Thoughts on Dylan Hunter

I just watched season 5 episode 4 where Dan is revealed as author of his novel “Inside”.

And wow, Dan/Dylan Hunter is a huge dick. I dislike him a lot in season 5. He’s thirsty and self serving. He told Vanessa at the end of season 4 that he worked on this book for “5 years” but he wrote Serena/Sabrina as a vapid promiscuous party girl when he was still involved with her up to December of that year and his “feelings” for Blair started over winter break. Definitely a dick move if he did revisions to make Blair look good and added a fantasy sex scene with her months before Vanessa found the draft of his book.

I know in reality, it’s probably a plot hole once the writers decided to drive first half of season 5’s drama with the book fallout. Still, Dan is so unlikable. He’s always has been judgmental and self righteous but its amped up to another level this season. Ugh.

Posted Oct 2, 2019, 4:59 PM UTC

135
jakev37•

Inside doesn’t really make any sense in fitting an actual timeframe to be written in. I believe the characters descriptions were actually based on what critics were saying about the show.

Every time a show features a writer as a main character this is what happens; Lucas’ book on One Tree Hill and Seth’s comic book on The OC. Dan writing a completely original book doesn’t push the show anywhere whilst Dan ‘exploiting’ his friends can push a story on the show.

16
OneTwoWee000OP•

Dan ‘exploiting’ his friends can push a story on the show

Yep, well said!

Funny thing is when Nate is able to exploit his friends in the next episode, he chooses not to. Dan is the one who lacks a moral compass and wrote a revenge/fantasy novel about everyone yet he berates Serena about giving him a “fake” apology to get the movie rights. Obnoxious doesn’t even describe him but it’s good he finally gave her the rights.

1
[deleted]•

Dan is the one who lacks a moral compass and wrote a revenge/fantasy novel

This is something everyone seems to forget, Dan didn't publish the book. How is he exploiting his friends if he was never going to publish it until Vanessa literally stole the book from him and had it published? Sure, one could say he's exploiting his friends by writing about them in his writing exercise, which is what the novel was supposed to be and not an actual novel until Vanessa stole the draft, but then every writer who draws from their own life is exploiting people.

As for it being a fantasy, people also seem to forget that Dan made his own character as bad or the worst of them all, and calls his own character a judgemental dick. And it's not a fantasy if he ends up alone with no one on his side. Which is how Dylan, Dan's character ends up in his own novel.

Regarding the different treatment of Serena and Blair, what you say about plot holes is the most likely answer. But even then, there is an in character explanation. Like I said, he made even his own character into a satire of the worst qualities of himself, so Serena's characterization in the book is in keeping with that of where he writes them as caricatures of their worst qualities. However, he's always seen Blair as a caricature of her worst qualities in real life, up until their unexpected friendship where he gets to know her more. So wouldn't it be more challenging for him to write her in a favorable light? His feelings played a part obviously, but it's said that Dan started working on it in again after 4.11, and at that point in time, his feelings for her were friendship, so he can't have written her in a favorable light just because he developed a crush on her by 4.17. There isn't enough time to rework an entire character.

9
fuckthetop•

I’m a mod for the Gossip Girl Wiki page and we have excerpts from Inside via screenshots taken from the show and the full articles from his Inside Out serial. The prose of the book is really interesting and is similar to the writing of the GG novels.

If you’re interested look here

Fun fact: the book used to be available on Amazon!

7
DarcyQ11•

I think it's definetely a plot hole. I mean I love GG, but don't take it too seriously. Don't over analize it either. The writers had good moments and then went completely random. I think they just decided to get Blair and Dan together and just invented that whole book despite not making sense.

1