The definition on bass notes is nothing short of stunning and make these the best headphones I’ve ever heard for electronic music.

Midrange on the 404LE is elevated all the way from 1k into the treble. It’s a rather gentle boost that I would guess is about 3-4dB, this means that many people might find the headphone shouty, I personallyd did at first but quickly adjusted. The smoothness in the mids makes it so that being elevated isn’t as large of an issue, and I quite enjoy the somewhat forward nature of most Stax lambdas. For reference I’d say it is less shouty than something like an L300.

Treble on the 404LE is well extended and has quite a bit of air (a common theme in Stax). It is not uneven in the same way L700 is, rather it has a slight bump from about 8-10k which gives a decent amount of sizzle to the sound. Anyone who has issues with even slight treble elevation in this range should probably stay away from these headphones. Overall it is very nice and detailed like most Stax.

Quick summary: SR-Lambda NB

The SR-Lambda NB was the first lambda Stax created back in 1979, it features the most comfortable headband of all these headphones. Extremely low clamp, very light and plenty of adjustment room even for my head. The headband feels quite weak but can take some pretty ridiculous abuse, the same goes for the chassis. It is much more sturdy than the L700. It also has a lighter cable than the other headphones here, which can matter depending on how you sit.

The SR-Lambda has a very light «ethereal» type of bass response. Bass can be heard very well all the way down to the lowest octaves but it cannot be felt at all. It feels really quick and nimble, which makes certain instruments like drums and timpanis lose some body. This thinner presentation does it some favors, however, as it has extremely nice definition on the bass notes, all manners of texture from a drum hit also become very obvious, these would make great monitoring headphones I think.

Midrange on the SR-lambda is quite seductive, it feels like it has quite a significant bit more presence than the other two headphones here but is somewhat thin in the lower midrange. The upper midrange/presence region also has a sense of «weakness» in the presentation, when you crank the headphone it sounds like it just wants to die (which could also be my ears not handling listening to 2-3k at such volumes). This is a pretty good headphone for weeb music if you don’t listen too loud.

Treble is strange, it has quite a bit of energy moving into the lower treble but then loses a significant amount of energy from 6-10k before picking up a lot in the air regions. This headphone has insane amounts of air and can be a little fatuiging because of that. The fact that the lower treble and midtreble are somewhat recessed also gives the feeling of the headphone being quite a bit warmer than most Stax despite not having that much lower midrange body to speak of.

SR-L700 vs SR-404LE

L700 wins in: soundstage and detail.

404LE wins in: Imaging, bass, midrange, treble and airiness.

The SR-L700 is utterly outmatched by the 404LE, the smoother midrange and far superior bass extension and definition being the main point where L700 falls short. While L700 manages a larger and more out of head soundstage it sounds incoherent and slightly congested compared to the 404LE. 404LE on the other hand, while having a very small stage has fantastic imaging and layering to go along with it which makes it that much easier to pick out nuance and immerse yourself in the music.

L700’s treble reproduction feels somewhat artificial when directly compared to the 404LE, as it lacks the smoothness that 404LE has. The L700 does have a more relaxed treble presentation overall however, so some listeners might find it more appealing due to that.

The bass on the 404LE utterly outclasses the L700, easily trumping it in extension, slam and detail. The somewhat blunted attack of the L700 makes it sound like a compressed version of the 404LE. 404LE also has far superior detail moving into the lower midrange as well.

The L700 wins in detail overall, a lot of things sound more obvious on it in the midrange and treble which is partially because the response is somewhat ugly in those areas, highlighting a lot of small things in recordings. I wouldn’t say this way to present details sounds very natural though, it feels very pushed up in your face compared to something like the 009S and where it just happens.

Overall it’s a stomp for the 404LE. The L700 brings some nice things to the table but is ultimately too expensive compared to older lambdas with similar or better performance. If you get a good price used I wouldn’t say it is a bad buy, it’s just not something I would live happily with forever knowing what else exists out there.

