DM's of reddit what was the funniest natural 20 you have ever gotten?

Posted Oct 14, 2019, 5:16 PM UTC

3113
Mostlyaverageish•

My party insisted on investigating a random door. It was a random closed door. I put it there entirely for aesthetic reasons. It went into an empty room. It was not even locked. I told the party this and they still insisted in all investigating it by different means. One rolled a 20 on his investigation. So I quickly googled a wooden door from home depot and just started reading the descriptions reviews and installation instructions for it.

17
Wytewalker311•

From a player- natural 20 on a dex check from a ranger to specifically make 12 prostitutes orgasm simultaneously so that the bard could hear downstairs. (There was an argument and a bet with alot of gold on the table)

From myself- a natural 20 as a wearwolf wizard to slap my penis on the eyesocket of a charging zombie minatour after passing a check to dodge its attack.

13
[deleted]•

[removed]

5
nannerdooodle•

I have several, but this one happened a few weeks ago. One of the PCs is a gnome druid who somehow became the leader of the party. The (very low level) party was fighting some thugs and their boss and this PC had started directly in the middle of the fight next to the top of a staircase (effectively blocking half the party from helping), and then couldn't get out of it due to fear of opportunity attacks and a very low AC. He'd already been downed and healed a few times, and decided it was finally time to move out of the way. I reminded him of all the opportunity attacks. He said "Do your worst. You can't touch this!" I rolled a Nat 20, but then rolled the lowest possible damage so he still had 1HP. He said "See? I can't lose!" I rolled for the second thug. Another Nat 20. Max damage. Literally 1 point away from insta-death. The party still makes fun of him.

11
GustavoAlex7789•

A player had a drunk dwarf who got arrested and wanted to escape. He got a Nat20 broke the shackles, jump on a donkey and escaped passed out riding a donkey into the forest.

5
KYLO-WHO•

not a dm, but the dm asked me to roll a d20 with advantage, first roll 1, second roll 20, great you manage to remain hidden in the crowd of 900 people naked and covered in dirt the people who did notice you thought you were on magic mushrooms and left you alone.

4
pussypoppi•

on the contrary, a natural crit 1. slight of hand check to steal [character]'s heart. they ended up hating each other.

3
DamianSmoothly•

The team had come across a garbage heap making a suspicious amount of movement. To try and lure what was in it out, both the fighter and the bard made performance checks to play the flute and sing, respectively. They both rolled natural 20's, and made the most melodious song imaginable together. Oh, and they got the old, lonely wolf searching for food to perk its head out of the trash, so, mission acomplished, I guess.

3
AeMasterClasher•

I don’t even know what that is but upvote

2
BigGaeFurry•

Dungeons and Dragons

3
AeMasterClasher•

I literally play that didn’t recognize at the time

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TitaniaOre•

Our paladin who has a over 20AC when receiving an attack joked "it's fine I could take anything" me rolled NAT 20, the attack rolls were the max as well paladin was KO'd it was both funny and kinda sad.

1
Poeteca•

Had a player want to change characters, but wanted to have his current character killed off to leave no loose ends. Ended up instigating PvP between him and a war cleric, the player planned on putting up a fight and was willing to put the war cleric, but the war cleric got nat 20 on guiding bolt instant giving the player before he could even act.

1