Should we request imgur to tineye uploaded images? Just like reddit search leads to the submission page when a link is not found?

Crediting the correct person, and maintaining history of items uploaded to imgur has been brought up a few times. Some say its a problem, some say its a feature, some say STFU.

I understand the ease with which on can upload to imgur and post to reddit, and then everyone has a few laughs or ends up visiting eyebleach.com

But then again, we only wanted imgur because the real sites couldn't handle the load. In other words, imgur helps us make sure we don't forward tons of advertising money to an original author, because their servers can't handle it.

Anyhoo, here's the idea:

  • Someone uploads and image to imgur
    • imgur searches through previous posts on reddit
  • imgur provides the option
    • here are links to the other sources where this image was found
    • upload the image anyway

Then the uploader may use the fresh upload, or an older link. Makes it more streamlined, helps synergy, pushes the envelope and helping all of us imagineer a better future.

[Edit: formatting, obvisouly]

Posted Sep 8, 2010, 9:44 AM UTC

69
jeffus•

Let me know what you think of the webapp a friend and I made for Reddit; here's an example:

http://srcplz.com/4gj3sd/

As you mention, tineye api is expensive (we looked at that too!), but we have some plans to add technology that might help a bit. Let me know what you think.

3
rantAccountOP•

It's pretty simple to use, and useful too. Helps people keep their ad-money, reduces load for imgur, gives credit, nicely done! Nice! :-D

Just gave your post, and reddit post an upvote :-)

1
socket0•

The idea is good, but this would place a huge load on TinEye, in exchange for zero ads being displayed. I'm not sure how many images imgur processes per day, but the number is sure to be significant. TinEye won't like that.

2
rantAccountOP•

They do offer an API, so clearly they don't mind people using it..

If we keep avoiding hitting websites we like to use because "they'll go down", it just seems weird (maybe only to me..)

Oi, found this too: 1500USD for 30000 searches. That might put a dent in the plan.

2
poidh•

Should be possible to negotiate a better deal for mentioning tineye... also, I think the load wouldn't be so heavy since imgur might cache the search results (a lot of duplicate submission will be binary copies of the same image, so it's enough to hash the file). So, say the most popular picture will be uploaded a hundred times, it all comes down to one query.

2
socket0•

Maybe they'll go for a fair offer: unlimited searches in exchange for a dozen bags of beef jerky and reddit Gold membership for all TinEye admins.

1
[deleted]•

Try reading the comments to every repost, old picture or any post you've seen a thousand times. There are always people who see it for the first time.

Reposts get upvoted for a reason. If everyone's seen it already it won't pass the new page.

2
bibster•

That's not the point, the point is bringing the content, but not a n-th copy, but rather an allready existing copy.

1
rantAccountOP•

I'm not promoting the end of reposts, just the ability to link to the correct post, even when reposting. Again, users should be allowed to ignore the hints and repost anyway too.

1