10
scgorgOPResident estatologist•

Part 2:

SR-L700 vs SR-Lambda

L700 wins: soundstage, detail and treble

SR-Lambda wins: imaging, bass and airiness

These headphones are tied in midrange reproduction for me. While the L700 has an ugly peak the SR-Lambda’s upper mids/lower presence problems make them equal to me, though I think most people will find the SR-Lambda midrange more agreeable if they don’t listen loud and vice versa for the L700.

The bass goes in favor of SR-Lambda, while not as clear cut as the 404LE vs L700 comparison it simply extends deeper, is tighter and has more detail. The L700 has more weight to the bass, however, so some may prefer this if they listen to music without much subbass. I think that while the L700 bass is too boomy the SR-Lambda bass is not boomy enough, it simply sounds artificially thin despite all the stuff that’s supposed to be in the bass being there, it also has a surprising amount of impact for something that I subjectively hear as quite bass light (but well extended).

Treble I have to give to L700, because while the response is somewhat wonky and unnatural the SR-Lambda has too much weird stuff going on, the dip from 6-10k into probably 5dB above neutral worth of air just makes it sound a little odd at times, and objectively further away from my preferred treble response. The SR-Lambda easily wins in airiness with such a pronounced response though.

In terms of detail the L700 wins once again, but for the same reason as earlier I find the SR-Lambdas way of presenting detail more enjoyable. The imaging goes in favor of SR-Lambda though, which I have no doubt is helped a lot by the pronounced air frequencies which subjectively makes a headphone image better to me, the layering is also superior on SR-Lambda. In total I feel it’s quite close between these headphones but if someone offered me one or the other for free I would pick L700 every time due to how many issues lambda drivers this old can encounter.

SR-Lambda vs SR-404LE

404LE wins: Imaging, detail, bass, mids and treble.

SR-Lambda wins: soundstage and airiness

404LE has a much more full bodied bass compared to the SR-Lambda. It hits harder, goes deeper and has more detail, once again the 404LE bass utterly outclasses the other lambda. There is not a single song with a lot of midbass and subbass where I think the SR-Lambda is nicer or more accurate to listen to.

In the midrange the smoothness of the 404LE tides me over quite easily, it also doesn’t feel like it breaks up as soon as you cross 80dB like the SR-Lambda does. SR-Lambda still feels like it has the most energy in the very upper registers of the midrange but it sounds a lot more disjointed than the 404LEs generally forward midrange presentation.

404LE has more detail throughout the entire range and has superior layering and imaging that makes it sound far more natural than the SR-Lambda. The SR-Lambda has a larger soundstage but everything within that soundstage feels more diffuse and lacking in layering comparatively. The SR-Lambda does gain a very slight edge in music that is very simple but that benefits from having a large stage though, as it feels more out of head and the layering isn’t an issue at that point.

Treble of the 404LE generally feels quite a bit smoother than the SR-Lambda, having slightly more energy from 5-8k and then having quite a bit more from 8-10k but losing out in airiness due to the elevated response that the SR-Lambda has here. I would say that 404LE has the more fatuiging treble, but not by much, and the elevation isn’t particularly bad so you would have to be treble sensitive for the 8-10k response to be bothering you. Overall the 404LE takes another clean win.

Conclusion

The 404LE stands at the top of lambda hill and is my personal favorite headphone ever. It simply sounds so natural and enthralling that most of my other headphones are close to unlistenable, and when I do listen I often catch myself wondering why I’m not just listening to 404LE instead.

The L700 and SR-Lambda are about equal to me, but I think the majority of people would prefer the L700 overall, my biggest gripe with L700 remains the price as it is quite a nice headphone, just not the best lambda Stax has ever made (which you would think seeing how expensive it is).

I will not recommend anyone to buy an SR-Lambda unless you know EXACTLY what you are in for, this is a very unique headphone that is also doomed to hit failure at some point. My pair still works but is probably on the way out any day now, I’ll miss it when it goes but 404LE simply does most things better.

