A damning take on some big name disruptors

https://www.profgalloway.com/mdma

I think post this might prompt some decent discussion, a lot of companies I see discussed around here are mentioned. Galloway, a Clinical Professor of Marketing at NYU, is decidedly unimpressed with the adoration heaped upon many of these companies. I hope the post is read before comments, there are nuggets of truth regardless of what side you stand on the matter. His predictions:

Overvalued unicorns:

  • Pinterest
  • Snap
  • Twitter
  • Peloton
  • Slack
  • DoorDash
  • Lime
  • Palantir
  • Uber
  • Compass

Companies that could lose 80% of their value or disappear entirely:

  • Tesla
  • WeWork
  • Lyft
  • Robinhood
  • OYO

Here's a response: https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-elon-musk-disappear-lose-80-percent-value-nyu-professor/

Posted Oct 7, 2019, 2:24 AM UTC · edited

1213
dvdmovie1•

The issue with Galloway is that he's become too much of a "character" - he's tech's hall monitor, which makes for easy soundbites on CNBC and elsewhere. When he talks for longer, he's more interesting but otherwise he plays a role that gets repetitive.

OP says: "is decidedly unimpressed with the adoration heaped upon many of these companies."

Yes, that's "his thing." He also said in 2015 that the future of retail "looks like Macy's, not Amazon." (https://www.l2inc.com/daily-insights/the-future-of-retail-looks-like-macys-not-amazon)

As for some of the companies:

Slack - when management has an automatic share sale program that is literally selling just about every single day (people thought Marc Benioff has been an aggressive seller of Salesforce at times over the years, it's nothing compared to how regularly Slack's management has been dumping) that's a problem.

Pinterest - I'm actually positive on Pinterest, which isn't something I'd thought I would be saying. I see Pinterest as a potentially very compelling mall; it's (at least in my experience) surprisingly good at suggesting things based on your interests and one can imagine Pinterest increasingly as a visual mall. It's the place where you can be inspired on what to eat, what to wear, etc. Continues to evolve the shopping aspect (https://www.wsj.com/articles/pinterest-harnesses-ai-for-visual-based-shopping-11568925943.) It's also an oddly calming Oasis of cute animals, pretty places and great food; it's not angry politics and the news. In other words, Pinterest is a brand-friendly escape.

Lime - There was a study somewhere and I wish I remembered where I saw it where the Scooters wore out before they could be profitable.

Uber - I still don't see how it's going to be profitable.

Robinhood - free trades are now basically a commodity. Either RH goes away or has to become more than it is and it will probably go towards banking. A lot of companies are - imo - going to try to be a financial hub - spending, investing, banking, etc. Square, too.

DoorDash - Square was smart to sell Caviar to Doordash while Doordash had Softbank money to spend. I'm not a fan of any of these third party food delivery services.

Tesla - I've noted my feelings on here about Tesla specifically at great length many times before. Broadly, the auto industry is not a great industry and that includes making EVs.

14
tlighta•

Yeah, fundamentally a professor of marketing at NYU isn't the person to ask about running an auto company.

The stock could lose 80% of its value, but that is because that is how high risk high growth stocks work.

4
6chan•

i need clarification on how is one a clinical professor of marketing?

1
reedread21•

Robinhood

Are they even public?

2
KillerMe33•

No.

1
d2fdf7dc3f53647f•

Agree with all.

IMO, undervalued recent IPO stocks:

Cloudflare

Avalara

2
gullypenguin•

I'm not disagreeing but why do you say that? They trade at 21x sales and 15x sales respectively and I only use this particular valuation metric because neither make money atm.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ikonkaar•

Tesla ain't going anywhere soon. Gigafactory 3 is almost ready.

1†

I think Tesla is interesting, they are running against time right now. The pent up demand for model 3 has been exhausted in most markets. They have been selling in new markets to prop up revenue but those markets too will reach study state in a few quarters. If they can get model y into production then it will survive but if they don't then it will be difficult to maintain the current valuation. Model 3, in hindsight was a mistake, it canabalised the sales of X and Y. I don't think they will go bankrupt anytime soon but if a few things go wrong then it could happen.

2
CarRamRob•

The giga factory isnt going anywhere and will continue to produce. Tesla...jury is still out.

1
JeffB1517•

Not quite sure what you wanted to discuss. SoftBank is a VC firm in addition to a big player in mobile telco. The valuations on SoftBank are excellent because WallStreet is so unhappy with the performance of the VC aspects. If one values the VC at $0 the mobile telco is going at a very good price. Stocks wallstreet hate that have lots of money and hard assets are my taste. So for the first time in my life, I'm in crazy internet stocks. I don't know what the crazy internet stocks are worth, but I gotta figure its more than -75b dollars which is what the street is currently pricing them at.

And besides as a value investor SoftBank is an excellent diversifier for me.

1
EasternBeyond•

Softbank has over $200billion debt. Their valuations are based on phantasy valuations of their invested start ups. They are definitely not a value investment.

1
JeffB1517•
  • 25.8% of Baba
  • 75% of ARM
  • 67% of Softbank corp (cell company)
  • over $23b in Sprint
  • 8.5b in other equiry
  • 33.4b in vision (likely worth something)

Cash and bonds for most of that debt leaving about $46b

The startups don’t matter at this price. That’s the point. Softbank’s valuations are based on Wall Street hating a stock with assets because they are mad about the start ups not working out

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0