Nina - My Case for Magic Meister vs. Summoner
So, I make no secret of the fact that Nina is my favorite character. I think she's super versatile. My current investment with Nina is 95 3/5/3/2/2. I'm posting this in hopes more people enjoy Nina! I feel like people try to use her as Summoner and find her underwhelming, so they stop using her.
Gumi ships her pretty hard with the Summoner job as her main. Her Babel War Arts skill, VCR weapon, and Wrath gate upgrade all provide goodies for her Summoner job. However, there is a major elephant in the room that keeps her Summoner job from being worth using: cast speed.
Prior to enlightenment, her Summoner job was not worth using, in my opinion. The HP/AGI was also far below what I'd even consider "playable" in EX/multiplayer content. Enlightenment does fix this in my opinion.
With her memento and Wrath Gate, her Summoner job is finally worth using; and with er goodies from Babel War Arts and VCR, its actually a viable option alongside Magic Meister.
Below are some charts I apparently wasted my effort on. Please do not focus your comments on whether or not you like my formulae or math or whatever.
Default Cast Times
https://i.imgur.com/H14ojhn.png
We can see from this chart that you are unlikely to ever catch enemies in the Summoner job's AoE spells. Magic Meister's AoEs, on the other hand, are instant cast. Oracle Ratty still won't perform exceptionally well, despite its great cast speed.If this is your setup, do not use Summoner, in my opinion! Use Magic Meister.
Cast Time with Leader Skill and Zero-Break Memento
https://i.imgur.com/TYliUc5.png
With the leader skill and the memento, we're finally starting to see less pathetic cast times; however you'd still be hard-pressed to catch anyone in Crusade Judge or Dark Flare. If you max the Wrath gate, the upgraded Call to the Crusade is more average in its ability to hit multiple enemies. I would still use Magic Meister if you haven't maxed the Wrath gate.
Cast Time with Leader Skill and Max-Break Memento
https://i.imgur.com/UY7MkiI.png
Everything is tolerable across the board here. It is really up to you at this point which job you'd run. Her Oracle Ratty is super reliable at this point. Again I would still use Magic Meister if you haven't maxed the Wrath gate. That cast time bump on her AoE from Wrath gate is pretty much what seals the deal, here.
Cast Time with Leader Skill, Max-Break Memento, and Shell Charge Passive
https://i.imgur.com/lrml9Eu.png
Cast times are great across the board like this... but you lose Sorcery Pair! Uhg! That's a huge drop in MATK. And you're surely not going to want to drop her Tir Na Nog Wind passive, either, because her niche is "deleting dark units", as another poster has pointed out in the past. The maxed out Sloth Gate upgrades Tir Na Nog Wind in a pretty deal-breaking way, too, giving Nina her above average AGI as a Summoner (mine has 163 with the White Plushie, Maxed Memento, maxed Sloth gate, and her VCR weapon).
Hopefully people found this enjoyable and not just tedious!
Posted Oct 11, 2019, 3:27 PM UTC · edited
I've only looked at the first chart so far, but unfortunately I can say you did the math incorrectly.
Let's take a cast speed of 300 for example, such as base Call of the Crusade in your first table. It gains 30 cast time per clock tick, and will fire off when its CT is 100+, which will be in 4 clock ticks, not 3.3. You can't exactly break it down into partial clock ticks.
On that 4th clock tick, it will have reached 120 cast time, so an excess of 20 over the needed amount. That means it will resolve before characters that have less than 120 CT on that tick.
So if for example a target has 190 Agi, you won't hit them if they reach 100 CT within 3 clock ticks, meaning that if they have 43+ CT now, they'll act first. If they have 42 CT, then after 3 clock ticks they'll have 99 CT, and on the fourth clock tick they'll have 118 CT, which will mean their turn comes after your spell resolves. So in short you can hit someone with 190 Agi and 42 CT, which isn't the same as the maximum 37 CT you listed in your table.
Man you went full retard on me. I don’t understand anything you said. But it sounds great!
So you know that Agility determines turn order/rate; for example, say if unit A has 105 Agi and unit B has 100 Agi, unit A is effectively 5% faster and will get its first turn before B does.
The way that it's calculated is that unit A will get 10.5 CT (charge time, which is one-tenth of its Agi) per clock tick, while unit B gets 10.0 CT per clock tick, and a unit gets its turn when it has 100+ CT. A unit's current CT is the third number displayed when looking at it (after current HP, and current jewels).
Clock ticks cannot be broken down into fractions: 10.5 CT per clock tick means strictly that, it does not mean 1.05 CT per 1/10th of a clock tick (that's not a thing). So starting from 0, after one clock tick unit A will have 10.5 CT, after two clock ticks it will have 21.0 CT, etc. After 10 clock ticks, Unit A will have 105.0 CT and unit B will have 100.0 CT. Now that one or more units have 100+ CT, this is when the game will let a unit take its turn; even though both units A and B have 100+ CT, unit A has 5 excess CT over the 100 needed while Unit B has 0 excess CT, so unit A gets priority and therefore it gets to go before unit B does. If unit A takes both a move and an action its CT is reduced by 100, so it will have 5 CT left towards its next turn.
