r/PSVR•
vgambit

After getting a Vive, and later a Quest, I now understand why my PSVR has spent years gathering dust, despite getting an Aim and many of the best games (IPD, tracking, controls, and PITA setup; bring on the downvotes anyway tho). PSVR makes too many compromises.

Fluff

Sorry for the wall of text. I type fast and generally don't have time to be more brief.

tl;dr: PSVR makes a lot of compromises in an otherwise transformative technology that limits potential in game design and comfort. Even with the improved HMD fit comfort, and image quality with its diffusers vs SDE in other headsets, IMO, you wouldn't enjoy your PSVR nearly as much if you had a Vive or Quest. I hope it gets replaced by an inside-out tracking system, and ultimately phased out at some point during the next console generation. I hope they don't force developers to support the legacy hardware. I also hope that PS5 features a new headset that uses inside-out tracking that doesn't need a camera, and also features hardware IPD adjustment.

First, a quick comparison between the PSVR and the Quest, from a comment I left a couple of days ago elsewhere:

PSVR:

  • Unbox the headset
  • Plug in the HDMI and data cables into the breakout box's cables
  • Swap HDMI cables so the PS4 passes through the breakout box (because my 1st-gen box doesn't have HDR passthrough)
  • Grab headphones and plug them into the PSVR
  • Move the camera on top of several boxes on a table in front of my TV (because my TV is too thin to put the camera on top of it, and I have one of the old boxy PS4 cameras) to try to reduce tracking issues
  • Turn on the PS4, then wait a bit and turn on the headset, leaving it to calibrate on a table to reduce drift later on
  • Make sure I'm sitting/standing at the right distance from the camera
  • Do a calibration test to verify I'm not out of frame for any common actions
  • It drifts anyway

Vs Quest:

  • Remove the Quest from the carrying case I bought for it, which is too small to stack anything on top of
  • Put it on
  • Grab controllers
  • Play

Rereading that comment, I realize that I left out the parts about adjusting the PSVR so that it fits properly, then readjusting after putting on headphones, then finding the ideal distance balance between so close my eyelashes rub against the lenses, instantly smudging it worse with every blink, and so far that a lot of light bleeds in and the FOV is sacrificed.

I'll admit that the Vive shares some pains with the PSVR, especially if you don't have stands for the base stations (even more so if you have to move the base stations every time you play). My PC is in the living room, but I have more space to play in my bedroom, so when I'm developing, I have the base stations in the living room, but otherwise, I'll move them and re-do room setup, which means unplugging, moving, re-plugging, then walking around the room, clicking the controller trigger in each corner to re-establish the room scale area.

So that's the PITA aspect out of the way. On to IPD:

My IPD is about 75-76mm. Quest goes up to 72. Vive goes up to 74. On Vive, I'm totally fine (I can actually force the IPD up to about 74.9). On Quest, I'm almost totally fine; if I go to the max, the offset between the hardware and my own eyes is small enough to be a non-issue. But on the PSVR, and this is something I honestly didn't realize wasn't normal until I tried the Vive, I actually cannot have a comfortable experience at all.

I had done the auto-IPD adjustment via the software, and that set my IPD to 74, but the problem is that the hardware's lenses are a fixed distance apart. You're supposed to adjust the HMD until you have a clear picture in both lenses, but if I adjust for clarity in one, I'm disorientingly blurry in the other. The best I can do is make both lenses slightly blurry, with a tiny, narrow window of clarity in the very center, and towards the inside of each lens. I imagine it's possible to get used to it, but it still kinda sucks when you realize how much better your experience can get when you're given the option to move the lenses apart.

Next is controls.

Here's my tier list, top to bottom:

  • Index controllers
  • Oculus Touch controllers

(wide gap)

  • Vive wands

(wide gap, bottom tier is below)

  • Dual Shock 4

(small gap)

  • PS Aim
  • PS Move

Index controllers have fairly accurate finger curl tracking in addition to a grip strength sensor. They're strapped to your hands, so picking things up and letting them go happens by making a very familiar pick up/let go motion with your hands, knowing that the controller won't fall because it's secured. Thumbsticks, buttons, and a ridiculously-accurate trackpad give you all sorts of control possibilities in games. There are also "cap touch" sensors that know when you're resting your fingers on buttons, but not pressing them.

Oculus Touch controllers also have thumbsticks, buttons, and captouch sensors, but replace finger tracking on the grip with a grip trigger. The gap between Touch and Index is somewhat narrow as a result, since you can get similar inputs (though you can't actually properly let go of Touch controllers without a hardware addon).

Vive wands suck in comparison to the above, but they're leagues better than the PS inputs due to the touchpads and their accuracy.

