Scientists like Dawkins get rightly indignant when religious people try and explain the natural world unscientifically. So why do they think that they, without any social science training, can best explain the human social world? Are they really that un-self-aware? As an atheist I’m embarrassed.

Posted Sep 29, 2019, 6:07 PM UTC

679
[deleted]•

I saw a recent interview with Dawkins where he freely admitted he had no training in social sciences and his opinions were his own, but referred listeners to greater scientists on the subject. I think we assume outspoken people are attempting to be right, when they often mean to just be heard and let the audience decide.

Many religions of course claim to be absolutely right, and the preachers have some special knowledge or connection to "truth"; if religions had less hubris, they would be less damaging.

11
third_declensionEx-Theist•

if religions had less hubris, they would be less damaging

That's right.

At the Independent Fundamentalist Baptist church I attended, the pastor insisted that everything the church taught came directly from the King James Bible. Of course, that assertion was pure bologna sausage; in the pulpit he was willing to preach almost anything that would tickle the ears of the more generous financial contributors.

By making such an outlandish claim, the pastor caused any critical thinkers in the congregation to regard with suspicion every statement he made, and he did more harm to his cause than good.

7
BuildAutonomyOP•

Oh I agree with your point about religions.

I just don’t understand why Dawkins and others think they should speak on social science topics instead of letting the professionals speak on it instead? I call that arrogance, hubris, and lack of self-awareness. They are doing to social science the same thing that religious morons do to them in regards to natural science topics such as the age of the Earth, evolution, etc.

-2
[deleted]•

I think anyone can speak on any topic, so long as they dont hold themselves out as an expert when they are not; I have seen Dawkins say he isnt an expert.

6
BuildAutonomyOP•

Just because they can, doesn’t mean they should. (See: pastors on science).

0
[deleted]•

Pastors hold themselves out as absolute experts on "truth", which trumps (in their worldview) science.

I have seen Dawkins offer the personal opinion as being just that. If you dont like him, fine, he is just a bloke.

4
Lurly•

So now you're an expert on the ethics of public speaking or should you not be talking?

3
LimpEmotion•

Did you read literally fucking anything in the comment you're responding to?

4
Cyber_Grant•

Are you trying to imply that religious people are "social scientists". Believing in God does not make you an expert on jack. Even a religious studies degree has nothing to do with the social sciences. As an atheist, I'm embarrassed for you.

2
BuildAutonomyOP•

no I'm not. please re-read my comment.

0
Cyber_Grant•

Are you saying "why do religious people think think they can describe the human social world"? Perhaps relating thier unscientific understanding of Earth science and evolution to their unscientific understanding of human social behavior due to the fact that evolution gives us an insight into human nature and that religion does not have a monopoly on morality?

1
BuildAutonomyOP•

No. It says why do natural scientists like Dawkins think they have the expertise to analyze and speak about the social science realm of study.

And especially why do they (again: the scientists) think it is a good idea to get in bed with religious conservatives to do so???

1
-SENDHELP-Anti-Theist•

Because perhaps they do? You don’t necessarily need a degree to be an expert, but Dawkins never claims to be an expert anyways.

2
mooninitespwnj00Anti-Theist•

It hurts my brain to see someone who is so capable of nuance throw the phrase "postmodern nonsense" out like it ain't shit.

Die-hard empiricists really bum me out.

1
BuildAutonomyOP•

Deep knowledge often makes people wrongly think they are also in possession of broad knowledge. It’s a problem. Ha.

1
Leevus_AloneStrong Atheist•

Without any social science training? Dawkins has continually argued that religion is a hinderance on progressive society. Sounds alot like social science to me.

1
BuildAutonomyOP•

Religion is so much more complicated than that. I am an atheist and I love natural sciences, but without having done any college level learning on the socio-cultural role that religion plays in different societies, making that statement is simply stating one’s own biases which are shaped by popular culture and not backed by research. Now they may be right (or partially right) or they may be wrong, but they are not social science.

0
Voltwind5006•

I've watched and listened to a lot of Dawkins. I honestly think he is quite polite and respectful. He simply requires people to back up what they are saying when they assert unscientific beliefs. He'll hold them accountable, that's all. I guess it makes them feel attacked and hurt when they can't defend their myths.

1
BuildAutonomyOP•

I like dawkins generally too. The god delusion was a great book. His books on evolutionary biology are awesome.

Why would he share a stage with christian religious nuts then?

3
Voltwind5006•

He's polite and more than happy to teach people about evolution and how it works and why it's accepted. A great example is the video where he's answering questions for high school students. I'm sure it's frustrating though when he can explain something to somebody only for them to go "no, you're wrong" when he's one of the most qualified people on the subject.

2
BuildAutonomyOP•

But the event I linked to in the post is about academic disagreements that religious conservatives have with social scientists and humanities experts (MOST OF WHOM ARE ATHEISTS BTW). And Dawkins is siding with the religious people!!! Insane.

1
voodoochile78•

To own the libs.

2
August3•

If he makes a mistake, feel free to use social science to counter him.

By the way, "as an atheist", what are you doing to quench the old superstitions?

1
BuildAutonomyOP•

Which superstitions? Religion, or the superstitions about the influence of postmodernism and pseudoscience in academia?

