ContaPoints’ Guide to Trickle Up Linguistics

Posted Oct 12, 2019, 6:47 PM UTC

Posted Oct 12, 2019, 6:47 PM UTC
Took a linguistics class at uni, this is a real observed phenomenon
do u happen to have any sources/papers on it? i've looked a bit but can't find much
Sure! The concept is called covert prestige. The example given is of Black and other African-american dialects of English being adopted by upper classes, but the concept seems to apply here.
Related is linguistic appropriation, but that is a subset of cultural appropriation more broadly
Huh, TIL.
Do you think this maybe relates at all to names and all that, that Freakonomics talked about? I can't remember all of it, but I remember some about seeing how some names will go from being upper to lower class, and vise versa, both from one class trying to appropriate the other.
Yeah, fascinating stuff.
Upper class names are popular a decade before they become generally popular, suggesting that style "trickles down" from the elite, who liked things (or at least baby names) 'before they were cool'.
Is it? It seems like cis black high schoolers invent way more words than queer PoC. Although, per capita, queer PoC might come out on top.
Well, the diagram that is presented in video is not a figure from a scientific article and is made in jest. But it is based on a real phenomenon.
I still remember a drunk white girl calling me the n word even tho I may be the whitest person on the planet
I got into a facebook argument and the guy called me the n word. Hard r. I was like "You can see my profile photo, you know that you're literally incorrect." So then he called me a f*ggot.
And I was like, hey, at least you're right this time.
There's nothing correct about calling black people that word either IMHO.
I’m not american but
Maybe blame music for that 😅😅😅
Every normie white girl I know just listens to boring mainstream trap. I'm not a boomer. I actually like some trap
I don’t even know trap apart from the slur. But you’re cool !
Trap is a subgenre of rap that originated in Atlanta and is probably the biggest and most lucrative musical trend in the US. As with any genre there’s great stuff and awful stuff that comes from trap.
It has no connection with the slur, by the way. Dangerous neighborhoods in Atlanta are/were referred to as “traps/the trap,” which I believe is a commentary on the cycle of poverty in the inner city
Yeah it's an unrelated meaning of the term. Trap is slang for drug dealing. A trap house is a place where drug dealers make and sell drugs. The Fetty Wap song Trap Queen is about the narrator's female drug dealing partner.
It there's one thing I can't stand ............. it's tra-a-a-a-psssssss.
no.
I don't know how to react to this that doesn't contribute to the cycle of linguistic gentrification AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH
I mean read me queen
Isn't it kind of different from gentrification though? Seems to me like more like appreciative chamaleonic mirroring than intentional reappropriation and exclusion of the original. To me it comes from a way more positive root
Then late night hosts and Fortune 500 middle managers trying to make their marketing presentations sound "cool", then presidential candidates.
I think the interplay of language can be a bit more complicated. Hilton Als wrote a great book called White Girls, that's a collection of essays about race, gender, identity, and privilege, that I think relates to this topic of trickle-up linguistics. According to the author Michael Jackson and Truman capote could qualify as white girls. Being a white girl isn't just about being born in a woman's body, it can be a state of mind, a way of acting and the pose of privilege. Some quotes from Als include, “A number of black gay men began to refer to Michael Jackson as ‘she’ and, eventually, ‘a white woman’ – one of the slurs they feared most, for what could be worse than being called that which you were not, could never be?” and “There’s the bizarre fact that queerness reads, even to some black gay men themselves, as a kind of whiteness.” The book is pretty interesting and hard to explain, but super interesting.
Woke is a funny example of this pattern (although I don't think it was a queer term in particular).
too fuckin accurate