Thanks for reading my review, I hope you found it worth your time.

TL;DR: Buy 404LE, bigly great headphone.

7
fii0Micro BL > Loki > Lyr 2 > Sundara•

... Why are the Lambdas doomed to break? Also it would be a great bonus if you mentioned where you managed to find your pair of 404LE.

0
scgorgOPResident estatologist•

The old SR-Lambda drivers have a whole slew of issues. The combination of their gluing and tensioning actually makes the driver loosen up over time (which DEFINITELY shouldn't happen), this means that the chance of membrane getting stuck to an oxidized point on the stator or discharging on the stator is quite a bit higher. It is not atypical for the SR-Sigma and SR-Lambda to encounter these issues after all these years. This usually manifests as channel imbalance as the coating burns off if it gets discharged too much (as well as natural degradation of the coating) and eventually the headphone just decides to die for any reason. The membrane can eventually tear, some dust might have gotten inside in those 40 years making it arc and so on. My pair needs almost 30 minutes before the left side hits equal volume to the right side.

3
saltmonkey27•

A fantastic write-up, thank you. And makes me confident in my decision to go down the 404LE route. They really are something special, the bass is right up there with my LCD-2f, especially after a slight EQ bump, but it's the detail on top of that that really puts all my other headphones to shame. That Stax only ever made 1,000 of them is a bit of a crime - more people deserve to hear them!

6
scgorgOPResident estatologist•

There's a reason I said I would buy your pair if you didn't like them ;)

3
saltmonkey27•

Haha yeah, I don't think I'll be giving up these puppies anytime soon!

2
o7_brotherSR-L700/500 | ER2XR | WF-1000XM3 are OP•

10/10 post

You mentioned you liked the blu-tack mod on the L700, I have it applied on mine and I love it, it makes a night and day difference compared to the stock sound.

How would you rank the bass of the blu-tack L700 against the others? I imagine the 404LE is still better.

2
scgorgOPResident estatologist•

404LE is still better to my ears (by far the best bass I've ever heard, it's unbelieveable). L700 when tacked handily beat the SR-Lambda though. It has so much more weighty bass, so removing the boominess by tacking it really helps.

Of all stax I've heard I would rank bass as such: 404LE>Tacked L700>SR507>009S=SR-X MK3 NB=SR-Lambda>Stock L700>L300>SR-5

2
CanonRockFinal•

how does shoutiness compare on the l700 vs l300 vs sr507 vs sr404 limited?

also, how does the sr507 sound in bass, mid, treble if u dont mind a doing a description of them

btw, great review, wish u had heard the l300 limited edition as well, some review ive watched say that they are like half a step improvement of l700 in terms of soundstage congestion and bass

1
scgorgOPResident estatologist•

I'd say 507 is the most shouty/bright along with L300. I could see someone finding L300 more fatuiging because it's so much more peaky but for me 507 was worst. L700 shout is just really weird because it doesn't have all that much energy in the upper mids, it's just a pretty big but decently narrow peak around 1k-1.3k or so. 404LE feels like it has the most upper midrange energy except for 507 but it's much smoother, so the shouty nature is far from as annoying.

In terms of listening fatigue: 507>L300>404LE>L700 (from most to least fatuiging for me).

SR-507 is the worst lambda I've had the privilege of hearing. Bass is pretty good for a lambda, it extends deep similar to 404LE. Midrange is pretty typical stax, elevated with a lot of presence. 507 is just boosted to fuck above 1KHz until about 10KHz so it becomes really tiresome to listen to. Soundstage doesn't exist but it images pretty well. I wrote a review on them if you want to dig through my profile. Should be more eloquent.

The L300 LTD is objectively not an improvement in the bass from L700. The L500 pads are more leaky than the L700 pads so the helmholtz resonance constructed by the lack of seal from the pad goes higher in frequency, boosting the midbass (where we find most bass information in music). This has been measured, and the bass on the L300 LTD flattens out if you put L700 pads on it.

