Scientists like Dawkins get rightly indignant when religious people try and explain the natural world unscientifically. So why do they think that they, without any social science training, can best explain the human social world? Are they really that un-self-aware? As an atheist I’m embarrassed.
Posted Sep 29, 2019, 6:07 PM UTC
I saw a recent interview with Dawkins where he freely admitted he had no training in social sciences and his opinions were his own, but referred listeners to greater scientists on the subject. I think we assume outspoken people are attempting to be right, when they often mean to just be heard and let the audience decide.
Many religions of course claim to be absolutely right, and the preachers have some special knowledge or connection to "truth"; if religions had less hubris, they would be less damaging.
That's right.
At the Independent Fundamentalist Baptist church I attended, the pastor insisted that everything the church taught came directly from the King James Bible. Of course, that assertion was pure bologna sausage; in the pulpit he was willing to preach almost anything that would tickle the ears of the more generous financial contributors.
By making such an outlandish claim, the pastor caused any critical thinkers in the congregation to regard with suspicion every statement he made, and he did more harm to his cause than good.
Oh I agree with your point about religions.
I just don’t understand why Dawkins and others think they should speak on social science topics instead of letting the professionals speak on it instead? I call that arrogance, hubris, and lack of self-awareness. They are doing to social science the same thing that religious morons do to them in regards to natural science topics such as the age of the Earth, evolution, etc.
I think anyone can speak on any topic, so long as they dont hold themselves out as an expert when they are not; I have seen Dawkins say he isnt an expert.
Just because they can, doesn’t mean they should. (See: pastors on science).
Pastors hold themselves out as absolute experts on "truth", which trumps (in their worldview) science.
I have seen Dawkins offer the personal opinion as being just that. If you dont like him, fine, he is just a bloke.
So now you're an expert on the ethics of public speaking or should you not be talking?
Did you read literally fucking anything in the comment you're responding to?