Too many Garmin devices. Not sure how to best track.

I've been running my trusty Fenix 5S as my bike computer for some time now but in an effort to stay motivated and run longer routes, I bought a Edge 530 for a whole lot of reasons but I cannot figure out which way I want to track activities, if there even is any difference at all.

As a triathlete, do I want to initiate activities on my Fenix or Edge? I know ANT+ sips battery but the limited 5S capacity plus the age of my watch in general means that if I wanted to do something like a full-day century ride tracking with the HRM-Tri and my powermeter padals, I will probably have to charge at some point. Using just GPS on a hike in Iceland, my watch died 5 miles from where we started which was pretty shitty considering we could have used those breadcrumbs to get us through a sticky bit.

Am I right in thinking that if I pair the HRM and pedals with the Edge, and initiate the activity there, all the device logging will happen on the Edge and thusly save my Fenix battery? Will I still be able to use the Extended Display function? Or should I just keep on keeping on with the Fenix? Are there advantages and disadvantages depending on where you initiate the activity?

Posted Oct 1, 2019, 12:18 AM UTC

38
aspenextreme03•

Try extended display and see what you think. I am not a fan it. Personally I use my 530 to track on bike stuff when cycling only as the screen is nice and big.

When i do brick workouts I track using my 6X watch as the main but also use my edge as a secondary just in case. Battery life on both are so good it is not an issue with my hrm tri and multiple other ant+ sensors.

5
abeardancingOPnoob•

I didn't even think about BRICK workouts.

I'll give the extended display some mileage. I'm definitely going to re-think my screen strategy. I think I'll make a bunch of watch screens then a bunch of bike screens. Hopefully it won't get too confusing.

1
aspenextreme03•

I really like the 6x and the battery / screen size are awesome. Using physio true up really works well so regardless of where you record it I get the metrics on my 6x.

Whatever data screens you have for run/bike etc are what show up when doing a brick.

1
abeardancingOPnoob•

How do you like your 6 BTW?

1
sporkinatorus•

I did exactly the same thing (Fenix 5 then bought Edge 530). Overall the Edge is superior in every way for riding. My biggest driver to get the 530 was the longer routes, the Fenix had limited memory and only supported like 74 turns for turn-by-turn directions. The 530's altimeter is more accurate as well (newer graphs are a nice touch too).

On race-day i use my Fenix to track the 3 disciplines and setup extended display on the bike before i do the swim. When I run up to the bike in transition, it's sync'd up already and ready to go with power meters and whatnot connecting as i start the bike leg.

​

Edit: Added words.

3
dale_shingles//•

Are you talking about just training or in a race? If it's just training, I don't see the point of running your watch and your 530, you don't really gain anything, and I find trying to use my watch for anything while I'm on the bike to be cumbersome and inconvenient. If you're racing and need to stretch your battery, you could try disabling GLONASS or using UltraTrac mode, but if your watch isn't making it through 5 or so hours in GPS mode then you should probably think about replacing that.

2
abeardancingOPnoob•

Specifically training. I was about to plonk down on a Fenix 6 but it looks like they are all sold out for the next few months.

1
dale_shingles//•

Just run the 530 during training and don't worry about a new watch until you step up to longer races.

3