1
4333mhz"AudioScience Stack" + HD800•

What amp are you using, and do you think that amps for Stax makes a difference other than volume?

Is the 404LE same as the 404 Signature other than the earpads? I bought a 404 Signature and I hear that they are acoustically different. However, after some use, surely the earpads will wear down a bit.

2
scgorgOPResident estatologist•

Personally I have blind tested the difference between an SRD-7 and my 006t with the SR-Lambda and I got it right almost every time, it's subtle though. 006t was used for this review so that every headphone could have the same amplification.

404LE and 404 signature are different. The 404LE drivers were first used in the airbow sc-1, though they apparently had a different dust cover and different earpads then. 404 signature is supposed to be somewhat brigther, less smooth and has worse bass. It is considered among the better lambdas stax has made though. Also, stax earpads last practically forever, that's their best quality imo. The lambda pads traditionally use quite hard foam that doesn't compress much, if at all, and the surface material is genereally very durable. The vinyl pads on my SR-Lambda are still intact with no real signs of wear other than a lot of sweat. EP234 which is used on 202/303/404/207/307/407 I believe is also quite durable and should easily last for at least a decade with little to no degradation. Their leather lambda pads are the same story except you should probably give them some love with a little leather conditioner occasionally.

4
Near_kv•

How did you test detail on all of them and soundstage as well? 🤔

Nice review too.

1
scgorgOPResident estatologist•

For soundstage that is typically obvious on any half-decently mastered music, so I mostly just listen. If I want to listen for soundstage specifically then some smooth jazz or Time by Wintersun.

For detail my go-to is track 13 - back to business from the Violet Evergarden soundtrack, there's A LOT going on there. Other than that Sons of winter and stars and certain electronic tracks are great.

3
Near_kv•

thanks so much 😋

1
o7_brotherSR-L700/500 | ER2XR | WF-1000XM3 are OP•

Not OP, but the only way to test detail and soundstage is with your ears :)

You can have measurements of distortion and transients or whatever, but I don't know of any standardized way of accurately measuring detail. RTings measures soundstage and it kind of seems to work, but it's their own method that's not exactly standardized.

2
Near_kv•

Yeah, most of my music seems to tops out at some point so I was looking for rec's just to see what OP has 🤔🤔🤔

1
Magol79SR-009 - SR-007mkII - Verité C - Eikon•

Thanks for the comparison. I have only heard the current Lambda generation. But I have been curious about the 404LE for a while. I wonder how the L700mkII compares to it..? The bass is supposed to be much improved on the new L700.

I used to own a pair of L700 until recently, but because I was never really satisfied with the roll of in the bass I ended up selling them. The L700 was what made me get into Stax to begin with, so I was a bit sad to see them go.

Anyway, Stax Lambdas are great headphones and give a unique listening experience that is well worth trying out.

1
scgorgOPResident estatologist•

The only things I've seen about bass being improved on L700mk2 has been from head-fi, that means I'm taking it with a huge grain of salt. Would be neat if it is the case though. I think the current lambda generation is quite good in absolute terms but too expensive for what they are. Just the L700 costs like 50% more than what the previous lambda flagship did (SR-507, which was overpriced as fuck too, I might add).

May I ask which gets more head time between your 007 and 009 and whether you've tacked the 007? I owned 009S for a while but ultimately felt it was too expensive for what it was, as well as requiring EQ to fix the bass and upper mids.

3
Magol79SR-009 - SR-007mkII - Verité C - Eikon•

Lachlan posted a vid on the Minidisc channel on YT with his impressions of the mk2 version.

Choosing between the 009 and 007 depends very much on the album I listen to. The 009 is more detailed, but can have problems with albums that are too harsh and/or hard sounding to begin with. But with well mixed albums I really enjoy it. The 007 is not as sensitive, it is more of a generalist and can take any album and make it sound good. I am running both out of a KGSShv.

2