0
August3•

Religion of course. And they can't all be right.

2
BuildAutonomyOP•

Oh as an atheist. I see. Well not too much, advocating for separation of church and state and against tax exempt status for religious institutions. Advocating for the end of religious private schools. Spreading the good word of there being no judgmental god out to get us all. Raising atheist kids. Writing letters when I see news stories of people being persecuted or excluded because of lack of religion. Probably the same as most atheists I would imagine. Why, am I not allowed to criticize Dawkins unless I am more of an atheist advocate than him? That’s a pretty absurd standard, if so.

1
August3•

I'm not asking that you exceed him, just that you recognize the need to get at the root of the problem - superstition.

1
Cyber_Grant•

Because scientists of any kind are smart people and religious people don't know jack about anything!

1
BuildAutonomyOP•

True

1
Bruce_LillyStrong Atheist•

why do they think that they, without any social science training, can best explain the human social world?

By "social science" you mean "postmodern" pseudoscience; anybody with training in actual science can deal with that the same way as they can deal with any other pseudoscience (astrology, numerology, phrenology...).

-4
BuildAutonomyOP•

Sociology, anthropology, geography, etc have tons of statistically and quantitatively based research. You’re just plain ignorant. This is exact arrogance I am referring to with Dawkins. Scientists displaying the dunning-krueger effect in regards to social science is so embarrassing.

3
Bruce_LillyStrong Atheist•

No. You put "social science" in the title of your post, whereas Dawkins is clearly and explicitly referring to "postmodern" pseudoscientific nonsense:

Pretentious postmodern nonsense is a serious menace in universities & contemporary culture.

-1
BuildAutonomyOP•

Yeah but that LITERALLY doesn’t exist as a large scale phenomenon. It’s a boogeyman. It’s a more acceptable and less confrontational way of saying social science. Because if they say social science, they’ll get ripped a new one by actual social scientists.

3
Bruce_LillyStrong Atheist•

Bull-fucking-shit. You could have easily looked up "postmodern" in any reputable dictionary or "postmodernism" on Wikipedia or an any reputable print or online encylopedia.

If you want to try to claim that the baragouinage (word salad) of Foucault, Lyotard, Derrida, et al. is "social science", go ahead and try to make a case. Perhaps you would like to explain how the deliberately nonsense article by Alan Sokal accepted and published in Social Text constitutes "social science" (other than in the way intended by Sokal).

-1
mooninitespwnj00Anti-Theist•

By "social science" you mean "postmodern" pseudoscience

Wut

1
Bruce_LillyStrong Atheist•

Dawkins referred to "postmodern nonsense"; OP conflates that with "social science".

1
BuildAutonomyOP•

Dawkins refers to social science AS postmodern psuedoscience. It’s a linguistic trick and you are trying to get away with it too. Not working, sorry. Please for the love of god take a sociology survey class.

2
Bruce_LillyStrong Atheist•

Dawkins refers to social science AS postmodern psuedoscience.

Citation please.

Dawkins isn't responsible for your misinterpretation. He was clearly referring to the sort of nonsense that has happened at The Evergreen State College, Williams College, Sarah Lawrence College, NYU, and others, as has been widely reported (e.g. see https://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/?s=Evergreen+State&searchsubmit=Find+%C2%BB). A book could be written on the problem, and indeed it has been: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/40711469-springtime-for-snowflakes.

0
mooninitespwnj00Anti-Theist•

OP reasonable links the dismissal of social justice with unqualified statements by an unqualified person about social science. A big reason for that is how Dawkins approaches the entire issue. Given Dawkins' (and new atheists' in general) philosophical outlook, it's honestly pretty easy to utterly dismiss his statement as a reactionary rant because Postmodern Bad =/= a real argument. The arguments that Dawkins throws out against social justice are just as inept as all the other reactionaries (relative to the subject) precisely because they are all identical, and equally weak.

0
Bruce_LillyStrong Atheist•

Please provide a citation where Dawkins said something negative or disparaging about "social science".

I can find only one quote about social science -- a positive one -- from an article written around an interview with him [reference to "social science" in bold]:

He explained that whereas classicists have traditionally been assumed to be the scholars most able to branch into any area of research, today – with advances in evolutionary study – it will be those with scholarship in evolutionary science who will supersede classicists in depth, breadth and usefulness.

He predicted that those who took his new degree course would achieve a "polymathic status". He said the course "places evolution at the centre but brings in lots and lots of other subjects such as economics, social science, philosophy, engineering, medicine, agriculture, linguistics, physics, cosmology and history of science."

Dawkins went into some detail to justify this statement, explaining the relevance of the various disciplines, starting with behavioural economics: "Everything has to be paid for, there is no such thing as a free lunch. You have to pay for whatever you do now in the form of lost opportunities to do other things in the future."

He claimed that in the areas of sexual selection, parent–offspring relationships and sex ratio theory, economic thinking was "rife" within evolutionary research.

"What are the evolutionary origins for empathy, for sympathy, for our tendency to feel sorrow when we feel distress? Our tendency to want to help other people – other sentient beings indeed."

1
Bruce_LillyStrong Atheist•

The arguments that Dawkins throws out against social justice

Citation please. N.B. "social justice" != "social justice warrior".

1