Which Book Title Schema Works Better?

Question

Hi Everyone,

I’m a fantasy writer hoping to become published in the next few years. In the meantime, I'm posting my two WIPs on Wattpad and Royal Road. I’ve been experimenting with different title schemas for the series, but sometimes it’s difficult to measure actual reader preferences just by randomly changing them.

In 2015 and 2016, my book titles were named after locations from the series.

For example:

Book 1: Whitecliff Academy

Book 2: Dragonshard

These started to feel unimaginative to me, especially Book 1 because the market is flooded with titles that include “Academy”. I also wasn’t sure I couldn’t keep up the locations theme forever.

After that, I changed the schema to reflect different orders of the magic users (Redeemer, Justicar, and Sanctifier) These also reference the main character of said book.

The Lost Redeemer

The Justicar’s Heir

The Crowned Sanctifier

I was happy with these for a while because they fit the title pattern of a lot of classic fantasy books. (ie: half the things by Sanderson, Rothfuss, Tolkien, GRRM, etc.) However, I recently did an experiment on Royal Road where I dropped the individual book titles and and labeled the entire work “Aeonica” (the series name) Views and rating increased dramatically with the shorter title, which gave me doubts about this system.

So the third schema I’ve considered lately is using a one word title for each book that reflects the central focus of that book. Will Wight’s Cradle series was my inspiration for this idea, along with some other books by Sanderson (Skyward, Warbreaker, Oathbringer)

It might look something like this:

Whitecliff

Etherfall

As a potential fantasy reader, does any one of those sets stand out as better? Or does anyone have feedback as a fellow writer? I realize that reader preferences might be balanced, which is okay too. But if there’s a dramatic difference in preferences, I’d much rather know now before anything is published.

TL;DR: As a potential fantasy reader, which of the top three title schemas works best for you?

Thanks!

Posted Oct 17, 2019, 12:15 AM UTC · edited

99
Rysanthemums•

Personally, I like the second schema. It makes me curious just what those titles mean.

6
corpingtonThe Annals of Amexya•

I second this

6
silvanthato•

Third it

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
fantasy_advice•

The second schema is by far the most interesting to me. "The Lost Redeemer" in particular is good. I don't think that titles named after places that have no meaning or association to first time readers are a good idea. This may work better for later books in a series, especially if the place was important in the preceding books. The one word titles seem to suffer from the same problem -- they're devoid of meaning if you don't know the significance of those words within the story. This could work if you choose words that have a more distinct and interesting meaning.

4
Cuilpen•

A good question! Personally, none of these schemas are very compelling to me. I think #2 is very overdone in fantasy, and while there are plenty of great works with titles like these, they never strike me as interesting because they are formulaic.

As someone who knows nothing about your world, "The Lost Redeemer" is just gibberish to me. I certainly would not guess that the title had anything to do with a class of magic user, and even if I did, I'm frankly not sure I would care. Further, it doesn't have that acoustic quality that makes it roll off the tongue and easy to remember.

Though it's hard to put a blanket statement out there about what kind of titles I like, I'd say, generally, that I appreciate titles that evoke feelings of action. As opposed to the titles you have listed, which are just noun phases. Static objects.

I also appreciate titles that make me look back at them at the end of the book (or at a critical moment in the story) and make me say, "oh, that's what it means!" Titles with lots of powerful symbolic meaning. That's my jam.

If you want to cater more towards the tastes of people like me (there's others like me, right?), try experimenting with verbs and other words that sound dynamic, powerful, or unique. Spend some time improving the acoustic quality of your titles, make them easier to stick in the mind as memorable.

All that being said, I would probably agree with others that #2 has the most potential of the ones here as they are. Though it's not anything to write home about, the naming methodology is tried and true. Still, I advocate finding a better way to verbalize the unique voice of your story. Best of luck!

3
Penfragon•

I feel like #2 is an oversaturated trope as well, that I've almost completely lost interest in. I prefer #3, followed by #1 - both of which give me a sense I will be exploring a story that is one part of a greater world, which is what I'm looking for.

3
malpasplace•

Placenames don't do it for me unless they are really evocative on the theme of the story. I find they work better for me for games than novels. (A question of where am I the player going to be vs. Who is the character or story I am following.)

Dark Gloom Academy tells me something probable about the characters. Wuthering Heights is oddly evocative, same with Bleak House. But those really set tone of the story.

I find Character evocative an easier invitation to what a story might be.

Whitecliff and Etherfall I find perfectly good names within a story, but don't have that grand evocation of tone to invite me in otherwise as a title. All the character based one's made me wonder, and in a good way.

2
Kevronium•

Maybe try something like Aeonica: The whitecliffs and Aeonica: The Etherfall. The aeonica part ties all the books together and the second part gives each title individual meaning.

2
newAprilAccount•

I like the placenames best. the others may be too confusing if i haven’t read the story

2