r/poker•
simonico

Does there need to be a "smoking gun"?

Discussion

I've heard suggestions that Postle might get away with it due to the absence of a "smoking gun", i.e. actual direct evidence showing him cheating. Is this really necessary, though?

People are convicted of crimes all the time on the basis of strong circumstantial evidence (fingerprints, DNA, etc.); while the law places a high burden of proof on the prosecution, at a certain point we have to accept that this threshold has been met. If your DNA is all over the crime scene and you've got the victim's blood in your car, you're probably going to prison, even though there is a tiny (maybe 1 in a few billion) probability that you're innocent. Why can't this standard apply to analysing cheating in poker? Postle's miraculous winrate over a solid sample size appears, in itself, to be a "DNA all over the crime scene"-type scenario. Couple this with the extremely suspicious behaviour and the likelihood of consistently winning pots with mathematically terrible preflop play and I don't see how any prosecutor could fail to secure a conviction.

Any legal experts out there who can chime in?

Also, could we get "Mike Postle" added as a flair option? Thanks.

Posted Oct 10, 2019, 11:20 AM UTC

132
Loading comments…