The Dual Shock 4 is good because VR games that use it (e.g. WipeOut) don't generally rely on it for tracking in 3D space, and it has a lot of buttons.

The PS Aim is not great, for two reasons: the rifle layout of the controller means it's really only any good for shooting games, and the tracking is terrible. If I play Borderlands 2 for 2 minutes, by that second minute, my in-game rifle is offset from my controller by something like 45 degrees, and I have to try to wrestle the thing all around to try to realign the two for a short while before they drift apart again, even if I'm standing at an angle relative to the camera just to try to prevent occlusion-based tracking problems, like Gun Club suggests.

The PS Move controllers suck because not only do they have bad tracking, but they also have a severe lack of inputs. If the move button were a trackpad like the DS4, then they might be sorta okay, tracking notwithstanding. If they had thumbsticks, that would also be sorta okay. But as it is, on PSVR, your locomotion options with Move are teleport or arm swinger, and the later is in very few games, from what I understand.

On Vive, you have the option of thumbstick/touchpad smooth locomotion, which lets you move around freely while aiming or otherwise using the controllers. If you don't mind spending extra, you can attach trackers to your ankles and walk in place to move. I'll be using my Vive wands as trackers now that I have Index controllers.

On Quest, again, you have thumbstick movement. I'm lucky, and seem to be immune to motion sickness, but as people get their VR legs, more and more developers have no issues using smooth locomotion as the standard option, especially given peripheral motion-blocking comfort options that are fairly easy to implement.

Finally, tracking.

On Vive, 2 base stations in opposing corners above your head are fairly bulletproof. I've had no issues at all with it.

On Quest, you have 4 cameras built into the HMD that look for the controllers, and the controllers have sensors that help compensate for the moments when they're out of sight (e.g. reaching behind your back or waist).

Base station on Vive and inside-out tracking on Quest means that you get roomscale VR, and can move around quite a bit based on how much space you have. I can get about 3.4m x 3.4m in my room. In H3VR, for example, I generally stick to the center of the space, but move around freely once I'm in cover during a hold.

On Quest, I can do the same, except I don't need to worry about how many times I turn in a direction because there are no wires.

On PSVR, not only am I forced to stay in one spot (otherwise I leave the tracking volume), but drifting is very common, especially if the light in the room isn't the right color or some nonsense. I point my Aim controller straight ahead and look down the sights, but my in-game gun is 45+ degrees off to the left. It's maddening.

Blood and Truth is cool and all, but imagine how much better it would be if you had more than a trigger and Move + a couple of face buttons to use to interact with the game. You could move freely instead of being pulled from point to point.

Due to all of the issues above, Dirt Rally, Tetris Effect, and WipeOut are the only games I'd bother with on PSVR moving forward, and 2 outta those 3 are also on PC. If you can, I'd recommend selling your PSVR in favor of a Quest. Even with the performance hit, the rest of the ways the Quest beats the PSVR more than makes up for it, and developers are finding creative ways of porting heavy PC games to that platform anyway. Crucially, you can just buy one from Best Buy, because their return policy gives you 14 days to try it out and return it if you don't think it's worth it.

I didn't mention the Oculus Link (PCVR cable) functionality launching in an update next month, or the hand tracking (also an update) launching next year.

The PSVR was kinda always a set of compromises compared to the Vive, largely in exchange for a much lower barrier of entry in terms of cost for folks that had already owned a PS4 for up to 3 years by its launch, but IMO, the cost of the competition is so low now that it really doesn't make any sense to get into it at this point.

Even if you're tight on cash, if you're a VR head, I'd strongly recommend selling the PSVR on Craigslist or eBay, and putting it towards a Quest. Save up/sell other games to make up the difference if need be. The rough, sideloaded (free!) version of Pavlov VR alone is leagues better than a lot of what's touted as the best PSVR experiences, IMO.

SN: I didn't mention this above, as it's a bit of a fringe thing, and not quite official, but sideloading on the Quest adds a ridiculous amount of utility.

It has a far higher resolution than the PSVR, so it actually makes sense as a media device, and works very well at it. It includes VR versions of Netflix and Prime Video, plus 2D (virtual screen) versions of a bunch of other media apps, but you can additionally sideload the standard Android versions of Netflix and Prime Video (as well as Plex), which enables higher-quality streams and offline video downloading. That, coupled with the 3DoF mode option, means you can watch shows and movies, in VR, at high quality, anywhere, even without an internet connection (e.g. planes).

You can also pair an Xbox One controller to it, and sideload RetroArch, a collection of emulators. You get full speed emulation of Genesis, NES, SNES, GBA, arcade, N64, and PS1. Apparently, it can also emulate Gamecube and Wii somewhat well in several cases.

Posted Oct 3, 2019, 7:34 PM UTC

081
Loading comments…