r/Fantasy•
botla

66% through The Magicians by Lev Grossman and I'm struggling to maintain interest. Is the end worth sticking around for?

I borrowed the Magicians from the library and thought it would be interesting. But I have been really struggling to get through the book and I'm not sure it's worth my time to keep going. I have other books that I borrowed that I could read if the ending isn't worth it.

Honestly, the main character is grating and not compelling at all. He starts depressed as fuck, somehow gets better, then gets depressed again. All of his moping - about Julia, his parents, about something being missing, it's all just so annoying. The author gives me no reason to feel sympathetic for him.

The parts I liked were the parts where >!the creature thing!< showed up in class, they discuss what wizards do in the real world as jobs, and the story about >!Miakovski (sp?)!<.

But then so much of the other parts are tough to get into. It seems like the author wanted to a wizarding school but then half-assed everything. He describes the classes for like a year and then we get no glimpse into the lessons again until year four. The competition thing they do is such a throwaway plot. They >!win!< their internal competition and there are no stakes at all. Then the international thing is shoehorned in there. Not like Harry Potter competitions which actually had stakes. Then of course the romance plot which was ok for a while but now with the >!infidelity from both!< has just become tedious and uninteresting.

The story is also so predictable. They go into such a long discussion of Fillory, it was obvious what was going to happen. Same when Fog explains that there are >!alternate worlds!<. The shit with Julia was also predictable. Now they are all so excited for >!Fillory!< and it seems like they are setting up to make it to be a disappointment.

Basically, I just want to know if the >!Fillory!< part of the book picks up and becomes interesting. At least does it provide some stakes or good character development? Does a cool twist happen that is worth sticking around for? Or should I go to the next book? Thank you.

Posted Oct 10, 2019, 1:07 AM UTC

1023
dragon_morganReading Champion 2017-18•

I loved the books but they are very divisive. If you don’t like the characters now you probably won’t find they improve much. There is excellent character development but a lot of frustration getting there. You might enjoy watching the tv show, it’s available on Netflix.

13
Casiell89•

it’s available on Netflix

In which country? I would like to watch it, but I haven't seen it in Poland, it's on Amazon here instead

2
Varathien•

I read the whole trilogy and would recommend just quitting now.

10
Huy_Ngo•

I've finished the trilogy, and tbh it was hard to. The books are kind of mediocre. If you're looking for great books, they're not worth reading. Though some parts are interesting, I'd say about half of each book made me sleep.

7
Built-on-Neon-89•

You made it through about 33% more than I did.

6
ExiledinElysium•

I don't know that the end of the first book is worth it, but I found the other two books to be worth it. The trilogy as a whole is one of my all-time favorite stories.

5
MusubiKazesaru•

If you're not hooked by now then you probably won't care for the rest.

5
obedientenby•

I think it ultimately is going to depend on whether or not you identify or empathize with the characters. I absolutely loved all three books (and the tv series). But if you're struggling and not feeling drawn in by fillory then perhaps they aren't for you.

4
briargreyReading Champion 2017-18, Worldbuilders•

So I found the first book to be mostly meh but in the final third, it picked up for me and compelled me to read book 2. I finished the trilogy and it was okay but I felt it could have been better. It definitely never felt "magical" to me. Now, I did very much enjoy some of the Julia pieces and the non-school way to learn magic and show how good you were. I watched some of the TV series and they changed the parts I liked the most unfortunately.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Dred_Deal•

I watch the tv show and really like it. Listened to 1st book until soon after they left school completely lost interest. Idk how they drank so much.

3
daavor•

I genuinely felt like the show came from a place of liking the material it was referencing, while still poking fun at/ twisting it. I felt much less like that about the books, it more felt like twisting and poking fun at something mean spiritedly.

3
emailanimalReading Champion 2017-18•

Been there, done that... Or something. What I like about The Magicians is actually the last third of the book. Once Quentin & Co graduate, the narrative shifts gears, and, in fact, actual plot appears. But what I liked the most about that last part of the book, is that it became a true ensemble cast story. A weird, and somewhat depressing one, but nevertheless. And true ensemble cast stories are really rare and far in between.

So, perhaps that last third of the book will be more to your liking? But it is also possible that it will not be. Depends on what you are looking for.

3
kawaii_renekton•

There are gazillion great Fantasy books, if you don't like one try one of the others. You don't have to conform to the taste of others.

For the record I did finish it but did not read the rest of the series.

3
botlaOP•

Yeah this doesn’t really make sense. I’m not trying to conform to others’ tastes. I’m trying to get people’s reactions to the end so I can make my own informed decision on whether to proceed. Asking for feedback =! Conformance.

1
jamesmrj•

I have enjoyed the show, but the books, not so much.

The books just felt like an depressing, R-rated mashup of Harry Potter and The Chronicles of Narnia.

3
MilesZSWorldbuilders•

I hated almost every character in book one, but kept reading and really enjoyed the series. If you tend to need a character to root for, I think you should stop. If the world building stuff is still interesting for you, keep reading, maybe!

3
Lorica_authorWriter Anne C. Miles•

I finished the book but moved on after. Not my cup of tea. If I had it to do over I'd quit

2
easypunk21•

I finished the second book and quit. It never quite rises beyond above average fan fiction and the characters stay annoying and never grow. Tried really hard to like it, read two whole books, would not recommend.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SlouchyGuy•

Read until the end of the first book, some people start to like it. I didn't, didn't make much difference for me, although I skimmed through the rest and it was more of the same

2
UndyingSwordSage•

It's a sort of weirdly grimdark deconstruction of Harry Potter and Narnia, imo. I didn't enjoy the books much, but the TV series plays the tropes more straight and doesn't feel quite as bleak.

If you want an adult Harry Potter that doesn't feel all depressing, I'd recommend Mage Errant, Arcane Ascension, or Mother of Learning instead.

2
konekokiara•

My friends and I still have this debate lol. I’ve seen the show (in fact rewatching right now lol) and haven’t read the books. One friend has read and watched and said the books aren’t worth it. Another has read them but couldn’t get into watching them. Apparently the second is more about what happens to Julia and the first season is like a mash up of the first two books to my understanding.

1
pwmcc107•

I made it through the trilogy, but wasn’t a huge fan. The first book was decent, but the following books diminished in quality and the story really started to drag. Unless you have lots of free-time and are willing to spend it reading below average books, I think I’d throw in the towel. You made it pretty far

1
Notlad0122•

Just watch the show it blows the novels out of the water. I stopped reading mid way through the second book

1