Mission Timers

Does anyone else find the constant mission timers to not really fit well with red dead? I started playing again recently to check out the new updates, and was really enjoying bounty hunting. I did one of the basic ones, but somehow didn't make it in time, I got to the police station literally right when the timer ticked down, and that was it, no reward, mission failed. Which, honestly, doesn't make any sense to me. Why would they not want that guy with a bounty because I was a second late?

I also feel like the timers keep me from really taking things slow and enjoying it. I wish I could take a mission and while I'm on the way I can stop and hunt if I see a deer, or help that stranger in the random encounter, but I can't, instead I'm just sitting in cinematic mode or repeatedly hitting a button for 5 minutes waiting to get where I'm going. The timers make the size of the map feel brutal instead of the benefit that it should be, because I'm focused on just getting where I'm going in time instead of enjoying what the map has to offer.

I don't expect Rockstar to completely change how they're going about things, but I think even just the addition of more un-timed things to do would make it more fun and even allow for more roleplaying. It just doesn't immerse you in the world when you want to steal a wagon or something, so you need to talk to a person, who then times you to get that wagon and get somewhere else, and then that's it. It feels incredibly gamey and almost separate from the rest of the world.

I feel like it works in GTA, because racing around the dense city streets to get there in time is like a fun minigame all on it's own, but it's just not fun in red dead. The map is just too spread out for it, making it so that the vast majority of my gameplay is just riding a horse unable to stop and smell the flowers on the way Haha.

Anyways, anyone else agree with my complaints, or is it something you got used to? Doesn't all the timed traveling start to get kind of unbearable? Have there been any comments from Rockstar on plans to make more un-timed things, or more options for things to do outside of set missions, maybe like stealing or robbing stagecoaches unprompted, or horses, or robbing people, or anything else like that?

Posted Oct 3, 2019, 11:02 PM UTC

45
SneezyBoots:collector: Collector•

I really like that the owlhoots aren’t timed. And I agree I think the bounties should be timerless.

4
EuphioMachineOP•

Yeah, at least that wasn't timed. But I also didn't really like the way it's like instanced basically. I guess that's my issue, I want less timers and less instanced stuff, more stuff that you can just run into completely free roam and just do.

2
Airikr666:Bounty: Bounty Hunter•

They are not really adding pressure most of the time because you usually finish a mission like 10 minutes before the timer runs out.

They are probably just there so players cannot block a free roam mission by going afk or doing anything but the mission after they have started it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
EuphioMachineOP•

They are not really adding pressure most of the time

Yeah I agree, most of the time you have time to spare and people just wait out the clock for a higher reward. I mean, after sitting on my horse waiting, getting the guy or the wagon or whatever it is, then sitting on my horse waiting some more, to then get to the drop off and wait a couple minutes more just isn't really fun, and I think it gets in the way of what otherwise would feel like some awesome content.

They are probably just there so players cannot block a free roam mission by going afk

This is actually something I hadn't really considered. It makes sense, you can't have two people doing the same mission going to the same place. But I feel like you could solve this by just having more options, and then also having an idle timer that will fail you if you're just sitting there.

I don't know, maybe I'm looking for it to feel more like a standard open world RPG and that's just not really what they're going for I guess. But even so, I feel like the constant timers and instanced content takes away a lot more than it gives.

1
Airikr666:Bounty: Bounty Hunter•

Yes, it's stupid that it pays more money if you milk the timer.

And I also agree that it should feel more like a RPG. They have decided to work on the depth and immersion of the experience but they are not really doing it right. A lot of stuff is way too shallow to live up to it's purpose.

1