Skills with a Cast Time also follow the exact same rules, with their Cast Speed determining the amount of CT they gain per clock tick (starting from 0), and resolving when it should be its turn. A spell with 300 Cast Speed gains 30.0 CT per clock tick, so it would resolve after 4 clock ticks, when it would have 120.0 CT (so it would land before anyone else who reached 100-119.99 CT during that clock tick).
If a unit has cast time reduction, such as the usual -33 from Swift Charge, then it means the spell needs 67+ CT before it resolves instead of 100+. So in this case a spell with 300 Cast Speed needs three clock ticks, at which point it will have 90/67 CT, or 23 excess CT, with regards to determining priority.
Does that help?
Yes strangely! I tend to miss a lot of my matks. But now knowing that a unit gains 10% of agi per clock tick(assuming a clock tick is, every time a unit takes action= 1 clock tick) I can plan those long cast!
Maybe I'll reply once more with a more practical example.
Say you have a Sage with 130 Agi, and the enemy has 110 Agi. You start the stage, your Sage goes first. On your Sage's turn you look at the enemy's CT: they have 88/100.
Knowing what I've mentioned (they'll be gaining 11 CT per clock tick), you can calculate that they will have 99 CT on the next clock tick, and 110 CT on the clock tick after that. So in two clock ticks it will be their turn, with 10 excess.
Which means if you were to cast a basic Cross spell, which has a cast speed of 600, it will reach 120 CT in two clock ticks, and thus it will resolve before the enemy gets its turn (so you can reliably hit them). But if you were to use a Mega spell with a cast speed of 350, it takes 3 clock ticks to reach 100 CT; the enemy will move before your Mega spell lands.
Even if you had Swift Charge, then after two clock ticks, your Mega spell would have 70/67; this is only 3 excess, which is less than the enemy's 10 excess at this time, so the enemy will still move before a Mega spell lands.
So you realize you should use a Cross spell and not a Mega.
Clock ticks aren't related to actions. Clock ticks are calculated in the background, counting up whenever it's not a unit's turn.
For example, at the start of a stage, everyone starts with 0 CT, so if there were only Unit A and B as in my previous example, the game will start calculating how much CT everyone should have: after 1 clock tick, unit A will have 10.5 CT and unit B will have 10 CT, but no one is at 100+, so it counts the next clock tick and Unit A has 21 CT and unit B has 20 CT. Of course the game doesn't make you just wait while it's counting, but that is essentially what it is doing to determine who goes next; it keeps counting upwards until at least one unit has 100+CT, which in this case will be 10 clock ticks.
Then it's unit A's turn (Unit A now has 105 CT and Unit B has 100 CT). So after Unit A takes an action, it is Unit B's turn; the clock hasn't changed since there are still units with 100+CT resolving their turns.
Then after Unit B takes an action, no one will have 100+CT, so the clock ticks start occurring again until someone has 100+CT.
[deleted]
The game works in chunks though, I’m not assuming anything; I’m telling you what Gumi programmed. If a 190 agi character has 99 CT, the next time the game checks whether it's their turn or not is when they have 118 CT. There will not be any moment when they have any number between 100 and 117. CT does not rise as gradually as you’re assuming.
[deleted]
Sorry, you're incorrect. If you were to do such an experiment you'd see that it works out as I said.
To get 100 CT, a 125 Agi unit will need 8 clock ticks (gaining 12.5 CT a turn). A 143 Agi unit will need 7 clock ticks. A 167 Agi unit will need 6 clock ticks. If you bring two characters within the same breakpoints, say a 125 Agi unit and a 142 Agi unit (both require 8 clock ticks), then when it's the 142 Agi unit's turn, if you look at the other's CT, the 125 Agi unit will also have 100 CT, not 88 or so.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1MHE1To79hZEBsSxUd4d6pfYEgPGYbZSle9Ye3LZ8XLs/edit
CT Planning document, it's not that long and worth a quick read
But shaiandra is correct, the game uses 100 clock ticks ... there is a spreadsheet calculator in the CT planning doc (helpful info guide link) that you could use as a starting point to make the calculations (i'll guess your CT numbers are off by about 1 to 3 in either direction).
And yes, lots of jobs suck if you are trying to solo something (or play MP with 3 random folks), summoner is one of the worst due to long cast times; but my ramses can't seem to kill stuff without every fn levi and sol getting in the way of a rudra cross either.
Bring a chrono, overclock nina and the instant cast/retargeting of crusade judge will destroy dark targets, or deneb with hexagram to boost cast times. The 100% hit for magic evade targets is situationally very useful (looking at you wag's).